The Best Parts of the Draft When You Know Nothing About the Draft

Just because you don't know the prospects doesn't mean you can't participate.

I unabashedly love the NFL draft. I watch most of it every year (I'll be honest, I'll tune in a bit on Saturday, but by that point I'm a bit fatigued; I miss the two-day format). I am extremely active on Twitter throughout at least the first few rounds. I'll be on the Cheesehead TV draft party, I'll have folks over for pizza and beer, etc. 

But here's the thing. I know jack shit about it.

In my younger days I had more time to follow college ball, but even then I never really paid that close of attention to who were considered the hot prospects. I was always far more focused on everything happening in the NFL, and so while I could talk about NFL teams and their players and specific needs for hours on end, I'd be essentially useless when it came to critiquing mock drafts or rating prospects.

Now as a man with several young children and a career, I have less time than ever to devote to my football studies. I do, of course, watch every Packer game and obsessively consume Packers-related content. I catch as much other NFL action as I can (usually primetime games after kids are in bed). In the not-too-distant future I'll be able to resume more obsessive football watching habits once again, even getting a healthy diet of college ball back into my life.

But as for the draft? My friends, I could list maybe five names of players in this thing. I'm more out of it than ever. And partially as a result, I'm looking forward to it more than ever.

So with that, I introduce to you: The Best Parts of the Draft When You Know Nothing About the Draft.

1. The online reactions.

Just about everyone has incredibly strong opinions about the draft and who the Packers should pick, and there are plenty of folks on the Packers' corner of Twitter (and in the comment section of this very website) who are ready to can everyone if the draft doesn't proceed in the way they believe it should.

Frankly, it's absolutely hilarious. Every single year the immediate overreactions are worth every single moment of drudgery between picks.

Who could forget the absolute hysteria of the 2020 draft? I thought Packer fans were about to storm 1265 Lombardi with torches and pitchforks after the first several selections. Everyone already was utterly on edge after a couple months of isolation in the start of a global pandemic. But HOO BOY, people popped off that night! The drafting of Jordan Love has to be one of the single-most entertaining moments of online Packer fandom of my lifetime, and it was made even more hilarious by the reactions to the drafting of AJ Dillon and Josiah Deguara.

What about every single time the Packers used a draft pick on something other than a wide receiver?

Or when Rashan Gary was instantly branded a "bust?"

Cannot WAIT for whatever hilarity ensues online tomorrow.

2. The beer (and also the food, I guess).

If you read my work on here, especially during the regular season, you know I enjoy a good local brew.

I always make it a point to save up a few extra-special beers for the occasion, particularly because the last couple years Corey Behnke has made it a point to ask me on the stream what I am drinking. With a reputation to uphold, it is critical that I come prepared with something interesting.

This year I do have one Carry the G cream ale left from the football season, which I will proudly consume at some point. But there are a few other lingerers in my fridge that I've been waiting for an opportune moment to pop out. I've got 1840's Barrel-Aged Hawaiian Drinking Chocolate, a barrel-aged imperial stout loaded with coconut and chocolatey goodness that goes down so smoothly despite its whopping ABV. I've got a couple really nice oak-aged saisons that I've been considering cracking open, especially with the weather hopefully warming up again soon. It's the tail end of bock season, so I've got a barrel-aged dopplebock that may have to make an appearance. And there are always a few fruited sours on hand around here, including a new one that I may be grabbing on my upcoming beer run this weekend.

But also I could end up going with something completely different entirely. Who knows how the spirit will move me!

And of course, every year I make it a point to get Toppers stix, because I used to do it during college and it just absolutely hit, so now it's just a thing that must happen every year. Wouldn't be draft night without it. 

3. Awkwardness at the podium

Roger Goodell never, ever looks comfortable in front of an audience. Sure, it doesn't help that he's always getting booed, but the dude is absolutely NOT a natural at working a room. 

But that's not all. Every year it feels like there's some sort of embarrassing or cringeworthy moment that happens when the league allows guests to come up and announce selections on the second night of the draft. 

4. Insight from actual reliable people.

I don't really get a whole lot out of draft analysis by the national guys any more. Don't get me wrong, I'll have on the ESPN or NFL Draft coverage. But my favorite stuff comes from Packers-specific people, often who do not have any ties to major media outlets.

To me as a Packer fan, it gets no better than Andy Herman. Andy does his homework, and backs his opinions up with significant tape study and logic. He is able to study prospects through the lens of what he knows the Packers need. Most importantly, he's not afraid to admit when he's wrong! Andy was one of the people who immediately referred to the drafting of Gary as a big-time mistake by the Packers on the night of the draft. But he went back, reviewed, and ultimately found himself to be in the wrong, and found a lot of things to like about the player. You don't get very many guys on the national level who are willing to own up to that sort of thing.

5. Pretending you know what you're talking about.

Perhaps most importantly, at some point during the weekend you have to make some grand statement about whether you agree with the team's approach to the draft or believe they have set themselves up well for the future. You are required to make this statement with the utmost certainty, going so far as to point out the foolishness of others who disagree with your chosen stance.

It does not matter if you know absolutely nothing coming into the draft. As soon as the tweets roll in, you are now an expert, and it is time to pick a side.

I look forward to gleefully doing so in the most self-aware manner possible this weekend.

 

To all of you in my shoes, enjoy the draft. To those of you who actually know what the hell you're talking about, please take it easy when the team doesn't draft [INSERT PLAYER] that you really wanted at [INSERT PICK NUMBER].

 

PLEASE SUBSCRIBE TO OUR CHEESEHEAD NATION WEEKLY NEWSLETTER HERE.

__________________________

Tim Backes is a lifelong Packer fan and a contributor to CheeseheadTV. Follow him on Twitter @timbackes for his Packer takes, random musings and Untappd beer check-ins.

__________________________

3 points
 

Comments (154)

Fan-Friendly This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 06:13 am

Who was the last Utah State player drafted in the first round before Jordan Love in 2020?

Phil Olsen 50 years earlier in 1970.

What does that say about Utah State and the level of competition Jordan Love faced?

-21 points
3
24
GregC's picture

April 20, 2023 at 06:24 am

Nothing.

17 points
17
0
LambeauPlain's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:50 am

Another pile of steaming nothing, indeed.

Southern Mississippi played as an independent when a certain gunslinger was coveted by The Wolfman, was drafted by Atlanta, buried on the depth chart, then traded to the Packers for a first rounder.

Wolf got his QB from a lesser college program. I remember the howl of dismay back then. "A first rounder? This Ron Wolf guy is an already a bust!"

Now he has a bust in the HOF.

11 points
12
1
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:51 am

At least it was brief!

9 points
9
0
murf7777's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:06 am

Oh no, don’t poke the bear!

3 points
4
1
Racingdad's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:12 am

To starrrodgers From your comments it’s easy to see you clearly hate Jordan love - so to you sir I say find a new team to bash because as true Green Bay packer fans we choose to support our team and yes our new qb !! Constant negativity solves nothing on this forum or in life !! Trying to live in the past gets one nowhere as for me I’m 100% behind our new qb-1 and our team even if that means we struggle for a while this team is too great to be down long if at all !!! So to you sir continue to worship at the alter of Aron if you must , become a jets fan if it helps you sleep at nite BUT stop the constant hate for our qb , our team, and our fan base . Change is not always easy but is 100% necessary so please change or leave but just STOP

12 points
14
2
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:47 am

Racingdad,

There is no hate here for Jordan, Aaron or any of the players, just reasoned and rational observation and data points.

My Packer friends and I have been rooting for the Packers and going to Packer games at Lambeau and across the country since the days of Bart Starr.

We always cheer for Jordan Love and all Packer Players.

We NEVER EVER BOO Jordan Love or any Packer player or any player for any team.

As fans though we do NOT cheer management - Management is not the team, management simply lives off the talents of the team. And in the case of Rodgers, Lafleur and Murphy and Gutekunst owe their continued employment to Rodgers talents,

All of my fellow Packer fan friends - all shareholders too - have called and written to Mark and Brian and voiced our opinions and displeasure with this trade and treatment of Aaron Rodgers and will continue to do so.

