Can You Still Love Them? Or Do You Have to Hate Them?

What happens when a fan favorite puts on a new uniform?

As Green Bay Packers fans, we are very accustomed to seeing our favorite players put on a different uniform once their time in green and gold is over. Rarely in the Packers' history have these great players ended their careers with the Packers. We loved them for so many years as their play made us cheer, but how's a fan supposed to feel once they leave Green Bay and head to another team? 

The Packers have a long list of legends who went elsewhere to finish their careers. Jim Taylor finished with the Saints, Herb Adderley in Dallas, Reggie White in Carolina, Brett Favre in Minnesota, and even Vince Lombardi was in Washington to finish his career before he passed away. It's become even more common in the last fifteen years, with both GMs Ted Thompson and Brian Gutekunst seemingly knowing when the best time to move on from a great player has been. For the most part, they've been correct. Greg Jennings, James Jones, Jordy Nelson, and Clay Matthews were all great players in green and gold, but they seemingly fizzled after maybe a year or two of success post-Packers. 

When these players depart from Green Bay, sometimes it's ugly, and sometimes it's admirable. Of course, we know how the departure of Brett Favre turned out. There was no love lost between the Packers and the old gunslinger. Favre made it clear that he wanted to make the Packers pay for their decision to trade him to the New York Jets in favor of starting Aaron Rodgers. And it divided the fanbase. Many vowed to never support the Packers until both Mike McCarthy and Ted Thompson were gone, some said they'd never support the team ever again, and others acknowledged that Brett Favre was just one player in the storied history of the franchise, and stuck with the Packers. I can't help but wonder where some of those pro-Favre fans are today and how they fared when the Packers and Aaron Rodgers were World Champions while Favre was hanging up his cleats for good.

Did they ever come back? Or did they keep their promise and not return until Mike McCarthy was fired in 2018? We'll likely never know for sure.

In the last four offseasons, Packer fans have had to wave goodbye to a few fan favorites in Davante Adams, Aaron Rodgers, Aaron Jones, and AJ Dillon. The first three could absolutely be defined as "Lambeau Legends" and will undoubtedly have their day being inducted into the Packers' Hall of Fame. One will likely have their number retired. But right now, they're playing for different teams. How's a fan supposed to react? Are they the enemy now? Or are they still friends?

Friend, or Foe?

In the NFL, players leave teams for a multitude of reasons. Not all of them necessarily mean there was bad blood. When contracts expire, and a player can make several million dollars more signing with another team than he can staying with his current team, it's hard to blame a player for leaving. These things happen under the salary cap or when another team just values that player's services a little bit more. You could call this the case with former Packers' running back, Aaron Jones. The Packers set a price they were willing to pay him, but he could get better elsewhere, and he did. It's hard to fault a player for that. Except for when they did what Aaron Jones ended up doing in that situation, but we'll get to that later. 

What about trades? What happens when these players are traded away to another team? That would probably depend on the situation. If a player demands a trade out of Green Bay for no real decent reason, it's hard to have any love for them. One might think back to the early 2000s when former wide receiver Javon Walker and former cornerback Mike McKenzie each wanted out of Green Bay simply because they wanted more money right then and there and wouldn't honor their current contract. Both were good players, were favorites at the time, but they burned all bridges, seemingly putting their pocketbooks before anything else. 

Those are situations where you can't blame a fan for their dislike. But what about an Aaron Rodgers trade where the team feels it's gone as far as it can with Rodgers and is ready for life after? Or Davante Adams, where it's reported that the Packers offered Adams a good contract, but he just wanted to move on somewhere he felt he had better stability, or was better set up for future success. There doesn't seem to be bad blood, but the trade stings nonetheless. Do you hold a grudge against that player? Or do you remain rather neutral, considering that's what the team-to-player relationship seemed to be? 

You can feel a little betrayed as a fan in these situations, and that's okay. Especially when you have to endure watching a player that was once a favorite of yours start babbling on about how their new team has the best fans and how that city has the best amenities. We're looking at you, AJ Dillon, choosing Wawa over Kwik Trip. You were given the keys to a Wisconsin County, and you pull this? For shame!

But of course, there is that dreaded caveat. When that player goes to a division rival. Suddenly, all bets are off. They now play for a team that the Packers have to face twice a year, and their success can be counterintuitive to the Packers' success. You might like that player as a human being, but when it comes to game time, you can't help but want them to fail. They went to that rival; that was their choice, and now we don't want them to be successful at all. Of course, we've seen this a few times lately, primarily with Brett Favre, Greg Jennings, Za'Darius Smith, and Aaron Jones going to Minnesota. Three out of those four admitted to wanting to play for the Vikings to get back at the Packers. When that's the case, as a fan, it is perfectly acceptable for there to be a bit of bad blood come game day. 

