Best & Worst Case Scenarios: 2013 Packers Specialists

In our worst-case scenario, Mason Crosby bottoms out. He can't seem to hit the broad side of a barn with his kicks and is eventually cut.

Green Bay Packers kicker Mason Crosby. Photo by Corey Behnke of

It's time for the seventh annual "Best & Worst Case Scenario" series, a feature that goes back to the days of the old domain.

I attempt to take a look at what is the very best possible season a player is capable of producing, and on the other hand, what would happen if a player fell flat on his face (without assuming they suffer a season-ending injury). These are intended to be extreme scenarios on both sides of the spectrum. More than likely, each player is going to fall somewhere in the middle, but every now and then, they just so happen to come to fruition.

As one final note, I also try to take a look at what these scenarios would be from an individual standpoint and not necessarily what's best (or worst) for the team.

Mason Crosby

Best-case scenario: Crosby is able to right the ship. No, he doesn't get back to the same level he was at in 2011 when he connected on over 85 percent of his field goals, but he has an average, maybe even slightly above average season for an NFL kicker. Compared to where he was, it's a marked improvement. Crosby makes over three-quarters of his field-goal attempts, is perfect on his extra points and ranks in the top half of the league in kickoff distance. When he misses a field goal, no longer do they miss far to the right or left of the goal posts, which inspires confidence.

Worst-case scenario: Crosby bottoms out. During preseason action he makes a little over 50 percent of his field goal attempts, which doesn't cut it. He might have the edge over Tavecchio in leg strength, but his accuracy is scattershot. His confidence is visibly shaken, and the Packers can no longer endure his struggles. With three years left on his contract, the team has to eat the guaranteed money on his contract, but they decide it's better than watching him continue to miss field goals.

Giorgio Tavecchio

Best-case scenario: Tavecchio consistently performs better than Crosby throughout the course of training camp and in preseason action. Whenever they practice field goals during camp, it always seems like the Italian native makes at least one more than Crosby. And when it comes to the exhibition season, his field-goal percentage outpaces the competition. The Packers are forced to keep Tavecchio on their roster when Crosby fails, and he goes onto have an average but at least reliable first season in the NFL, making over three-quarters of his field goals and easily scoring more than 100 points.

Worst-case scenario: Tavecchio has an average training camp with the Packers, but it's not good enough to supplant Crosby. After his decisive win over the veteran in the Family Night scrimmage, it seems as if Crosby gets the better of the young kicker the rest of the way. It doesn't help that Tavecchio has the weakest leg on the team compared to Crosby on field goals and Tim Masthay on kickoffs. The Packers eventually cut Tavecchio, but that doesn't necessarily prevent them from scouring the waiver wire for another kicker to take over for Crosby.

Tim Masthay

Best-case scenario: Masthay re-writes the Packers record book, breaking most of the marks he already holds. He's able to better his single season career high gross punting average of 45.6 yards, his net punting average of 38.9 yards and the 30 punts downed inside the 20. It's all the more impressive considering the winter climate he forced to perform in for the last quarter of the season. Masthay also wins the kickoff specialist job by default when Crosby is cut. Pro Bowl honors are bestowed on him for the first time in his career.

Worst-case scenario: It's an average season for Masthay, partially because he's prone to mini-slumps. Each year he seems to get off to a slow start or a slow finish, and in 2013, he does both. Masthay isn't helped by his coverage units, but his gross and net punting averages dip to career lows. At least one of his punts is returned for a touchdown and another gets blocked.

Brett Goode

Best-case scenario: For a sixth consecutive season, Goode doesn't have a single errant snap that causes disaster on a punt or kick. It's a remarkable achievement that he's done his job rather flawlessly for so long. Goode isn't a speed demon, but he does as well as can be expected in coverage, which allows the punt team to excel.

Worst-case scenario: The streak is broken. Goode has two bad snaps, one going over the head of the punter and the other over the head of the place-kick holder. It's an unfortunate occurrence, but the Packers aren't about to cut him midseason. They are, however, motivated to bring in competition at long snapper in the offseason.

Previous Best & Worst Case Scenario Entries

Quarterbacks July 29

Running backs July 30

Wide receivers July 31

Tight ends August 1

Offensive tackles August 2

Interior offensive linemen August 3

Defensive linemen August 4

Outside linebackers August 5

Inside linebackers August 6

Cornerbacks August 7

Safeties August 8

Brian Carriveau is the author of the book "It's Just a Game: Big League Drama in Small Town America," and editor of Cheesehead TV's "Pro Football Draft Preview." To contact Brian, email [email protected].

0 points

Comments (4)

Fan-Friendly This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.
Jake's picture

August 09, 2013 at 02:14 pm

The BEST case scenario is Crosby bottoming out. That would finally force Ted and Mike to bring in a real kicker.

0 points
Lars's picture

August 09, 2013 at 03:26 pm

Worst case scenario, Crosby is allowed to remain as the Packers kicker after he almost matches Tavecchio in FG accuracy in the preseason. Then, Crosby immediately turns back into a pumpkin when the regular season begins. All the cut kickers have jobs and it's 2012 redux with McCarthy standing by his kicker so they can again pretend they didn't make a mistake signing Crosby to a long-term $3 million a year deal.

0 points
JakeK's picture

August 09, 2013 at 04:53 pm

This could really turn out to be a mess. If Crosby can't fix himself, who thinks Giorgio Tavecchio is the answer? ... If Thompson really wanted to 'jolt' Crosby into a better performance, he should have brought in some legitimate competition.

0 points
Cuphound's picture

August 10, 2013 at 03:32 pm

I refuse to speculate about the worst damage that Mason Crosby could cause. Almost every time we kicked a field goal last year, I said, "Sweet Lord, not this guy again."

0 points

Log in to comment and more!

Not a member yet? Join free.

If you have already commented on Cheesehead TV in the past, we've created an account for you. Just verify your email, set a password and you're golden.