We are in consensus that Brian Gutekunst is destroying the team and the Rodgers trade is an ignorant irrational ego and emotion driven trade as was the drafting of Jordan Love and the Packer Management being the only team of 32 teams in the NFL to not have drafted a running back, wide receiver or tight end in the first round for the past 20 years - 2003 through 2022.

We root for the Packer players not for the egos and stupidity of the Parasitic Packer Management of Gutekunst who owes his continued employment as GM to the performance and miracles of Aaron Rodgers - as does Mark Murphy.

Hopefully the trade will fall through and Aaron will return as a backup to Jordan so that he can be there to salvage the Packers season, should Jordan fail, which based all data points and observations of Jordan in college against Power 5 Conference competition and each of the NFL preseason and regular season games Jordan has played in, he will.

That said, my Packer fan friends and I will always be cheering the Packer players - Jordan Love and all of them and NEVER EVER BOOING ANY PACKER OR ANY NFL PLAYER - win or lose as we did each game of each year from 1968 through 1991 when the Packers went through QB after QB and were in the playoffs but 2 of 23 years.

Being a fan of a team does not mean you have to cheer its SUITS who are there primarily to maximize the Collective and Profits of the 31 Billionaire Parasite Owners.

We are there as fans to cheer Jordan, Aaron, and all the players whose athletic talents create the value and are worth watching, not the parasitic Billionaire Owners and their Marines in Business Suits.

We are die hard Packer player fans, not fans of the parasites who suck value out of the blood, sweat and tears the players shed when they each week risk crippling injury, brain damage and death for our entertainment and escape from the reality of greed driven and war profiteering Billionaire Owners of these teams and the USA.

-9 points
4
13
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:55 am

Is there a team whose management DOESN’T “live off the talents of the team”?

14 points
14
0
Racingdad's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:56 am

Start if you indeed are a fan as you claim than get the heck on the love train or move to jets as arod is NOT going to ever play in gb again get on board and start acting like a packer fan and not an Aron lover and fo hater !!

2 points
4
2
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:45 am

Racingdad, "Start if you indeed are a fan as you claim than get the heck on the love train or move to jets as arod is NOT going to ever play in gb again get on board and start acting like a packer fan and not an Aron lover and fo hater !!"

STR: Racingdad, why should any TRUE DIE HARD Packer fan support a Management trade that they do not agree with?

On the contrary - All my Packer Fan friends - IN TH EREAL WORLD, not an internet site - are opposed to this trade and have been calling and writing and emailing Brian and his staff and Mark and his staff requesting that they DROP THIS IGNORANT EMIOTION AND EGO DRIVEN trade and bring Aaron back.

And we will continue to do so.

And at training camp WE WILL BE OUT AT LAMBEAU WITH SIGNS - BRING AARON RODGERS BACK!!!

And if the time comes that Jordan is starting we will ALWAYS CHEER AND NEVER BOO JORDAN no matter how badly he plays during games.

We are fans of the players and cheer the players, NOT management.

-4 points
2
6
coolhand's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:17 am

DROP THIS IGNORANT EMIOTION AND EGO DRIVEN trade and bring Aaron back.

What? It was Rodgers who demanded the huge contract and 1 year later says he was 90% sure he would retire. Who has the EGO here?

2 points
5
3
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:21 am

I’ve never seen you criticized for not supporting Packer Management. I’ve seen you claim many who certainly and vocally don’t are management lackeys. This is just one of your smoke screens for the indefensible drivel you regurgitate repeatedly.

The only thing I can detect you support is Rodgers. He’s gone in reality. If I believed you, turning up to “support” Love with “bring back Rodgers” signs is the kind of support no one needs.

Go back to your bridge.

3 points
5
2
mrtundra's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:48 am

Did "Packer Fans" say that sort of thing about Kansas State and the level of competition Jordy Nelson faced? NO! Love will be a solid QB for us. I'm guessing that you also did not like RoIdgers, when the Favre retirement debacle was going on.

9 points
10
1
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:35 am

"Did "Packer Fans" say that sort of thing about Kansas State and the level of competition Jordy Nelson faced? NO!"

mrtundra,

To answer your question, Jordy Nelson played in the Big 12 Conference - one of the Power 5 Conferences - which has produced 21 National Champions - there is no question that Jordy faced players who would be first round draft choices in the NFL when playing for Kansas State. The Mountain West Conference that Jordan played in on the other hand has never produced a team that won a National Championship. Jordan played a soft schedule until he faced a couple Power 5 Conference teams and when he did his performances were awful - see the October 2019 game against LSU. or the games against Michigan State and Wake Forest. Watch the games - we have these and all of Jordan's exhibition and regular season games with the Packers.

mrtundra: Love will be a solid QB for us.

We all hope so, but we don't see any evidence of it from Jordan's games against real college NFL bound competition or in Jordan's NFL games to date. And Packer fans on this website complain when Aaron "only" leads the Packers to the playoffs.

mrtundra: I'm guessing that you also did not like RoIdgers, when the Favre retirement debacle was going on."

STR: Bad guess - all my fellow Packer fan friends and I - from watching Aaron Rodger in college vs. #1 USC and other Pac 10 teams and the Thursday night Dallas game and Packer exhibition games knew Aaron was composed, cool,, thinking and improvisational from the start. Jordan looks like he he is SCRIPTED - if he has to adapt to defenses, he looks lost. Watch the LSU game and the Chiefs and Lions games. The Eagles game was already decied and the defense was in a prevent and laying back and letting Jordan complete short passes that you and I could complete. Jordan is better than Brett Hundley in his arm strength and mechanics and though not a running quarterback is good on his feet, but he does not demonstrated the intelligence under fire that Aaron already demonstrated as a 20 year old at Cal.

The reason to replace Brett with Aaron was not that Brett was old or fading physically. Brett was still near the top of his game. The reason to replace Brett was simply that Aaron was better QB than Favre when they were both young and a better QB than Favre when they were both in their prime. Aaron was simply a better QB than Brett.

That said the Packer Management was also NOT up front and truthful with Brett in March of 2008 and we felt due to that Brett should have been allowed to compete with Aaron for the job.

We were certain that Aaron would have won the job. Brett's durability provided stability at QB and this allowed the Packers to keep winning, but the most important thing for a QB is to be able to think on his feet and not turn the ball over, especially if Packer Management :

1) Over your 15 years as Packer starter provides you with a top 10 defense only 3 years - Brady during the same 15 years was given a top 10 defense 12 times and 14 out of 15 years had a higher ranked defense.

2) was the only NFL management from 2003 through 2022 not to use a 1st round draft choice on a running back , tight end or wide receiver.

-5 points
1
6
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:49 am

“The reason to replace Brett with Aaron was not that Brett was old or fading physically. Brett was still near the top of his game. The reason to replace Brett was simply that Aaron was better QB than Favre when they were both young and a better QB than Favre when they were both in their prime. Aaron was simply a better QB than Brett.”

Simply not so, probably not true till 2009 and arguably 2010. You are just proving you weren’t paying attention then and actually know nothing.

As to watching Rodgers, if I believe that you watched him in college, and I don’t, you obviously have no more clue about the Tedford O than you did about Hookers Volunteers the other day when pronouncing. Obviously didn’t watch him in camps the first couple of years at least. I think you just make things up.

I conclude that you are a troll. Pure and simple.

Go away.

3 points
5
2
golfpacker1's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:06 pm

Another thread hijacking by STR. Starr I was going to ask you if you were related to Rodgers because of the fixation you have for him. But I hear Rodgers is a tool to his family, so they probably don't like him as much as you do. I will be glad when he is gone, and you are on the Jet sites praising his glory.

0 points
1
1
Irish_Cheesehead's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:49 am

Sounds like you don't know much about the draft either!

11 points
11
0
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:53 am

Once again, I am starting to think you might slightly dislike this whole transition.