When it all comes down to it, though, there's no reason to gatekeep. Fan how you want to fan. It may be hard for some of us to cheer on a former fan favorite in a new uniform, but if it's easy for you, do it. As long as it doesn't interfere with your fandom of the Green Bay Packers, of course!

 

 

PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO OUR CHEESEHEAD NATION WEEKLY NEWSLETTER HERE.

__________________________

Greg Meinholz is a lifelong devoted Packer fan. A contributor to CheeseheadTV as well as PackersTalk. Follow him on Twitter @gmeinholz and Bluesky @gmeinholz.bsky.social for Packers commentary, random humor, beer endorsements, and occasional Star Wars and Marvel ramblings.

__________________________

NFL Categories: 
0 points
 

Comments (30)

Fan-Friendly This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.
splitpea1's picture

May 27, 2025 at 10:11 am

It's all just business. The organization should be trying to do what is best for the team, and the player is trying to do what is best for him or his family. Rare is the situation where even a decorated player stays with the same team throughout his whole career, because there's usually someone willing to take a chance on an aging star, hoping there's a little left in the tank. So there's no need to love, hate, or dwell on the matter and personality. Just move on and go forward.

0 points
0
0
SicSemperTyrannis's picture

May 28, 2025 at 05:31 am

What's this? Rationality on the interwebs?!? Is that even legal?

0 points
0
0
Cheezehead72's picture

May 27, 2025 at 10:20 am

I really never had issues with an ex Packer putting on another uniform. I always thought it was a good thing because that means the Packers are developing players.

I did not like Favre wearing purple because, I will keep it short, I believe he orchestrated that whole move to the Vikings just to play the Packers twice and beat all 32 teams.

I was happy to see Rodgers go. I was only not happy because it was a year too late but what can you do. I liked seeing him in green.

I did not like to see Jones go because I liked him as a player and a person. I wish he would have signed a better contract with a different team.

Adams I was happy for because he got what he wanted and we got a good trade.

Oh I could go all day but I won't. The one thing I really do not like to see is our good players wearing that hideous purple.

0 points
0
0
GregC's picture

May 27, 2025 at 10:24 am

The first time they get their picture taken in the purple uniform, it's like seeing a picture of a once respected person wearing an orange prison jumpsuit.

0 points
0
0
GregC's picture

May 27, 2025 at 10:22 am

I'm mostly indifferent about Packer players who go to other teams. I never get very attached to players as individuals anyway. I don't like it when they go to a rival just to play against the Packers though. These guys make millions of dollars because fans are so passionate, and I think it's disrespectful for them to turn against the fans of their former team. It's not a classy move.

0 points
0
0
Vachio's picture

May 27, 2025 at 10:33 am

I'm a fan of the game, not just of "my" team. My hierarchy of fandom goes like this: 1 - The Packers, 2 - Individual Players, 3 - The NFC North as a whole, 4 - Anyone playing against the Cowboys.

Earl Campbell was the reason I even got interested in football at all. I loved watching LT play. Also Barry Sanders and Walter Payton. Richard Dent, Ronnie Lott, and Jerry Ball were some other favorites. I'd cheer for all those guys unless they were playing the Packers.

I still enjoy watching the Packers legends play even when they they play somewhere else at the end of their careers.

0 points
0
0
LambeauPlain's picture

May 27, 2025 at 10:38 am

When a player leaves via free agency or an outright release, it concerns me very little. Either they are not worth a second K (Myers), are chasing money and not a Championship (likely Alexander), or are a disgruntled team cancer (Marty Bennett). There are always a few players who get away too easy...Casey Hayward was one...Sitton another. Ted barely tried to keep Hayward at a time when the CB position was in bad shape. Sitton's release was a head scratcher.

Trades are rare for the Packers. Rodgers, Favre and Adams have been the marquee deals that also attracted little to no attention from me. The "green grass" those players were expecting did give them gold, but mostly burnt lawn in terms of playoffs and Championships. Favre nearly got it done with the Ugly Purple, but it was another INT to end his career with this 3rd team.

Over time the loyalty in the NFL has waned. There is so much churn every season now...so exiting players don't affect me much. NFL...Not For Long...requires an urgent mindset and "next man up"...and outstanding coaching and front office.

0 points
0
0
TarynsEyes's picture

May 27, 2025 at 10:49 am

I cheer for the team, not the individual player, though I did have a username that showed a bias for Rodgers, but when he left, so did that username.

The days of being loyal to a player has long passed, as it's hardly ever reciprocated back from the player today, to the team, and especially the fans. When a player leaves and then says the new team is the best place he has ever been associated with, even to placate the new, it's a hurtful thing to say to those who gave so much.

