Packers Players as Hamilton Characters

You've always wondered...

We’re still deep into the offseason, and I’ve had a few beers. Rather than talk about the pandemic or other exhausting topics, let’s talk about musicals. Did y’all watch Hamilton? Well, we’re talking about Hamilton, so, enjoy that I guess. For CHTV, it’s Packers players as Hamilton characters! 

Alexander Hamilton

This is Aaron Rodgers and I refuse to hear otherwise. You know who would fall in the draft only to be the greatest of all time? Alexander. Hamilton. There’s a million records he hasn’t set, just you wait. Just you wait. Hamilton is kind of sassy and has an attitude because he’s a damn genius, and if that doesn’t scream Aaron Charles Rodgers then I don’t know what does. He’s not throwing away his shot because he’s the Hail Mary king. Just trust me on this. It fits. If there’s one player who’s consistently looking to prove himself, it’s Rodgers. 

Marquis de Lafayette 

If this isn’t David Bakhtiari...someone who wants to get into fights and get into trouble. Feels like Bakhtiari and the way he’ll always protect Rodgers. He’s also got a sharp wit and brings humor to the performance, which sounds a lot like Bakhtiari on game day. 

Hercules Mulligan

This can be Allen Lazard because he’s growing into a significant role in Rodgers’ squad. Mulligan was a key member in Hamilton’s posse, and the same goes for Lazard and his role on the Packers offense in 2020. 

John Laurens

John Laurens is Hamilton’s right-hand man, and that’s absolutely Davante Adams in this Packers offense. We saw what the offense looked like when Adams suffered from turf toe and wasn’t on the field. Even thought it was still successful, Rodgers wasn’t the same without him, just like Hamilton isn’t the same without Laurens. Rodgers relies on Adams to make the offense go. 

Aaron Burr

Aaron Jones? No. But hear me out. What if Aaron Jones helped to prove that the offense doesn’t need Aaron Rodgers to be successful, and that instead the team can function behind a run-heavy offense? Could the success of Aaron Jones spell the end for our beloved hero Aaronxander Hamilrodgers? Just you wait. Okay I need to stop reusing the same joke. But it still holds. 

George Washington

Washington is one of the best characters in Hamilton without a doubt. It’s not even up for debate. Like, the whole point of his character is that you’d go to war for him. You know who I’d go to war for? Za’Darius Smith. This was the easiest comp to make and I refuse to hear otherwise. 

The Schuyler Sisters (Angelica, Eliza, and Peggy)

This is the tight end unit, and I’m laughing as I write this. Angelica is Marcedes Lewis because Rodgers is still obsessed with him despite Lewis being an aging veteran. Eliza is Jace Sternberger because the offense is trying to pair the two together in a happy marriage (we don’t know that’s possible at this point, but we assume, right?) Peggy is Josiah Deguara because the offense has all the potential to harmonize with Deguara as a piece in the offense, but he definitely won’t play a leading role in year one. 

King George III

The theme on Twitter is to elect Kevin King as King George III. But that’s too easy, right? King George is like the low-key star of the show, so his role deserves to go to a player like Corey Linsley. Doesn’t get a ton of recognition from fans, but he carries the team’s performance week in and week out. And I just assume he spits a lot I guess based on how many plays he has to change at the line of scrimmage as a center.  

Maria Reynolds

THIS IS JAKE KUMEROW. Let’s talk about a player that maybe doesn’t necessarily need to be on the roster but the main character (Aaron/Alexander Rodgers/Hamilton) really likes him so he’s part of the story for that alone. Who would distract Aaron Rodgers from the rest of the offense? Jake Kumerow. So there you go. 

Thomas Jefferson 

Jefferson opposes Hamilton on almost everything. So I can only assume this role would fall to Mason Crosby, and that the only disagreement would be that Crosby wants to kick field goals while Rodgers wants to score touchdowns. 

James Madison

JK Scott reporting for duty. Madison’s role is largely to back up Jefferson before all else. Sounds like the young Scott and the role he plays on special teams behind Crosby. Madison has maybe five lines during the entire musical, which JK Scott can relate to since he barely punts since the offense moves the ball so well. (Just let me have this.)