12 points
12
0
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:40 am

Bullshit

Despite all your puffery you continually demonstrate almost a total absence if football knowledge or interest in verifying facts.

First of all there are a number of players from the Mountain West that you should know. Remember Davante Adams? How about Brian Urlacher? Josh Allen? Derek Carr? For a Packers DIE HARD, it’s odd that you don’t remember KGB.

Second your “fact” is actually simply wrong. Do you know how to do a basic internet search?

Here’s a few hints; which college did these players get drafted from?

WR Steve Smith. 2001
OT Jordan Gross. 2003
S. Eric Weddle. 2007

A. Utah State

As for the conference, remember 2005? With the greatest of ironies, none other than Utes QB ALEX SMITH, the QB whose career became intertwined with Rodgers through that draft.

They may not have been first rounders, but they were all giid players and other conference players have been taken I. The first, and you were talking about opposition faced.,

They were all drafted. There are more. It’s really easy to find out, but try here: https://nevadasportsnet.com/news/reporters/murrays-mailbag-who-are-the-1...

You display either no knowledge or no adherence to factual integrity on a consistent basis, only to an outcome you try to justify through any means possible, whatever the contortions to memory, fact or logic that entails.

7 points
8
1
stockholder's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:33 am

In 2020 Jordan Love was drafted with the 1 and #4 pick
They brought in Liki Fotu DL Utah. A guy I wanted.
He went to the Cardinals and is starting. 4th rd.
Just saying.

0 points
3
3
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:46 am

They traded the 30th pick and a late 4th, if that’s what you are saying, yes. I was not happy about it then, but as a prospect with high upside low floor and time to develop, that’s not bad value.

Would you be sad if we took Washington at 26? Would you be happy if we took the older and much less tested or talented Hooker? I wanted a player for then, not the guy you cite, but that doesn’t mean I can’t accept the value proposition.

3 points
3
0
greengold's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:31 am

True. Franchise QB tho, able to make any throw from any platform, tailor made to fit LaFleur’s scheme.

When that opportunity presents for the cost of an R4…???

What’s so great about Fotu? 27 tackles and 1 sack in 3 years of play? TJ Slayton has near as much in 2 seasons.

I liked him too, but we weren’t getting him R4. Would have had to take Fotu R3 to get him.

4 points
4
0
golfpacker1's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:09 pm

I wanted Fotu that year too SH.

0 points
1
1
bottlefliper's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:32 am

I got that this Starr2Rodgers guy, who has not the slightest idea of how to use information and facts.
No matter how the numbers are, its always bad and will get worse. But at least he is the first one here to post the same stuff all over it again and again. We have a job, a life and some brains, so we dont spend 24 hour here like you. It would be nice if you find another outlet for your troll hate (for Love, for the FO, for the NFL.....for everyone besides 12) propaganda. This is CHTV and not Fox News.
And I bet you have been crying here als the time the last 10 years that the Packers wast AR prime. I can only tell you that AR wast my prime way too long.....

1 points
3
2
Mike Rossmeier's picture

April 20, 2023 at 01:49 pm

None of the Tetford/California QBs before Rodgers were any good - so let's hope Love like AR is a history-makers.

1 points
1
0
Savage57's picture

April 20, 2023 at 06:25 am

The Crib Notes version of all post-draft commentary:

"The Packers should have taken so and so."
"No, he was a reach at his position. So and so was the better BPA choice."
"You obviously know nothing about football."
"Eat my shorts."

Enjoy the draft, y'all!

18 points
18
0
LambeauPlain's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:57 am

Most years, the prospects I covet on video and stats rarely end up at 1265 Lombardi.

Last year was a happy exception. I was a huge proponent for Watson as my top WR talent...and really wanted to get Doubs if Watson got away. I could not believe Gutey got both!

Sometimes a blind squirrel finds a few acorns...

13 points
13
0
Savage57's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:48 am

Pigs, too, I hear.

0 points
0
0
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:15 am

Why would a blind squirrel want to find a pig?

2 points
3
1
SoCalJim's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:27 am

The pig can see.

-1 points
1
2
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 01:35 pm

Teamwork, baby!

1 points
1
0
BirdDogUni's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:31 pm

Bacon, duh...

1 points
1
0
BirdDogUni's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:35 pm

Also, pigs are great truffle finders. What squirrel wouldn't want a pig to find truffles for him?

;P

1 points
1
0
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 06:37 pm

As long as the pig doesn’t find his nuts

0 points
0
0
GregC's picture

April 20, 2023 at 06:29 am

I've been reading more and more about the draft ahead of time in recent years, so it will be more interesting to watch, but basically I'm just aware of the conventional wisdom rather than having strong opinions of my own. My wife finds it very entertaining when my "prediction" about the Packers draft goes right down the toilet almost every year.

8 points
8
0
T7Steve's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:20 am

Just like my March Madness brackets.

6 points
6
0
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:06 am

It’s also kind of fun when a guy is in the NFL for a few years and then GB acquires him, and you can recall that player’s draft profile.

4 points
4
0
greengold's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:37 am

S Tarvarius Moore and WR Bo Melton are two of those guys for me.

Tarvarius Moore - Southern Miss
6-2 191 4.32 11.1 broad 38.5 vertical RAS 9.22

During Moore’s Senior year (2017) 522 of his 831 defensive snaps were either in the box or at FS, earning an elite run-defense grade of 90.2 that ranked 1st among the 123 draft-eligible safeties and an 82.9 coverage grade that ranked tied for 18th.

His last two years Moore had an 86.2 coverage grade and allowed just nine completions on 24 targets for 173 yards and one touchdown, 5 INT, 2 PBU. Passer rating allowed off just 37.7 on throws into his coverage — 3rd best among Safeties with at least 20 targets in coverage.

Moore’s a premium athlete w smooth hips, fluid feet, ability to handle man cover matchups that others could struggle with.


WR Bo Melton - Rutgers
5-11 198 4.34

Since 2020, Melton ranked #19 in Power 5 deep receptions (15), #2 in uncatchable targets (23). This really says it all. Taking out screens, his Catchable TGT Rate was 7th worst in Power 5 over 3 year span. His separation so good it was in 86th percentile.

He shows good understanding of how to run routes and set up defensive backs and has some spectacular plays in his tape. A 4.34 40 at the combine showed he has legit speed as well. Melton broke double-digit tackles in each of the last two seasons.

Shifty. Speedy. EXPLOSIVE. ROUTES. SEPARATION. TOUGH. YAC.

*Just saddled with a really bad QB. Steal late.

6 points
6
0
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:09 am

Melton is genuinely interesting. I admit to not wanting to draft a slot early last year, since we were going to play Cobb and had Rodgers. Melton was one I did have among my late wants (with Toure). He’s got some learning to do technically with his catching, he needs to add upper body strength—he’s all lower half, but he can genuinely run with the ball and, if he can get separation, is both fast and elusive.

He had a minor injury that held him back and started out with some drops before coming on really strong late in camp and preseason was beaten out by my late draft crush last year Dareke Young who also plays STs and is an athletic freak from a very small program. He is a genuine prospect “extra draft pick” with the biggest question being hand consistency. In most years he’s a mid round type.

Moore is a guy who could be our Micah Hyde in reverse. A player who should have been a S all along but was forced into playing corner. The difference is he’s only just come off a really bad injury which has both a lag between fitness and peak athleticism and can reduce that athleticism permanently. He looked to have a considerable amount back by the playoffs, which is encouraging. He’s a wild card. He could turn out to be a major steal, good depth or just a STer. He should be given the chance to compete to start, then we see if he can justify that.

7 points
8
1
golfpacker1's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:32 pm

Green, I didn't know about Moore until you stated talking about him, but he sure looks like a steal to me. And at a position we really need. It's a surprise that the Niners didn't do better with him since they are a smart, successful team. And they usually draft really well. I wanted Fred Warner badly the year he was drafted and was bummed when the Niners drafted him. They really hit with that guy.