I don't care what a player does for himself and family, that's his concern, I care what he does for the team I cheer for, and when they leave, they leave without a care from me.

0 points
0
0
Doug_In_Sandpoint's picture

May 27, 2025 at 10:50 am

At the end of the day, I’m cheering for laundry. Only the color of the jersey matters.

0 points
0
0
Packers0808's picture

May 27, 2025 at 10:59 am

To be expected, it is a game of attrition, after all.

0 points
0
0
Leatherhead's picture

May 27, 2025 at 11:07 am

Dead to Me. I root for laundry.

0 points
0
0
T7Steve's picture

May 27, 2025 at 12:30 pm

Didn't he used to coach the Cowboys?

0 points
0
0
SicSemperTyrannis's picture

May 28, 2025 at 07:20 am

Don Henley wrote a song about him, how dirty he is.

0 points
0
0
davekenya's picture

May 27, 2025 at 11:28 am

Interesting that most responders here are in the 'cheer for the team, not the player' camp. Either that represents the large majority...or simply those who (are here) and respond. Free agency has meant that fans know their player investment would be to the player and not the team as 'churning' happens. I admit getting a bit attached to players and invested them. It's hard when they leave (GB); occasionally I follow them on their new team, but that wains quickly over time.

Reggie White is mentioned in this article as a legend leaving GB for Carolina. No mention of GB taking him from Philly. If we don't like a player leaving us, we should feel equally 'guilty' when a player joins GB and their fans are upset. It goes both ways.

0 points
0
0
SicSemperTyrannis's picture

May 28, 2025 at 07:22 am

Never guilty for acquiring good players, especially when Gutey steals them.

0 points
0
0
Brewcity_BearsFan's picture

May 27, 2025 at 11:41 am

I like to see the guys I cheered for, continue to succeed. Even if they don't.

I know this is a Packers page, but I will use my preferred team as the example.

Steve McMichael and Julius Peppers both made their way north. I was pretty young when McMichael made the move. The Peppers move stung, but I blamed Chicago for that.

I cheered for Devin Hester in Atlanta. I am happy for David Montgomery in Detroit (again that falls on Chicago management). I felt Matt Forte still had a good year or two in him when he went to the Jets.

Gregg Olsen traded to Carolina (management again. Boy there is a theme there).

I did literally "LOL" about Bennett to the Packers though. He had worn out his stay in Chicago, and any Bears fan could see how that would end.

0 points
0
0
T7Steve's picture

May 27, 2025 at 12:38 pm

Didn't he used to play for the Packers?

Thanks for the link.

Actually, I hope everything works out and we keep/get a Pro-Bowl CB with a good attitude back.

0 points
0
0
stockholder's picture

May 27, 2025 at 01:41 pm

Regardless how most feel.
It's still about the power and control
over the players.
We forget the nice things players did.
And focus on opinions and the obstacles
that management faced.
Their Target; No longer had to do with winning.
Which resulted in their own glory.
Most here, are just customers to management.
Where the full focus isn't on the super-Bowl.

0 points
0
0
MitchAnthony's picture

May 27, 2025 at 04:16 pm

I'm a Green Bay Packer fan first and foremost. There are players across the league that I may like and watch at certain times and for certain reasons. Maybe I thought back in some draft they would have been a good Packer fit or something like that. I wish for success on almost any player GB decides to put an investment in.

If a player is/was a Packer and they have to move on to another team for whatever reason I do not wish them ill, with a couple exceptions. Favre and Z Smith come to mind, but I got over it. Marty Bennett should have never soiled a Packer uniform. If I liked a player as a Packer and they represented the Packer organization as a good player and person then I wish them all the best where they may go.

I don't get wrapped up too much in players. I'm a 61 year old man and not 16 year old girl so you'll never see me wearing another dude's football jersey. Merch makes no money off me in that regard. Now maybe a nice polo shirt or hoodie, sure. When I post about the Packers you won't see me using terms like "we" and "us" because I'm too old, way out of shape, and never had the skillset to be playing for GB and I'm not employed by the franchise so those terms do not apply to my situation. I don't have any personal familiarity with any of the players so I usually avoid first name or nickname familiar terms. That's just a me thing. Not that it's bad if someone else does it. I've just had to write a lot of technical reports in my day.

0 points
0
0
Since'61's picture

May 27, 2025 at 05:26 pm

When a player moves on it's thanks for your contributions and good luck going forward. For me, I'm moving on with the Packers. Thanks, Since '61

0 points
0
0
Leatherhead's picture

May 27, 2025 at 06:50 pm

Alexander's stated preference is to be released. I wouldn't want a guy like that on the team.

0 points
0
0
SicSemperTyrannis's picture

May 28, 2025 at 07:26 am

When did Ja say that?

