Create Account

Or log in with Facebook


Log in

Or log in with Facebook

Preseason Revisited

Preseason Revisited




Kudos to Mike McCarthy and Dom Capers for somehow convincing the entire Packer team that last Sunday’s game was a preseason game.






Well, the Packers finally got the quality win that they so desperately needed—their first since the win over the Bears in week one. In between, there was a surprising—but in hindsight, not so bad—loss to the Bengals, two humiliating losses to the Vikings, and an inexplicable loss to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. On the plus side, there were wins against the Rams, Lions, and Browns—three of the worst teams in the league.


What are we to make of all this? It beats the heck out of me. The most encouraging thing is that the defense just played its best game of the season by far. The Cowboys may be notoriously undisciplined and poorly coached, but there’s no denying that they are loaded with talent, and they beat the Packers convincingly in Green Bay last year. So maybe this is progress.


Watching the defense get home on blitz after blitz, I was reminded of those warm summer nights when the Packers were the kings of the NFL preseason. I’ve always thought that, if you know what to look for, the NFL preseason can provide some useful clues about how the regular season is going to play out, but whatever remained of that belief was smashed to bits by this year’s Packer team, as their preseason momentum evaporated almost immediately when September rolled around. It got me to wondering what the most important differences are between the preseason and the regular season. Beyond the obvious difference that the starters don’t play as much in the preseason, there are two factors that stand out: game planning and motivation.


Of course, teams do not game plan nearly as much during the preseason as they do when the games count. This is actually one of the things I like about preseason football. I enjoy watching the one-on-one matchups. I often think that all of the complicated schemes employed by NFL teams may actually detract from our enjoyment of the sport. But the significance of preseason game planning (or lack thereof) for this year’s Packers is that the team’s starters seemed to match up well athletically against all of their opponents--heck, even Allen Barbre showed an ability to block pass rushers--yet when the real scheming began, the Packers suddenly looked like the same sorry team that took the field in 2008. This would not appear to reflect well on the coaching staff.


The struggles of the defense in the regular season have been less surprising than the struggles of the offense. In the preseason the Packers blitzed way more than most teams do, simply because they needed to practice their blitzes. It was expected that opposing teams would be better prepared to handle the blitzes in the regular season. But the decline of the offense has been a little harder to figure out. And maybe that’s where motivation comes in. Nobody is fully motivated during the preseason—or at least they shouldn’t be—but the regular season is what separates the teams that want to win from the teams that REALLY want to win.


On this web site, Jersey Al was quick to question Mike McCarthy’s ability to motivate his players when the Packers began to falter. I was initially skeptical. I’ve always been inclined to let the season play out before passing judgment on coaches and GM’s anyway. But after watching the Packers get kicked around by the Vikings at Lambeau Field, in a game where they HAD to play their best and clearly did not, then watching them crumble up and blow away in the fourth quarter in Tampa, I had to admit that Al may have been onto something. This win against the Cowboys at least gives us some hope, however.


Maybe the motivation needed to come from the players rather than the coaching staff. I would prefer to have a coach who can lift the team’s spirits almost singlehandedly, but if we don’t have that kind of coach, the players need to do it themselves. And maybe that’s what happened in the “Come to Jesus” team meeting after the loss to Tampa Bay. I wouldn’t bet on this new attitude having any staying power, but at least for now, it gives the team something to hang its hat on going into Sunday’s matchup against the 49ers. Maybe the Packers have finally recaptured some of that spark that they seemed to have in August. It seems like that was a long, long time ago.  

  • Like Like
  • 0 points

Fan friendly comments only: off Comments (8) This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.

PackersRS's picture

Good article, Greg C.

I think the preseason gave everyone a sense of calm that shouldn't be there. Including players and coaches.

They just thought they were the cream of the NFL, that they could stop anyone anytime, and specially, that they could put points in anyone, and play the way they wanted to.

Looking back, it would be better if they were criticized during preseason, and played with a chip on their shoulder for the whole regular season, and THEN build confidence, much like the Bengals.

RonLC's picture

Since game two of 2008, I've been bitching about the lack of quality in the offensive line. Even after Dallas, I have not changed my mind. With Wells and his mysterious concussion, GB could have their 7th starting Oline lineup in 9 games. This indicates one very critical defect that TT has screwed up since he arrived. None of his draft choices has moved up and taken charge of a position (maybe Lang-too soon to tell). After 5 years, that is not acceptable. He refuses to use FA to get an upgrade (Duke was not an upgrade). On Sunday it is possible that Dietrich-Smith will be starting at the critical center position. Four sacks last week and one drive is nothing to brag about. The offense needs to take the step forward the defense did last week.
It's all on MM this week. Can he do it? We'll see soon enough.

Greg C.'s picture

There's little doubt that the O-line is Thompson's biggest failing. Ironically, this is the position group that is most dependent on good drafting, as it is hard to find good O-linemen in free agency. I think McCarthy's poorly-run ZBS scheme is at least partly to blame for the mess, but in the end, it's all on Thompson, because he's the guy in charge. I think he's done a very good to decent job in most other areas, though. The exceptions: We're thin at safety and we don't have a standout at RB, and the punter continues to be a source of embarrassment.

Stan's picture

Ah the hopes of preseason. It's always a bad omen when everyone and their dog votes the Packers to the playoffs, or even worse the Superbowl.

Regards the O-Line, the minute I heard that Colledge was practicing some at centre I started to lose hope again. Why Ted, why did you decide Duke Preston was worse than Evan Deitrich-Smith (the rookie apparently had a real tough time ending in an injury in his first first-team practice). . . . oh dear, we lose Wells and this O-Line gets EVEN worse (bye, bye Rodgers).

RonLC's picture

Looks like Wells is going to start on Sunday. Tauscher will also start. Why in hell didn't they get at least one good Oline FA this year? It should be no secret why they cannot be consistent.

Jersey Al's picture

I found it amazing how many "experts" picked the Packers for the Super Bowl based on preseason. Will they ever learn?

FITZCORE1252's picture

I'm an "expert", I picked the PACK! Man, I ALWAYS remind myself "preseason means nothing", but when it pertains to the PACK and things looking up, it's hard not to get enveloped. I really thought this could be a special season. Remember the starting offense's TD ratio, STAGGERING. Starting D wasn't giving up shit... in hindsight, it was all too good to be true, BUT, we're not dead yet!


Greg C.'s picture

Yeah, I felt very good about the Packers too. They seemed ready for a bounce-back season to begin with, and when they looked so good in the preseason, I thought they were going to be contenders. I shied away from making an "official" prediction though, because the previous year I had predicted them to win it all, and they went 6-10. Oops!

After all that's happened in the first nine games, I'm skeptical but I won't give up till the Packers are out of contention. They still have a very reasonable shot at the playoffs.

Log in to comment, upload your game day photos and more!

Not a member yet? Join free.

If you have already commented on Cheesehead TV in the past, we've created an account for you. Just verify your email, set a password and you're golden.

Or log in with Facebook


"I firmly believe that any man’s finest hour, the greatest fulfillment of all that he holds dear, is that moment when he has worked his heart out in a good cause and lies exhausted on the field of battle – victorious."
"The Bears still suck!"
"A school without football is in danger of deteriorating into a medieval study hall. "