Not like the Jets organization, who constantly miss on or can't develop promising talent. If the trade happens with the Jets, I am still hoping we get Denzel Mims back as a sweetener because like Moore, He still has a boatload of untapped potential and could be a steal if we could get it out of him. I still think he is better than Quenton Johnston and a lot cheaper.

For years I wanted GB to draft a small jitterbug slot guy like KC had so much success with. I was happy when the Packers got Amari Rodgers and I thought he would be a good get for us. He was a very good college player. He was a bust in GB but really didn't seem to get many chances. And when he did he pressed so much that he screwed up. Melton is a real sleeper for us and he will contribute this year. He would have been rated much higher if he had been with a better program. At Purdue he might have been an All American. They have been a WR factory. Look at what they did with Charlie Jones from my Iowa Hawkeye. He went from 25 catches to 106 in one year.

1 points
1
0
greengold's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:31 pm

golfpacker, great point on Mims. You’re right, he might prove a solid add/throw in by NYJ. I believe he’s in the last year of his deal = no dead cap charge for the Jets clearing the way to be added.

That slot role is perfect for Melton, and he’s got the speed to work deep as a Z receiver. He’s quite versatile and I think he’s going to have a very special career in GB.

We need depth at the X position. Too, lolz.

This draft is going to be crazy. We all probably could name 10 players we’d like for the Packers to take at both 13 & 15.

This year, I’m going to ease back and see what happens.

Do I want Quentin Johnston? Yes. Broderick Jones? Sure. Brian Branch? Insane defender. Yes. JSN? Sure. Darnell Washington? Yeah. Lucas Van Ness? Great. Calijah Klancey? Absolutely! Nolan Smith? Perfect! Carlos Gonzalez? Hell yeah. O’Cyrus Torrence? Hells to the yes! Darnell Wright?

Man, if this trade drops the way I believe it will, yeah, I could see Gutekunst taking bookend LT/RT with 13/15. Why not?

Mayer? Sure…!!!!

Gutekunst should be able to land great value with a trade down of one of those too.

A lot to like this draft for the Packers.

0 points
0
0
PatrickGB's picture

April 20, 2023 at 06:44 am

I learn more here, with the back and forth, than anywhere else. I love the posters who give opinions and reasons for their thinking. However, I do Google some of the references made. By this time I am so confused that I just wait and see what happens.

12 points
12
0
LambeauPlain's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:02 am

I am impressed by many here who really do their homework on prospects. But the CHTV prospect reviews are first rate, especially how they fit with the Pack.

5 points
5
0
NickPerry's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:03 am

I love the Packers and every morning between 3 AM and 4 AM PST I begin my day reading all the Packers content I can while I sip my morning cup of joe, ALWAYS starting with CHTV. Being a true "Homer" has it's benefits but I'll admit, I can talk myself INTO believing almost any Packers pick will turn out well.

Now there have been times even I had a hard time with who the Packers drafted (Kevin King...UGH!!!) and who they didn't (TJ Watt) and I STILL haven't gotten over that one. It took me a minute but I blame that one on Mark Murphy. God Bless Ted Thompson and all he did for this organization, but God Damn Murphy, you saw Ted every day and STILL thought he was equipped to run an NFL Franchise when EVERYBODY who watched his pressers knew he wasn't. What a fucking putz!

The last several years I've done much more "Homework" on these kids coming out who I hope will being the next Lombardi to Green Bay. BUT, I've ALWAYS understood no matter how much homework I can do in my limited time to do so, I'll NEVER know what Brian Gutekunst will know. Nope, not even in Gutes little pinky.

I'll always have my opinions about who the Packers draft or don't, BUT I never in a million years would think I know better than Gute. Just like I'm 100% certain Gute knows more than 99.999% of the CHTV posters here. This year will be no different than the previous drafts I imagine. I probably will question a pick of Gutes in the heat of the moment, say some stupid shit on sites like CHTV, but then eventually come to my senses and get on board with Gute.

Afterall, NO TEAM wins the draft on draft weekend. That comes 2, 3, or even 4 years later when we as fans find out what Gute REALLY drafted. I Can't wait!!!

16 points
17
1
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:08 am

For sure, but that can also work the opposite way. I really wanted GB to pick Patrick Queen. In hindsight it looks like they were right not to pick him.

9 points
9
0
greengold's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:09 am

I’m much the same, Nick. This year’s draft is going to be bananas. Gutekunst has so many different ways he can work this one, and, suspect our need areas change dramatically at pick #13 = Blockbuster.

I trust Gutekunst more than ever after last year’s draft. Seems he improved over previous years in finding the greatest value picks available, ant each and every draft slot. Not once did I find a pick to be a head scratcher last year.

Hoping he puts a premium on being laser focused with each & every selection, which should be a lot.

3 points
3
0
Bear's picture

April 20, 2023 at 05:21 pm

Nick, I enjoy everyone’s reaction or over reaction to draft picks. We don’t know how the nonstarters are developing or the plans to replace Bahk or Nijman possibly Preston Smith after this season because of salary cap issues. As one GM said do you draft for need or best player available, who can predict that your current best player doesn’t get hurt and you didn’t have a need until after the draft!

Enjoy the draft….

1 points
1
0
stockholder's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:11 am

Is it too much to ask for the best player of the draft?
@15- The guy should be one of the best picks our history.
I’m not asking for a miracle. Or filling a Need.
But- Why pass on a guy that could be a legend?
Ok- so the beer is talking. There are No Legends anymore.
After all, we're going to trade one for the unknown.
But - The cheesehead draft guide is always right.
Regardless of the controversy. That guide will pump us up.
And truthfully; how many of you did better on the simulators?
I didn’t have one back in the 70s and 80s.
I trusted The Packer report. And surely legends knew Legends.
But Trust can be blind. So if it’s tweeted, go with it.
Because No matter what you think.
Somebody will always tell you you're wrong.
Especially if you go against the sell job.

-9 points
2
11
Oppy's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:47 am

Just make sure to post all your Packers picks for each round at least one round before the Packers are on the clock (ideally, all in the same place, where it's easy to find) so we can check your work in the coming years.

:)

8 points
8
0
stockholder's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:01 am

This is who they should Draft .
And I've seen Mocks still showing a #13 too.

15. Nolan Smith Edge Geo. He will be better than Parsons
45. Dalton Kincaid TE Utah (Back trouble Drops him).
78. Rashee Rice. WR SMU All Day - All Night!
116 ^Trade up coming. @97 Jamie Robinson S FS. - Replaces Amos-
149. Noah Sewell. ILB Oregon - Slow ILB drop/ Back-up
170c. Charlie Jones WR Purdue -
232. Ronnie Hickman S OSU- Not a sure Tackler-
235. Hunter Luepke. FB ND State-
242. Tanner McKee QB Stanford-
252. Trade w /116

-4 points
2
6
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:36 am

If smith drops to 15, that will be as wonderful as it is surprising. The same with Kincaid reaching 45. The chances of both seem incredibly small. A GM can only draft what is available.

One pick you suggest, perhaps the only one, I think is both plausible and desirable is Robinson at S. That’s a reach according to most commentators, but I think for us it’s one I would be happy about there. He’s perhaps the best fit for us in this draft at S.

0 points
2
2
jannes bjornson's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:46 pm

Good eyes for Charlie Jones, 4th latest. Belichick will be sniffing him out. Maybe in the 3rd. His type of guy, gets open fast, catches the ball. No need to string a guy up in the air and get his ribs cracked like a two-route, post-up guy. Sewell will be gone by the end of rd two. He is a blaster, can cover the hook zones, takes no prisoners and has brains. A guy Gutedkunst will pass on. Kincaid? Kraft is better. A complete TE. He played in a Pro style offense, not an Air Raid set up. The other guy from Utah is better. Blocking guy can be sniffed out rds 6-7. Averett, or Ben Sims. I don't think Leupke gets out of the 5th. He needs to get some picks in rd six not wait around to the 7th.