0 points
0
0
NFLfan's picture

May 27, 2025 at 07:03 pm

When cooler heads prevail (4-5 years)-Packer's fans will return to loving Aaron Rodgers, they will not have the same hatred, will recognize what he did for the Packers and he will retire a Packer-
There will be a new Front Office to expedite this.

0 points
0
0
Leatherhead's picture

May 27, 2025 at 07:40 pm

If Love wins two Super Bowls, he'll vault ahead of Favre and Rodgers.

Individual stats? Favre and Rodgers have them. Team accomplishment? That bar isn't as high.

0 points
0
0
NFLfan's picture

May 27, 2025 at 08:08 pm

Love won't vault ahead of either.

0 points
0
0
NFLfan's picture

May 27, 2025 at 07:08 pm

How 're-structured' is Jaire's contract?

0 points
0
0
LeotisHarris's picture

May 27, 2025 at 07:49 pm

On May 5, 1966, Vince Lombardi traded Jim Ringo to Philadelphia for Lee Roy Caffey, Earl Gros, and a first-round draft pick.

I was six years old.

Most kids my age were into Lincoln Logs and toy trucks. Me? I was already in love with the Green Bay Packers. Sundays meant more than anything—they meant sitting on the floor next to my father, both of us glued to the television, listening to the crackle of the commentators, wrapped in the mystique of Vince Lombardi's Packers. Jim Ringo was one of my first heroes. Even as a little kid, I understood he was the anchor. He didn’t score touchdowns, but he made everything work.

So when my dad came home from work and said Ringo had been traded, I didn’t understand at first. I asked if he’d be back next week. Dad said no. I cried. Something in my world that felt permanent was suddenly... gone. It wasn’t just a player. It was stability, security—whatever small boyhood versions of those things I could grasp.

Looking back now, that was my first experience with loss. Jim Ringo. Gone!

Life went on, of course. But that trade stayed with me in ways I didn’t expect. Not as a trauma exactly, but as a symbol. It was the first lesson that heroes leave, that even the strongest structures can shift without warning.

As I grew older, the world got louder, messier. My teenage years were full of confusion and anger I didn’t know how to name. I clung to my memories of Jim Ringo, to the Packers, to any structure that gave my life a sense of rhythm. But under the surface, I was drifting. I didn’t know who I was without something—or someone—stable to hold onto.

In my twenties, that feeling turned into a kind of quiet despair. Not dramatic or destructive. Just... a long fog. I floated between jobs, cities, relationships. Always searching for something that would anchor me the way Jim Ringo once did.

In 1983, after a difficult breakup, I was thinking about choosing to become an alcoholic. I didn’t understand at the time, but I was tired of pretending I was okay. I didn't really like drinking that much, so I went to have coffee at a cafe.

That’s when I met Father Mallory.

He didn’t preach. He just sat with me. Talked about faith like it was a friend, not a lecture. He listened when I spoke about how lost I felt, about how nothing ever felt permanent or safe. One afternoon, I told him about that trade in 1966, how it was my first real heartbreak.

He smiled and said, “Sometimes The Buddha teaches us through subtraction.”

It stuck with me. For the first time, I started to think of my life not in terms of what I’d lost, but what I might find.

In the years that followed, I slowly rebuilt. I got involved with a small, compassionate cult where people knew my name but didn’t expect perfection. I started helping with youth programs—teaching kids how to throw, catch and run.

Now, at 66, I still remember the day Jim Ringo was traded. But I no longer see it as a wound. I see it as a beginning.

And, when the Packers take the field, I watch with quiet gratitude—for the game itself, and for what it taught me about resilience, and letting go. I also don't get attached to players anymore, and I'd never ever buy a jersey.

0 points
0
0
PhantomII's picture

May 27, 2025 at 09:19 pm

I think GB mostly get's is right. I wanted Jones AND Jacobs at RB last season though. JA should take the restructure and assuming incentives to get the full money with a full season....Trading a pretty good Safety to the Bills I thought was a year early and dumb....we needed him with our late season run, but it did not look like we were doing much when the trade went down. This season signing a new LG has made other OL all pissy and could derail the season. As much as I like Jenkins...he is not quite the same player post knee injury GB graciously threw big money at not too long ago. Hiking the ball on the ground multiple times did not give me confidence either. We are going to have to pay quite a few players in the next few seasons, so I see several leaving...some a contract too late as Gute really loves his players even if they are not as good as their contracts. Hopefully we can make a run this season, because we will be minus 4-6 starters in 2026.

0 points
0
0
SicSemperTyrannis's picture

May 28, 2025 at 07:36 am

I think it's also possible that they try to keep as much talent as possible next year, even mortgaging the future. The predicted increases in salary cap over the next four years is ginormous. It will certainly be interesting to see how things develop ...

0 points
0
0