Create Account

Or log in with Facebook


Log in

Or log in with Facebook

Giants vs. Packers: Wild Card Playoffs Rants & Raves

By Category

Giants vs. Packers: Wild Card Playoffs Rants & Raves

The NFC North champion Green Bay Packers are back at Lambeau Field for another playoff game against the New York Giants.  It's the first home playoff game since the divisional round win over the Dallas Cowboys following the 2014 season.  You know, the one where Dez Bryant DROPPED a big fourth down pass to end any threat of a win.  While long gone are the days of the Packers' absolute dominance at home during the playoffs, but they have re-established themselves as a team that most others don't want travel to play.

Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers has played out of his mind and the offense is humming.  Despite a triage unit at cornerback, the defense has upheld their end of the bargain for the most part and this team just seems to have a solid grasp of what is in front of it.  The Packers secured the fourth seed and a home game, but they are likely to face a tough road all the way to Super Bowl LI.  Much has been made of match ups and which scenario best suits the Packers in their quest to bring another Lombardi trophy to Green Bay, but they have to get through Eli Manning and the Giants first.  This is Manning's third playoff game in Green Bay, where he has had some of his best games and broken the hearts of many Packers fans.  So how can the Packers make the third time a charm?  Let's look at the good and bad of the final game of wild card weekend.


This is playoff football.  The Packers finished the season 6-0 and as winners of the North.  There should be no rants.  But of course there are those who can't get past the. . well, the past.  Others are looking at the numbers.  All of the stats such as Eli Manning being 7-1 in road playoff games or Ed Hochuli officiating some of Green Bay's worst playoff defeats (three Dallas games in the 1990's, 4th & 26 and the Super Bowl loss to the Denver Broncos. Source: C.D. Angeli's sometimes overly realistic Twitter) aren't too encouraging but as much as the comparisons and storylines are intriguing, this Giants team isn't any of those past teams.  These are Ben McAdoo's Giants.  Doesn't have the same ring to it as Tom Coughlin's Giants, does it?

Some want to harp on the Packers defense and how depleted they are and that they can't cover Odell Beckham, Jr.  OBJ had five catches and a late touchdown in the last meeting that made the game a lot closer than the final score indicated.  The Packers were without Damarious Randall in that game and while Randall has struggled lately, I'd rather have him out there than not.  His knack for the football combined with Eli's tendency to throw an absolute stinker are a good match.  While the distraction of Beckham's relationship with the kicking net has died down, the image of him mobbing deep in South Beach just a day after the Giants win over Washington is still fresh.  I don't know that I think it will affect his ability to show up big on Sunday.  He may be young and crazy, but he's still a world class athlete and I doubt the Packers are getting a hall pass.  OBJ is going to get his.  The Packers need to minimize everything else around him.  That includes a Giants running game that has busted out of late.  They ran the ball 40 times against Washington for over 150 yards.  The game plan seemed to be to keep the ball away from Washington and the Redskins seemed willing to oblige so that total may be a bit skewed.  But between Rashad Jennings and Paul Perkins, the G Men have a nice two-headed monster and they feed it plenty.  They're averaging around 30 total carries over the last month.  The Packers need to score often and keep the run in check to avoid letting New York dictate the pace.

Others think New York's secondary, otherwise known as the NYPD, is capable of shutting down Green Bay's passing attack and rendering the offense null.  This is the playoffs.  This is Mike McCarthy's team and this team, as young as they are, knows what they need to do to prepare for a win-or-go-home scenario.  Oh and that Rodgers guy I mentioned.  The look in his eyes and his demeanor tells me that he's as ready as he's ever been for the second season.  And 75,000 of his most adoring fans (even Giants fans have to appreciate #12) will be in the house, too.  He'll have plenty of mojo going on.


The Rave is that the Packers finished on a huge winning streak and, much like in 2010 when they needed every last game to get into the postseason, they're hot and the last team the others want to face.  So why is that?  