0 points
0
0
stockholder's picture

April 20, 2023 at 06:51 pm

Jones size pushes him down. Under 6. Stick mover!
Sewell - most sites have him outside the top 100.
I figured it was the 4.6 and agility.
I'm still on the fence with Kincaid.
Love his adjustment to the balll.
And with the faster WRs - open all day.
Leupke is a Fb - They don't go high.
I've seen 5th As a TE? doubt it.

1 points
1
0
jannes bjornson's picture

April 21, 2023 at 12:05 am

6'-0, 190. All-American .Led the NCAA in receptions. Of course he moves the sticks. Think Edelman, Wes Welker, Amendola. Big Bad Bill is looking at this guy.
The Packer Profile bullshit from Wolf,Sr is yesterday's man. Get Players. Phillip Epps, Don Beebe, Robert Brooks was a 6'-0,180 pound guy, Bad Moon 6'-0, 187...run clean routes, have the brains to read the zones, get open fast, move the chains and score TDs. I don't read any of the draft sites. I watch them play during the season. Sewell will stuff 1st, 2nd, 3rd and goal just like Raymond. He can drift to the zones and knock O linemen backward when engaged. That was Kincaid's function for Utah. Play from the slot. Air Raid vector offense. Kraft can also block and block in space. From Pro style sets, former RB, so he has footwork. He gets the YAC and works the seams. Luepke is more RB than fullback. He can get to the perimeter. Clear spaces on the move like Juszczyk. The 49rs will watch for him.

0 points
0
0
NickPerry's picture

April 21, 2023 at 05:40 am

I love Rashee Rice. I wouldn't even be mad if they took him in the 2nd. I like Luepke too. Just a real solid FOOTBALL player who can do a lot for your football team.

0 points
0
0
NickPerry's picture

April 21, 2023 at 05:40 am

I love Rashee Rice. I wouldn't even be mad if they took him in the 2nd. I like Luepke too. Just a real solid FOOTBALL player who can do a lot for your football team. If they drafted those first 3 it's a MAJOR win though I think Smith is too small for Gute.

0 points
0
0
Oppy's picture

April 21, 2023 at 07:00 am

It doesn't matter who they "SHOULD" draft.
This is pure fantasy. You want to claim you do a better job than the pros, you need to make your picks on the clock, from the pool of available talent at the time they pick.

You don't get to play revisionist history in the future and brag about your selections that weren't even available when the Packers actually get to pick.

That's the whole point of you posting your picks in real time. You have to pick from the pool of talent that is actually available. It's not a fantasy draft at that point.

0 points
0
0
jannes bjornson's picture

April 21, 2023 at 08:18 am

No Problem. Tune in.

0 points
0
0
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:07 am

Oppy: "Just make sure to post all your Packers picks for each round at least one round before the Packers are on the clock (ideally, all in the same place, where it's easy to find) so we can check your work in the coming years."

STR: Instead of asking Stockholder to post his picks why don't you lead the way and post yours?

-4 points
2
6
Oppy's picture

April 21, 2023 at 07:07 am

Mostly because I haven't boasted that I draft multiple All-pro players every year in my mock drafts.

Mostly because I don't have the audacity to believe I'm better at a job I've never held in my life than the people who have dedicated their lives to it professionally.

I don't claim to be a draft expert. Some people do. I think those people who want to boast and brag about how good they are at it, and specifically, how bad the pros are at it, should be excited for the opportunity to prove it to the world.

I'm not one of those people. I may be critical of the outcome of a given draft, but I don't have the audacity to believe that as a part-time hobbyist I'm more qualified and accomplished than the people who do it professionally.

1 points
1
0
RCPackerFan's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:45 am

Maybe Cheesehead TV could create a post your pick article or something, each time GB is about to be going to be on the clock.

It would be great to see who people want them to take vs who they actually take.

That way we can look back and see how people actually did.

5 points
5
0
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:17 am

That is a cool idea!

5 points
5
0
BirdDogUni's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:41 pm

NFL.com used to have a "Predict the Pick" for the 1st round of the draft.

I haven't seen it this year. Last year we had a group of CHTV participants.

It was fun! ;P

0 points
0
0
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 06:40 pm

0 for 2 last year. Quite willing to admit it.

0 points
0
0
Oppy's picture

April 21, 2023 at 07:10 am

It's almost as though you're reading my mind

I only say that because I've posted multiple comments about this over the last two weeks, lol

0 points
0
0
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:55 am

Who is the best player in the draft? Damned if I know. I would appreciate you sharing. Who is the 15th best?

4 points
4
0
stockholder's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:06 am

Bijon Robinson RB

-3 points
1
4
DoubleJ's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:01 am

Bijon wasn't even as good in college as Jonathan Taylor and Taylor was an R2 pick. I guess in this draft where it is pretty thin for blue chip players Bijon might be the 15th best player. However, there is no value drafting a RB in R1 in the modern NFL. If someone wants to trade up to 15 to get Bijon then you take the deal for extra picks.

4 points
6
2
bottlefliper's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:39 am

you mean the playoff Legend after 2011? Or the leader Legend? Or the immunized Legend of the truth? It must be the blame Legend, because it was never his fault!!!

So much Legends and only one single ring for it.....

2 points
3
1
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:19 am

I thought this analysis of Brian's drafting relative to the other 31Team's GM's that Rex of Cheesehead TV provided the other day from PFF was quite independent and objective - in sum Brian has been in the bottom third or lower in rounds 2 through 7 and bottom half in round 1 - in other words, pretty terrible - I will just quote Rex's article:

Draftin' Ain't Easy: How the Packers Have Drafted Since 2017 Some teams navigate the draft waters better than others.

"How have the Packers fared at finding talent throughout the draft under general manager Brian Gutekunst? Pro Football Focus analyzed draft selections from 2011 to 2022 to see how well front offices performed in the draft, measured by “PFF wins above replacement over a four-year rookie contract.” PFF split it up into two groups: 2011-2022 and 2017-2022. I’ll focus only on the latter, as that most accurately represents how Gutekunst has performed since taking over at the helm in 2018.

The Packers ranked 17th in terms of draft success in the first round, taking into account positional value, and 7th in the NFC.

On Day 2 (rounds 2 and 3), the Packers have been below average since 2017. The team ranked 27th.

Finally, the Packers rank 21st on Day 3 (4th round to 7th round) in team draft success from 2017 until 2022.

Overall, the Packers’ draft results under Gutekunst have been nothing to write home about..."

-10 points
3
13
Racingdad's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:35 am

Again we get it you hate fo that brought us many wins Super Bowl caliber playoff teams 3-13 win seasons —- ya they all stink —- please go root for jets if you think they are better drafting near the end of every round for years is not easy it’s easy to “hit” on players when your team drafts top 5 or 10 every year not so much in late 20’s but go ahead and keep bashing if that’s your thing just do it on jets boards

9 points
11
2
LambeauPlain's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:11 am

RD, just don't feed the trolls.

8 points
8
0
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:58 am

Again we get it you hate fo that brought us many wins Super Bowl caliber playoff teams 3-13 win seasons —- ya they all stink —- please go root for jets if you think they are better drafting near the end of every round for years is not easy it’s easy to “hit” on players when your team drafts top 5 or 10 every year not so much in late 20’s but go ahead and keep bashing if that’s your thing just do it on jets boards

Racingdad,

I posted excerpts from an article Rex Shields of Cheesehead TV just posted this week:

Draftin' Ain't Easy: How the Packers Have Drafted Since 2017 Some teams navigate the draft waters better than others.

PFF rates the GMs on objective data about the players they have drafted and PFF and Rex show us that Brian is near the bottom.

Being a Die Hard Packer fan does not mean you have to IGNORE REALITY.

And another reality is that before Jordan Love in 2020 no Utah State player had been drafted in the first round since Phil Olsen 50 years earlier. That tells you that Utah State is not producing top NFL talent and their conference - the Mountain West Conference has never won a National Title. Pac 10 was produced 10 National Title winners, Jordy Nelson's Kansas State Conference, the Big 12, has produced 21 National Champions.