Phillip Hamilton 

This is Jordan Love. I mean, the quarterback of the future has to have some relation to the quarterback of the present, right? Hamilton suffers (spoilers) from trying to prove himself to the world, and that resonates with a young Love sitting behind Rodgers. Just go with it. Love won’t throw away his shot, but the rest of the NFL might not be ready for his shot just yet. 

Well everyone, this was fun. You should watch Hamilton if you haven’t yet. And you should also submit your player comps in the comments. Because there’s a million comps I haven’t done, and I'm not throwing away my shot. (I'm so sorry.)



Maggie Loney is a writer for Cheesehead TV and podcaster for the Pack-A-Day Podcast and Pack's What She Said. Find her on Twitter at @MaggieJLoney.

3 points

Comments (10)

Fan-Friendly This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.
egbertsouse's picture

July 31, 2020 at 07:56 am

Wow. For those of us not into musical theater I would request that next week you do an article matching Packers with Seinfeld characters.

5 points
MaggieLoney's picture

July 31, 2020 at 08:04 am

Filing this away for a later date...

2 points
mrtundra's picture

July 31, 2020 at 08:23 am

The field turned upside down!

0 points
Rick5952's picture

July 31, 2020 at 08:26 am

Or maybe the Simpsons?

0 points
mrtundra's picture

July 31, 2020 at 08:22 am

It must be nice, it must be nice to have Zadarious on your side!

3 points
dobber's picture

July 31, 2020 at 08:45 am

.....aaaaaaand now we've really hit those last days before camp opens.

1 points
PackEyedOptimist's picture

July 31, 2020 at 09:23 am

Okay, as a former director of musicals, I loved this! (also, I've directed or seen almost every known/major musical, and I consider Hamilton the greatest musical ever written. Les Miz is my number two, and then it gets crowded with shows like Guys and Dolls, Urinetown, Wicked, Man of La Mancha, Pippin, The Producers, etc.)
I love most of your casting! Zadarious: "Losing is easy my friend, winning is harder." And can't you imagine Z in the locker room? "History has its eyes on you."
Rogers definitely is someone who "will never be satisfied" "the man is non-stop!" (he also throws "like he's running out of time")
Some casting differences?
Aaron Burr? The jealous rival who never takes a risk? Maybe Mike McCarthy...
Hey...should Eliza be Danica? Angelika as Olivia Munn? Nah, I like your spin! :-D
Phillip Hamilton? How about Manny Wilkins? Lots of potential, Rogers liked him, but...
King George? I feel like this should not be a Packer, since he is the enemy. I'm thinking Tom Brady. He's been on top for a long time, but now he's losing, and thinks cheating ("I will kill your friends and family to remind you of my love") is okay, because "he's the GOAT."

0 points
Since'61's picture

July 31, 2020 at 09:33 am

Having seen the show on Broadway in NY I think your comparisons are very good. If the season ends up being canceled there is a long line of musicals you can work with to fill the gap until 2021 assuming we have a season by then.

I like West Side Story myself, the original. Due to the pandemic we haven’t seen the recent revision yet. You could do the Packers and Bears as the rival gangs or Packers/Vikings.

In any case it’s clear that we are seriously overdue for some football here at CHTV. Thanks, Since ‘61

2 points
mnbadger's picture

July 31, 2020 at 10:28 am

thanks for the lighthearted story. I haven't seen Hamilton, but now that it's made it as a main storyline for CHTV, I guess it's for real. My wife and I will watch it this weekend. GPG

1 points
splitpea1's picture

July 31, 2020 at 11:44 am

What a bizarre article. As far as this particular musical is concerned, I don't think I could make it more than a couple minutes through it without drowning in my own vomit. If we're going to discuss musicals, let's stick with the classics like "Top Hat", "Carefree", and the "The Wizard of Oz"--even people that don't like musicals (like me) should enjoy these.

-3 points