Create Account

Or log in with Facebook


Log in

Or log in with Facebook

What If Favre Was Benched in 2007 for Aaron Rodgers?

What If Favre Was Benched in 2007 for Aaron Rodgers?

By now, everyone should be familiar with the current quarterback controversy in San Francisco.

Alex Smith was the incumbent, performing near or at a Pro Bowl level thus far in 2012. He sustained a concussion against the Rams on November 11, and hasn't played since while recovering from this injury.

During his absence, Colin Kaepernick stepped in as the starter, and after two solid performances, has been named the starter for at least one more game, despite Smith's being cleared to play going forward.

In short, Alex Smith has been Wally Pipp-ed in favor of Kaepernick.

This morning, while listening to Green and Gold Today, the following came across my timeline on the Tweeter:

"Up and Coming: Aaron Rodgers Subs for Injured Brett Favre"

It was five years ago today that for all intents and purposes, the Brett Favre era ended in Green Bay when he was injured against the Cowboys, and third year quarterback Aaron Rodgers entered the game. Although the Packers lost the game 37-27, and Favre would regain his starting spot the following week and for the rest of the season, this game was a glimpse into the future direction of the Packers.

After reading the short recap about the game as well as the game recap on ESPN, I got to thinking-what would happened if the Packers followed a similar path the 49ers are following?

Think about it for a minute: Favre is the starter, gets injured, Rodgers takes over for him, and never relinquishes the starting spot. Would this have changed the outcome of the season? Would the Packers have made it to the Super Bowl this season with Rodgers leading the team the rest of the way? Remember, Mike McCarthy was reportedly close to benching Favre in the NFC Championship Game, making the comment "If that guy weren't Brett Favre, I'd bench his ass!"

Perhaps just as good a question is if this were to take place is what would the reaction of Favre have been? Would he have been a team player and accepted his new role while the team was continuing to win en route to a Super Bowl victory? Or would he have been the pompous, arrogant Favre that showed all too often in his final years in Green Bay, voicing his displeasure over the decision instead of thinking about the team first?

We will never know the answers to any of these questions, and in the end it does not matter, as both the Packers and Favre went ahead to follow their own paths to the future. But it is an interesting discussion point to wonder what could have happened, if this switch had been made mid season like the 49ers have chosen to do.

  • Like Like
  • 3 points
Filed Under: 

Fan friendly comments only: off Comments (2) This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.

Michael's picture

Great article but I think it would have been dumb to take Favre out after the Cowboys game. He was still playing at a MVP level.. Plus we all know he wouldn't have taken it laying down. He would have been on every news show that would have ask him for a interview. I loved Favre don't get me wrong but he was a big baby.

Mike's picture

I enjoyed your article. I remember that Thursday night game. Favre started out terrible and put the Pack in a hole. Rodgers came in and played great. I also wonder what would have happened if Rodgers would have replaced Favre in the Championship game. I appreciate what Favre did as a player but toward the end I was tired of some of his stupid passes that any other QB would get benched for.

Log in to comment, upload your game day photos and more!

Not a member yet? Join free.

If you have already commented on Cheesehead TV in the past, we've created an account for you. Just verify your email, set a password and you're golden.

Or log in with Facebook


"A school without football is in danger of deteriorating into a medieval study hall. "
"The Bears still suck!"
"I firmly believe that any man’s finest hour, the greatest fulfillment of all that he holds dear, is that moment when he has worked his heart out in a good cause and lies exhausted on the field of battle – victorious."