Just producing facts here - Jordan simply did not face top NFL bound college players/top competition and when he did face Power 5 Conference teams - LSU, Wake Forest, Michigan State he was pretty awful.

OF COURSE WE ARE GOING TO CHEER FOR JORDAN LOVE, but we don't have to HIDE REALITY. .

There is no hate here for Jordan, Aaron or any of the players, just reasoned and rational observation and data points.

My Packer friends and I have been rooting for the Packers and going to Packer games at Lambeau and across the country since the days of Bart Starr.

We always cheer for Jordan Love and all Packer Players.

We NEVER EVER BOO Jordan Love or any Packer player or any player for any team.

As fans though we do NOT cheer management - Management is not the team, management simply lives off the talents of the team. And in the case of Rodgers, Lafleur and Murphy and Gutekunst owe their continued employment to Rodgers talents,

All of my fellow Packer fan friends - all shareholders too - have called and written to Mark and Brian and voiced our opinions and displeasure with this trade and treatment of Aaron Rodgers and will continue to do so.

We are in consensus that Brian Gutekunst is destroying the team and the Rodgers trade is an ignorant irrational ego and emotion driven trade as was the drafting of Jordan Love and the Packer Management being the only team of 32 teams in the NFL to not have drafted a running back, wide receiver or tight end in the first round for the past 20 years - 2003 through 2022.

We root for the Packer players not for the egos and stupidity of the Parasitic Packer Management of Gutekunst who owes his continued employment as GM to the performance and miracles of Aaron Rodgers - as does Mark Murphy.

Hopefully the trade will fall through and Aaron will return as a backup to Jordan so that he can be there to salvage the Packers season, should Jordan fail, which based all data points and observations of Jordan in college against Power 5 Conference competition and each of the NFL preseason and regular season games Jordan has played in, he will.

That said, my Packer fan friends and I will always be cheering the Packer players - Jordan Love and all of them and NEVER EVER BOOING ANY PACKER OR ANY NFL PLAYER - win or lose as we did each game of each year from 1968 through 1991 when the Packers went through QB after QB and were in the playoffs but 2 of 23 years.

Being a fan of a team does not mean you have to cheer its SUITS who are there primarily to maximize the Collective and Profits of the 31 Billionaire Parasite Owners.

We are there as fans to cheer Jordan, Aaron, and all the players whose athletic talents create the value and are worth watching, not the parasitic Billionaire Owners and their Marines in Business Suits.

We are die hard Packer player fans, not fans of the parasites who suck value out of the blood, sweat and tears the players shed when they each week risk crippling injury, brain damage and death for our entertainment and escape from the reality of greed driven and war profiteering Billionaire Owners of these teams and the USA.

-8 points
2
10
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:56 am

You cherry picking to distort again.

You:

“Overall, the Packers’ draft results under Gutekunst have been nothing to write home about..."

Rex Shields”

“Overall, the Packers’ draft results under Gutekunst have been nothing to write home about, but he has still landed quality starters, including an All-Pro cornerback, a top-end offensive lineman, and a potentially star wide receiver. He has also found value in the later rounds, which is not an easy feat.”

Whether or not one buys Rex Shields’ assessment, it’s pretty clear you distorted his conclusion deliberately.

Go back to you bridge, troll.

5 points
6
1
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 03:19 pm

Coldworld: "You cherry picking to distort again. Whether or not one buys Rex Shields’ assessment, it’s pretty clear you distorted his conclusion deliberately. Go back to you bridge, troll."

Coldworld:

You have no objectivity at all.

All you can do is name call and try to censor anyone that provides facts - even Cheesehead TV.

Coldworld, anyone that is half awake knows that you work for the Packers General Manager & Public Relations and are paid to:

a) steer people's thinking with Packer Management Fed Propaganda diverting blame onto the Coach and Players

and

b) follow those posters around that have a critical view of Packer Management decisions, trying to discredit them as they provide simple facts.
You are on this Cheesehead TV site every day performing this function - jumping on anyone that is critical of GM Brian Gutekunst.

I didn't "cherry pick"

The assessment was from Pro Football Focus analysts who looked at “PFF wins above replacement over a four-year rookie contract.” for all players drafted by the 32 GMs. PFF's numbers showed:

"The Packers ranked 17th in terms of draft success in the first round, taking into account positional value, and 7th in the NFC.

On Day 2 (rounds 2 and 3), the Packers have been below average since 2017. The team ranked 27th.

Finally, the Packers rank 21st on Day 3 (4th round to 7th round) in team draft success from 2017 until 2022."

The PFF article Rex Shield of Cheesehead TV referenced in Rex's April 14, 2023 article:
"Draftin' Ain't Easy: How the Packers Have Drafted Since 2017
Some teams navigate the draft waters better than others. "
was titled "NFL general manager superlatives, trends: Most successful at trade-ups, best Day 3 drafters and more" and was written by Brad Spielberger on April 11, 2023.

Rex of Cheesehead Tv was just trying to be kind to Brian Gutekunst. with his qualifying "but....."

After all, even though Cheesehead TV claims at the top of their website:

"Cheesehead TV is not affiliated with the Green Bay Packers or the National Football League."

for some unknown reason: Rex and Cheeshead TV also offer that:

"We are the 1st independent fan site to be officially credentialed at a Packer Regular Season, Playoff Game & Superbowl (XLV)."

and I am sure they do not want to lose Packer Management and "The League" (i.e. the 31 Billionaires Owners) credentialing them.

-2 points
1
3
HawkPacker's picture

April 20, 2023 at 04:23 pm

Sorry but your responses are too long and I do not read them.

2 points
3
1
Racingdad's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:25 am

My take on this draft: we may take jsn, but if he’s gone the last stick and pick player to me is Darnell Wright if neither happens I could see a trade back to gain picks than a te edge and wr in second safety in third quan martin, s. Brown, or Jordan battle after that schoonmaker or whyle , than d lineman etc. we also need the ar trade to happen i would truly love 42+43 plus just a second next year maybe throw in d mims, so much talent in the second rd so many needs but I’ll be happy with whatever transpired as gb is my team and starting fresh with j love is gonna be exciting can’t wait to see how it all comes together

-3 points
3
6
T7Steve's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:28 am

The draft needs to start at the base lines and work from there.

I'll start with Miller High Life then, and only then, may work up to Miller Genuine Draft.

6 points
7
1
Racingdad's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:38 am

T7. Just no bud light please, thanks

-5 points
4
9
Irish_Cheesehead's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:51 am

Love Bud Light! I'll be having a few during the draft!

2 points
7
5
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 05:40 pm

Terrible beer. If it’s a beer at all.

2 points
2
0
mrtundra's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:54 am

Funny how a can of beer can set some people off!

9 points
10
1
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:12 am

And their reasons why are funny too.

4 points
5
1
Johnblood27's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:16 am

even more funny how 6 cans can set some people off!

5 points
6
1
LambeauPlain's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:44 am

I don't think the Belgians are seeing humor in a $7 Billion haircut in company value.

1 points
2
1
Bitternotsour's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:58 am

if it were true. it's not.

-1 points
2
3
T7Steve's picture

April 20, 2023 at 03:29 pm

Antifreeze is better than tranny fluid. Better for ice fishing.

2 points
2
0
Oppy's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:51 am

I can totally relate with this article.

I used to be a pre-draft data junkie many moons ago.
Today, I am happy to let the draft happen and research the picks after they're made.

There's hundreds of possible picks. At some point, I decided I was tired of tracking hundreds of draftees only to watch them go to other teams. I can't sway the Packers' picks, so it just saves me an awful lot of time and effort if I just research the player they've already picked to learn about the newest members of the Packers.

11 points
13
2
Guam's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:01 am

Yup, I am at the same place Oppy and it is a good place.

2 points
4
2
Johnblood27's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:17 am

You just decoded my DNA!!!