Rodgers is so far and above the reason why the Packers are a bad match up for most defenses that we could end this conversation here.  40 passing touchdowns, four rushing touchdowns and just seven interceptions.  Rodgers had a touchdown pass in every game but one (at Chicago and he should have had two in that game), even when he was struggling and the team wasn't playing well.  Perhaps never more than in this season did we witness the long-standing narrative that Rodgers has created a level of play that he is held to that is incredibly hard to achieve.  Fortunately, he is achieving everything that most expect from him.  The touchdown throw to Geronimo Allison against the Detroit Lions last week was the type of throw that so few quarterbacks can make but that we expect Rodgers to make.  Besides a big touchdown to help beat the Lions, the Packers have to be encouraged that Rodgers is throwing those types of passes at a time when they'll become so important.  Against the good Giants secondary, Rodgers is going to have to thread the needle at times.  He threw two interceptions in the first meeting and hopefully that was Rodgers getting it out of his system against New York.

Less than a month ago, Rodgers was dealing with a hamstring and calf injury.  He could barely walk off the field after the games against the Seattle Seahawks and Bears.  Rodgers' mobility appeared to be in serious jeopardy at a time when it was needed most.  And then suddenly, he's running around like he was never hurt against the Minnesota Vikings.  Against the Lions, it was vintage Rodgers, running for first downs and making pass rushers miss him, badly.  The determination that Rodgers has to getting himself ready and putting himself on the line to make plays and elevate this team is something to admire.  It reminds me a bit of Reggie White in 1995.  White had a severe hamstring injury late in the year and appeared headed to miss the rest of the season.  He was back two weeks later as if he had never been hurt.  In a game this Sunday where everyone wants to talk about the past and the parallels, there's one that is slanted the Packers' way.  

All of the talk about what Manning has done against the Packers should have that famous chip on Rodgers' shoulder in full effect.  Having joined the Packers in 2005, Rodgers has witnessed both of Manning's performances at Lambeau Field in the postseason.  It's time for Aaron to remind everyone who's king.

2254, 26

2254, the combined receiving yards between Jordy Nelson and Davante Adams.  26 combined touchdowns for the duo.  That's enough to keep any defensive coordinator up at night.  Nelson and Adams have been good all season but their emergence late in the year during the six-game winning streak has been explosive.  Both will face a lot of attention by the Giants' secondary but the game's best players still find ways to make plays.  Expect to see both Nelson and Adams to have modest days statistically, but their contributions will end up being key.  Scoring isn't likely to be very high given the weather conditions so it's going to be about quality over quantity.  These two have been coming through in big moments.  Nelson's 60 yard catch late against the Bears set up the game winning field goal.  Adams has finally started making some of the big and tough catches such as this one that some may have forgotten from week one this season.  

What's His Name 

The Packers have forged a reputation of relying on little-known players, many undrafted free agents, to play big roles.  Injuries this season have further forced the Packers to bring up young and inexperienced guys to try and play over their heads.  Guys like Lane Taylor, LaDarius Gunter, Geronimo Allison, Joe Thomas and Kentrell Bryce to name a few.  It's not the most ideal situation, but all of the snaps these guys have under their belt now become paramount as they will line up against the league's best for the rest of this season.  Gunter will see plenty of Beckham.  Taylor will try to help stop Olivier Vernon.  Allison will likely see Janoris Jenkins, who had two interceptions against Rodgers in the first meeting earlier this season.  

While that all seems to favor the more experienced players, Green Bay has seen these unsung young players step up and play big roles.  Allison had a big touchdown catch against the Lions while stepping in for an injured Randall Cobb.  Taylor only had to fill in for former Pro Bowl guard Josh Sitton and had a brilliant season.  Gunter has faced some of the league's best receivers in Julio Jones, Alshon Jeffrey, and Beckham to name a few.  While many see a mismatch of stars versus joe's, I think about how close Gunter, for example, has come to making a big play this season and how he's due.  Fullback Aaron Ripkowski has endeared himself to Packers fans but outside of Green Bay, who had heard of him prior to last week's game against the Lions?  61 big yards later and the Ripper is on the map.  

It's a big stage to be playing in a playoff game, but these guys have been out there every week.  The wide eyed phase is past them and it's time for them to seize another big moment.

