Create Account

Or log in with Facebook


Log in

Or log in with Facebook

The Award For Worst Packer Ever Goes To...

The Award For Worst Packer Ever Goes To...

It must be the off season, because it's time for a list.

In light of Ron Wolf declaring Brett Favre the greatest Packer of all time, the discussion naturally turned into whether this was correct or not. Some thought Bart Starr was indeed the greatest ever, others thought it might be Don Hutson. And believe it or not, there were even some who thought it was Favre. It is the discussion which will never, ever end.

So rather than delve into that discussion, I decided it was time to ask a different question.

This morning on Twitter, I made a comment which every Packer fan must have an opinion about. The statement was simple, but yielded some answers as emotional as the best ever discussion brought:

You never hear about the worst Packer player of all time.

The responses came fast and furious, and were accompanied with some interesting comments. As I read the candidates come in, I kept thinking about how each one of these players sucked in their own unique way, and as a result, are imbedded in the brains of Packer fans for their suckitude.

The early results for Worst Packer of All Time are:

Tied with one vote each: Rich CampbellMichael HaddixJustin Harrell, and Taco Wallace

A two way tie with 2 votes each for Terrell Buckley and Jamal Renyolds

Next up with 3 votes, BJ Sander

A two way tie for second place with 4 votes for Tony Mandarich and Ahmad Carroll

And the winner, for worst Packer of all time goes to...........

TJ Rubley.

Don't remember who TJ is? Don't know why he ranks as the worst Packer of all time? This might refresh your memory, or help create a new one.

Congrats TJ. Here is your official Worst Packer of All Time trophy.


You suck.

Feel free to cast your vote in the comments.


  • Like Like
  • -2 points
Filed Under: 

Fan friendly comments only: off Comments (16) This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.

Mitch's picture

Ahmad Carroll. 1000 times Ahmad Carroll. I remember being in vacation in Hawaii with my dad when he was drafted, and that's the most positive memory of him that I have. Just an absolute waste of a draft pick, roster spot, and salary.

JPB's picture

Mandarich was taken with Barry Freaking Sanders still on the board. Carroll, Harrell, and Rubley don't even add up to how bad he was compared to what we could have had.

Andy's picture

Personally I thought Jim Del Gaizo was the worst. I watched him play and he was horrible! I know TJ Rubley disobeyed Holmgren and lost that Game against the vikings for us but Del Gaizo sucked bad.

Michael's picture

Mandarich was the worst pick ever. This guy actually went on a talk show to say he could beat up Mike Tyson in his prime.

Michael's picture

That was a good aticle to by the way.. I don't remember that guy at all!

JohnRehor's picture

Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for reading!

Estus Hood's picture

No mention of Asb-estus Hood as the worst of all time? Ah, how quickly we forget...'s picture

Hi, that are a ok article.'s picture

my friend, that is a great article.'s picture

my friend, that are a great article.'s picture

Hi, there are an great article.

cheap men uggs 358556's picture

ugg, news and information about ugg Cheap ugg, ugg Sales Men & Women

north face cyber monday's picture

Croker decides to secure the backing of Mr Bridger, underworld boss, quickly a guest of Her Majesty in the prison from which Croker has just been launched. He finds the "usual channels" ("Camp" Freddie) less than valuable. "Charlie," opines Freddie, "you couldn't even spell major." So Croker is pressured to interrupt in to the prison and place the strategy just before Mr Bridger.I am a 55-year-old business enterprise specialist and part-time local actress. 4 many years back, I used to be identified with breast most cancers. Prior to my prognosis, I led a pretty healthy lifestyle and was quite conscientious regarding the way I appeared.
north face cyber monday

louis vuitton black friday's picture

The funny factor about environment business goals is the fact that when you reach one, quite often the other individuals drop into line shortly thereafter. A great profession mentor will sit you down and drive you to consider stock of your goals and ambitions. As soon as you get rid of the shackles of capital (which is easy to complete on paper but nearly not possible in true lifestyle) you may emerge using a clearer perception of your calling or goal..Ward found out that certainly one of them experienced gotten in trouble in class for speaking on her cellular phone. Ms. Ward documented the incident for the principal - who then warned her to not punish the girl.
louis vuitton black friday

moncler sale's picture

The Montgomery Location mansion was originally developed in 1804 inside the federal fashion. Davis re-designed the mansion between 1840 and 1860 inside the classical revival fashion. Lots of folks worked to the landscaping of Montgomery Location.

Log in to comment, upload your game day photos and more!

Not a member yet? Join free.

If you have already commented on Cheesehead TV in the past, we've created an account for you. Just verify your email, set a password and you're golden.

Or log in with Facebook


"The Bears still suck!"
"I firmly believe that any man’s finest hour, the greatest fulfillment of all that he holds dear, is that moment when he has worked his heart out in a good cause and lies exhausted on the field of battle – victorious."
"A school without football is in danger of deteriorating into a medieval study hall. "