0 points
3
3
mnbadger's picture

April 20, 2023 at 12:58 pm

I too am totally with Oppy's take. So many college players, so many packer needs, so little time.
I'll put all the time in possible to learn who we actually pick instead of spending valuable hours learning about future players of other teams.
Like Tim B, I will have my favorite beverage in hand - a short pour of Redbreast Irish whiskey.
GPG!

1 points
1
0
golfpacker1's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:43 pm

I could learn from you Oppy.

0 points
0
0
Irish_Cheesehead's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:53 am

I have to agree I miss the 2-day format as well. Like everything else these days in the NFL, it's all about making more money. I'll watch Thursday and Friday, but come Saturday I'll be checking back here for updates on the later rounds.

8 points
8
0
EnemyTerritory's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:02 am

Awesome article. I know nothing about college ball but love the draft. Ditching the usual in home draft party this year to actually attend with the unwashed masses in the streets of KC (but OMG the cost of getting into the big tent is absurd…). The team has so many needs that taking BPA will also probably fill many holes. Can’t wait for the energy of the big announcement that GB has traded the future HOFer to (SF, TN, NY?) for a bigger than expected but nonetheless underwhelming haul of picks. Expecting Gutey to be active on the phones accumulating additional picks to build for the playoff run in 2024 or 2025.

GPG. (And Cheers to the Bucks for the smack down last night!)

5 points
5
0
Handsback's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:03 am

Two things I heard on the NFL radio channel about the draft…Both were from Bill Polien, GM of the Colts, a players draft status may go up a round with an outstanding Combine performance. Never will it go up more than that. He said it would take an act of Congress to do that. The second point makes sense because the most important information that they get from the Combine is the medical and mental makeup of the players, not the times they ran or distances they jumped.
Teams do their due diligence during the season not at the end. So whatever we think about a WR that runs a 4.3 during the Combine, teams already know that and have accounted that for his grade.
That is why the most accurate draft guesses are usually before the Combine.
Just MHO

4 points
4
0
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:14 am

Isn’t Polian the one who,said, “Who the hell is Mel Kiper?”
One of the great draft moments!

3 points
4
1
MainePackFan's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:49 am

I think it was Jim Irsay

-2 points
0
2
BirdDogUni's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:03 am

GM Bill Tobin...

Classic!

5 points
5
0
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:13 am

Ah, yes!

1 points
2
1
MainePackFan's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:46 am

You're right Bird. Do I get points for having the owner right : )

0 points
0
0
LambeauPlain's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:28 am

Ted Thompson tended to draft prospects with a solid resume of college production...and his secret ingredients...guys who also loved the game and possessed high character.

Gutey does that too...but he has also focused more on athleticism (RAS, etc) than TT. Wolf was not as good drafting as TT, but he was urgent and decisive acquiring FAs and with trades. Reggie, Favre, Dotson, Jones, Brown, Risen, Desmond, etc.

5 points
6
1
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:14 am

Yes! And Wolf’s exit was hastened because he said it was getting too hard to make trades.

2 points
3
1
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:37 am

Who was the last Utah State player drafted in the first round before Jordan Love in 2020?

Phil Olsen 50 years earlier in 1970.

What does that say about Utah State and the level of competition Jordan Love faced?

-11 points
1
12
jannes bjornson's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:35 am

Josh Allen, another California guy played at Wyoming ( Mt West); The Carr brothers @ Fresno State(Mt West); Brett Rypien @ Boise State( Mt West). Ohio State has Fields playing for the Bears, after following a stellar group like Haskins, Terrelle Pryor, Art Schlicter, etc.

2 points
2
0
Swisch's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:18 pm

I didn't know this before today, but apparently Phil Olsen was the younger brother of Merlin Olsen, who also played at Utah State.
Remarkably, Merlin made the Pro Bowl his first 14 seasons as a defensive tackle in the NFL, out of a total of 15 seasons, all with the Rams. For part of his career, he was part of a defensive line famously called the Fearsome Foursome.
It seems Phil had a good career, as well, including two seasons starting alongside his brother, both as defensive tackles for the Rams. He was limited by knee injuries, the first of which came at the old College All-Star Game, and inadvertently involved Mike McCoy, a defensive tackle who would play for the Packers.
I guess any relevancy of all of this is that good football players can come from just about anywhere.
Whatever any of us thinks about the drafting of Jordan Love, we can unite in hoping he is the next great player from Utah State.

0 points
0
0
x24's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:39 am

The BEST part of the draft?

Counting down the days until Mel Kiper Jr retreats once again to his underground catacombs

6 points
7
1
KnockTheSnotOutOfYou's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:00 am

Thats funny x24

0 points
2
2
x24's picture

April 20, 2023 at 12:09 pm

Watch with the sound off, and tell me he does not look like a dog drinking from a hose

-2 points
0
2
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:42 am

Again we get it you hate fo that brought us many wins Super Bowl caliber playoff teams 3-13 win seasons —- ya they all stink —- please go root for jets if you think they are better drafting near the end of every round for years is not easy it’s easy to “hit” on players when your team drafts top 5 or 10 every year not so much in late 20’s but go ahead and keep bashing if that’s your thing just do it on jets boards

Racingdad,

There is no hate here for Jordan, Aaron or any of the players, just reasoned and rational observation and data points.

My Packer friends and I have been rooting for the Packers and going to Packer games at Lambeau and across the country since the days of Bart Starr.

We always cheer for Jordan Love and all Packer Players.

We NEVER EVER BOO Jordan Love or any Packer player or any player for any team.

As fans though we do NOT cheer management - Management is not the team, management simply lives off the talents of the team. And in the case of Rodgers, Lafleur and Murphy and Gutekunst owe their continued employment to Rodgers talents,

All of my fellow Packer fan friends - all shareholders too - have called and written to Mark and Brian and voiced our opinions and displeasure with this trade and treatment of Aaron Rodgers and will continue to do so.

We are in consensus that Brian Gutekunst is destroying the team and the Rodgers trade is an ignorant irrational ego and emotion driven trade as was the drafting of Jordan Love and the Packer Management being the only team of 32 teams in the NFL to not have drafted a running back, wide receiver or tight end in the first round for the past 20 years - 2003 through 2022.

We root for the Packer players not for the egos and stupidity of the Parasitic Packer Management of Gutekunst who owes his continued employment as GM to the performance and miracles of Aaron Rodgers - as does Mark Murphy.

Hopefully the trade will fall through and Aaron will return as a backup to Jordan so that he can be there to salvage the Packers season, should Jordan fail, which based all data points and observations of Jordan in college against Power 5 Conference competition and each of the NFL preseason and regular season games Jordan has played in, he will.

That said, my Packer fan friends and I will always be cheering the Packer players - Jordan Love and all of them and NEVER EVER BOOING ANY PACKER OR ANY NFL PLAYER - win or lose as we did each game of each year from 1968 through 1991 when the Packers went through QB after QB and were in the playoffs but 2 of 23 years.

Being a fan of a team does not mean you have to cheer its SUITS who are there primarily to maximize the Collective and Profits of the 31 Billionaire Parasite Owners.

We are there as fans to cheer Jordan, Aaron, and all the players whose athletic talents create the value and are worth watching, not the parasitic Billionaire Owners and their Marines in Business Suits.

We are die hard Packer player fans, not fans of the parasites who suck value out of the blood, sweat and tears the players shed when they each week risk crippling injury, brain damage and death for our entertainment and escape from the reality of greed driven and war profiteering Billionaire Owners of these teams and the USA.

-13 points
2
15
Oppy's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:35 am

As a Packers fan and shareholder, surely you must understand that the Packers are a not-for-profit organization without a "greed driven and war profiteering Billionaire Owner".

3 points
3
0
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:55 am

As a Packers fan and shareholder, surely you must understand that the Packers are a not-for-profit organization without a "greed driven and war profiteering Billionaire Owner".