Magic Mike

Some would say Packers head coach Mike McCarthy is hardly magical in the postseason.  Some are still harping on his decision to kick two field goals early in the NFC Championship game against the Seattle Seahawks two seasons ago.  Some harp on his decision to run twice, predictably, late in that same game, stalling a drive and giving the ball back to Seattle.  But when the Packers' backs have been against a wall in the decade that McCarthy has been here, he's come up with some pretty good plans to prepare his team.  I feel like I reference the game against the New England Patriots in 2014 ad nauseam, but that was a brilliantly called game.  Patriots head coach Bill Belichick said so himself.  Russell Wilson helped a ton, but the Packers came up huge against the Seahawks in week 14 during their "table run".  That was the toughest remaining game on the schedule and the Packers were ready for every Seattle miscue on the day.  That mentality is something instilled by leadership.

When the Packers were losing, many wanted McCarthy to go crazy, scream at guys and be demonstrative.  Show he cared.  McCarthy knew better.  He has a good pulse on this team and instead focused on how close they were to making some big plays, to getting a win instead of suffering a close loss.  It's hard to argue with the result.  McCarthy is aware that his legacy of two bad losses to the Giants in the playoffs is hanging over his head and that a third loss would likely cement New York as his ultimate kryptonite.  Expect McCarthy to come out and show is former pupil, McAdoo, a thing or two about football in January.  We've been waiting for tight end Jared Cook to have this "game for the ages" that we keep hearing that he can.  Based on what has troubled the Giants defense this season, it would seem that this might be the week that McCarthy's game plan puts #89 front and center of his strategy to nullify the NYPD and send Eli pouting all the way back to New Jersey.

Adam's Pack

Jersey Al and Julianna Czech will be in the house for this game.  Safe to say that Adam will also be there, in whatever way he can.  That's a lot of added mojo for the Giants to have to deal with and they don't even know it's coming.  Just before he passed, Adam told Julianna that the Packers were going to make a run.  Winning six in a row certainly made a prophet of our fallen friend but something tells me this "run" isn't quite done yet.  Wishing Adam's Pack a great day at Lambeau Field and a big celebration afterwards.



Jason is a freelance writer on staff since 2012 and also co-hosts Cheesehead TV Live, Pulse of the Pack and Pack A Day podcasts.  You can follow him on Twitter here

  • Like Like
  • 0 points

Fan friendly comments only: off Comments (15) This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.

cpabandit's picture

Great post Jason, great post.

jasonperone's picture

Thanks for stopping by as always!

Since '61's picture

I believe that this is the most difficult game that the Packers will face in their hopefully successful post-season. Given the way Aaron Rodgers has been playing neither Dallas or Atlanta have a defense that can stop Aaron Rodgers even if he plays on the road. However, the Packers must get past the Giants first. The Giants defense has been playing very well and Eli has been a great playoff QB on the road and against Green Bay. However, Eli is not the player he once was and he is working with a weak OL and a poor running game. He does have a world class WR corp led by OBJ but OBJ is the only threat to be concerned about. On defense the Giants defense has been improving steadily throughout the second half of the season and they have one of the best secondaries in the league. However, they haven't faced a QB who is playing as well as Rodgers has for the last 6 weeks in their entire season even when they faced Rodgers himself in week 5. Both teams are different teams than they were back in week 5 when neither team was playing particularly well. To some extent this is a game of the other units. By that I mean the Packers defense and the Giants offense. Can the Packers keep the Giants running game and OBJ in check and for the Giants can their offense make enough plays to keep the game close and allow their defense to hold a lead late in the game. I think that the Packers OL plus the play of Aaron Rodgers will carry the Packers. The Giants defense is good against the run but not great and their pass rush is not as strong as it was back in 2011 and 2007, although they have been successful with blitzes during the year. Their secondary which is very good will have all they can handle with Adams, Jordy, Allison, Cobb, Cook, and Monty or whatever combinations MM comes up with. The Giants have not faced a QB and a receiving corps like the Packers all season. Another factor for the Giants defense to deal with is Rodgers legs. He kills defense by running for 1st downs and or TDs even when they have his receivers covered. Rodgers being healthy may be the difference in this game. Between the Packers OL, enough of a run game, the Packers receivers and Rodgers arm and legs the Giants will not be able to keep up with the Packers offense. On defense the Packers need to stop the run and pressure Manning. They should be able to accomplish both against the Giants OL. The Packers defense receives many knocks but the fact is they have won the last 6 games in a row so the defense must be doing something right. The Packers can hold the Giants under 20 points but the Giants cannot hold the Packers under 20 unless the Packers beat themselves with penalties and turnovers. Plus the Packers defense is +14 at least during the 6 game streak. A few turnovers by the Giants will seal the deal for the Packers. No excuses, no let up and no prisoners. Go Pack Go! Thanks, Since '61

jeremyjjbrown's picture

"no let up"

Amen brother.

I really liked the look on McCarthy's face last week at the end to the game. It was steely and read that he was not going to let up until the clock ran out. I haven't seen him like that in years. That's how he needs to be.

Nick Perry's picture

"All of the talk about what Manning has done against the Packers should have that famous chip on Rodgers' shoulder in full effect".

That's what I've thought about a few times this week. If there was ever a time for Rodgers to play with "The Chip", it's this Sunday at Lambeau. This team has won 6 in a row. Rodgers thought they could run the table and they did. With each win came confidence, and this offense has it in spades. No one is going to just shut down Rodgers, it's just not happening this year.

White92's picture

Great piece Jason. I think McCarthy is a great coach. A couple of these playoff losses came with the Packers being huge underdogs in overtime and the offense never getting the ball. I also liked the 2014 quote but this years "Hell, we're the Green Bay Packers" was right up there. He is a leader/motivator/teacher second to none and that's a great coach.

jasonperone's picture


GVPacker's picture

Jason has anybody ever found out what type of treatment A Rod was getting in that little tent that was on the Packers sideline during those earlier games? I recall Jon Gruden was pointing that out during the Monday night game against the Eagles. It seems to have helped!

jasonperone's picture

I think they were inserting a pad in his pants to protect his hamstring and he had to remove the pants to do it. As far as treating the hamstring and calf, that seems to have happened after Chicago and before Minnesota. Not sure what was done but he thanked the medical staff and others as well so it's somewhat of a mystery but it looks to be working!

Handsback's picture

I want to set the record straight IMHO about the Packer's win over the Cowboys three years ago. I live in DFW area and the reception that wasn't had no, I repeat no effect on the final outcome.
The Cowboys could have scored a TD from that reception , but their problem was time left on the clock. Rodgers seemed to be scoring at will in the 4th quarter.
Garrett screwed up by not running the ball on that 4th down and running it until there was no time left while scoring the TD. Green Bay wasn't doing very good against the run, but Garrett seemed to ignore that aspect.
I hope this year the Packers defense can stop the run or the pass and make their opponents one dimensional. Do that and Rodgers will do the rest.

calabasa's picture

What's his name and Magic Mike. Thanks for the laugh! GO PACK!

Lphill's picture

Rodgers just has to be better than Manning and the Packers win.

Samson's picture

Come on Jason, it's easy to be a great cheerleader before the start of a game but actual realistic analysis say the Pack need to play better than they have most of the season. -- Although your blog is a good one, it could have been written (with alterations) every year for the past six seasons. --- The Pack stumble in the play offs for a number of reasons. ------ That's my concern, every year since season 2010 there have been too many ways for them to lose. --- Try to be a little more real than just jumping up and down with your pom poms.

chugwater's picture

You can't spell ELIMINATED without Eli.


chugwater's picture

Hey Cow,

You guaranteed NYG would be up by 18 at halftime. Have you no shame?

Log in to comment, upload your game day photos and more!

Not a member yet? Join free.

If you have already commented on Cheesehead TV in the past, we've created an account for you. Just verify your email, set a password and you're golden.

Or log in with Facebook



"I firmly believe that any man’s finest hour, the greatest fulfillment of all that he holds dear, is that moment when he has worked his heart out in a good cause and lies exhausted on the field of battle – victorious."
"A school without football is in danger of deteriorating into a medieval study hall. "
"The Bears still suck!"