Oppy,

31 Colluding Billionaire Owners that control the NFL - and the Packers - are interested, in Maximizing Revenues that are shared equally among the 31 Billionaire and the Packers. Their teams winning are secondary to these 31 Parasites pulling as much revenue out of their NFL operation as possible. The New York NFL television market is a huge asset and underperforming. Murphy and Brian will fall in line with the 31 Billionaire's wishes or they will not have their jobs for long.

Oppy, that is just reality

-4 points
1
5
Bitternotsour's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:05 am

conversely, those self-same monopolists will force the jets hand to get with the program.

regardless, the narrrative, the drama, is good for the draft, and good for the league.

that said, i don't doubt that Mark Murphy would sell out the franchise for the promise of a league front office job, post- forced retirement from the packers.

0 points
2
2
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 12:06 pm

“ARTHUR: Well ... I AM king.

DENNIS: Oh, very nice. King, eh! I expect you've got a palace and fine clothes and courtiers and plenty of food. And how d'you get that? By exploiting the workers! By hanging on to outdated imperialist dogma which perpetuates the social and economic differences in our society! If there's EVER going to be any progress ...

[An OLD WOMAN appears.]

OLD WOMAN:

DENNIS:! There's some lovely filth down here ... Oh! how d'you do?

ARTHUR: How d'you do, good lady ... I am Arthur, King of the Britons ... can you tell me who lives in that castle?

OLD WOMAN: King of the WHO?

ARTHUR: The Britons.

OLD WOMAN: Who are the Britons?

ARTHUR: All of us are ... we are all Britons. [DENNIS winks at the OLD WOMAN.] ... and I am your king ....

OLD WOMAN: Ooooh! I didn't know we had a king. I thought we were an autonomous collective ...

DENNIS: You're fooling yourself. We're living in a dictatorship, A self-perpetuating autocracy in which the working classes ...

OLD WOMAN: There you are, bringing class into it again ...

DENNIS: That's what it's all about ... If only -

ARTHUR: Please, please good people. I am in haste. What knight lives in that castle?

OLD WOMAN: No one lives there.

ARTHUR: Well, who is your lord?

OLD WOMAN: We don't have a lord.

ARTHUR: What?

DENNIS: I told you, We're an anarcho-syndicalist commune, we take it in turns to act as a sort of executive officer for the week.

ARTHUR: Yes.

DENNIS: ... But all the decision of that officer ...

ARTHUR: Yes, I see.

DENNIS: ... must be approved at a bi-weekly meeting by a simple majority in the case of purely internal affairs.

ARTHUR: Be quiet!

DENNIS: ... but a two-thirds majority ...

ARTHUR: Be quiet! I order you to shut up.

OLD WOMAN: Order, eh -- who does he think he is?

ARTHUR: I am your king!

OLD WOMAN: Well, I didn't vote for you.

ARTHUR: You don't vote for kings.

OLD WOMAN: Well, how did you become king, then?

ARTHUR: The Lady of the Lake, her arm clad in the purest shimmering samite, held Excalibur aloft from the bosom of the water to signify by Divine Providence ... that I, Arthur, was to carry Excalibur ... That is why I am your king!

OLD WOMAN: Is Frank in? He'd be able to deal with this one.

DENNIS: Look, strange women lying on their backs in ponds handing out swords ... that's no basis for a system of government. Supreme executive power derives from a mandate from the masses, not from some farcical aquatic ceremony.”

The sad fact is that Python’s surrealism is not only funnier than your screeds, but conveys more meaning, taken at face value. It’s also shorter.

3 points
5
2
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:29 pm

Tis but a scratch!!

1 points
1
0
golfpacker1's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:48 pm

Get the aluminum foil out and make your hat Starr. Conspiracy theorist =TOOL. Go be a Jet.

1 points
2
1
Oppy's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:38 pm

So you're actually implying that Rodgers to the Jets is fueled by a league-wide desire to "maximize" an under-performing NY TV Market? That's what you're saying?

Uhhh... okay. Get a grip.

1 points
1
0
bottlefliper's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:46 am

many wins Super Bowl caliber playoff teams.....only to go nowhere because the QB was not on his best when it really counts, even he had more weapons than most if not all.

Im really afraid all the one and done is over and all the negativity, all the eyerolling and the fingerpointing. The toxic looks and the blaming everybody else.

But I guess I taking the risk and welcom back the joy of football

2 points
2
0
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:31 pm

Why are you leaving out the space lasers?

1 points
1
0
Johnblood27's picture

April 23, 2023 at 07:35 am

space laser dreams felled the Soviet Union...

just sayin'...

0 points
0
0
croatpackfan's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:43 am

As I'm probably the less experience fooball fan here, that doesn't stop me to learn fast and look what I find out several years ago. All football operation parts are undoubtedly team work. From draft, practicing, coaching, playing. There was no situation in football in which one man can produce win or loss.

Same is with draft, practice, coaching, playing. Brian Gutekunst is not the person who alone make draft boards for Packers. In creating Packers draft boards there are so many persons you may never think they have any influence. To name few: field scouts from HS, college level, from in building scouts to personnel departmen, HC and his coaching staff (with their vision and requests). Brian Gutekunst is just the guy who call the names on draft days, trade up or down the positions to select players all of them want or think to be the right choice. Brian Gutekunst is not just for drafting, although some of his responsibilities as GM were taken away from MM, he also has to take care of constant roster upgrade, overseeing salary cap (also limited), decisions who to cut, when and why (in coordinance with HC) and others I can even imagine what.

Same you have with HC, he has lot of responsibilities, too. And from what we saw last 4 seasons he seems not to be so good in all of his responsibilities. That is why I'm so hard on him. It looks like he only cares about offensive side of the team. I respect that he had very hot potato in his hands to deal with and that maybe the reason why he seems to lack of overview other responsibilities, but nevertheless, he should not allow that.

Taking all that in consideration, I can not be so person orientated when we are talking about drafting process. That process is team project and whole team should bare responsibilities.

On the other hand, when you have CEO who wants to be like other owners and mess into your job, it is hard to know who is the culprit at the end.

So, my fellow Packers fans, to be the part of the team you have to silence yourself and find a way to start breathing and living as unit made of many different personalities. To be the leader is even harder and ask for even deeper feeling of humility and to give yourself to the team completely. That does not mean that you can not talk about things you feel they are wrong, it means that you have to serve not to rule.

And I want to point, one more time again what Ron Wolf said about draft: "Men, this is not my pick or your pick. It’s our pick. It’s the Green Bay Packers’ pick. We’re picking for the Packers."

Thank you.

2 points
2
0
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:30 am

CPF: "All football operation parts are undoubtedly team work. From draft, practicing, coaching, playing. There was no situation in football in which one man can produce win or loss.

Same is with draft, practice, coaching, playing. Brian Gutekunst is not the person who alone make draft boards for Packers. In creating Packers draft boards there are so many persons you may never think they have any influence. To name few: field scouts from HS, college level, from in building scouts to personnel departmen, HC and his coaching staff (with their vision and requests)."

STR: All very true CRP, but Brian as the GM is responsible for hiring these "field scouts from HS, college level, from in building scouts to personnel departmen"

CPF: On the other hand, when you have CEO who wants to be like other owners and mess into your job

STR: CPF, Murphy is President and responsible for Gutekunst job performance, but there is no evidence that Murphy is "messing into Brian's job" That's like Greengold and Oppy and other Rodgers haters saying that Rodgers doesn't help the receivers, isn't like by his teammates, etc. isn't a good person. is "elitist scum" blah blah blah, when Greengold and Oppy have never met Rodgers and Rodgers, and Christian Watson and Aaron Jones just last month said how much Aaron Rodgers has helped - Watson said he just spoke to Rodgers - and how Jones wanted Rodgers back

Here is the original Press Release of Murphy/Packers making Brian the GM. The release EXPLICITLY says Brian:

"will have complete control over all roster decisions, including the NFL draft and free agency, while leading Green Bay’s scouting department"

"We could not be more excited to elevate Brian to the position of general manager," Murphy said in a statement. "He has earned this opportunity throughout his 19 years with the Packers, proving to not only be a skilled talent evaluator, but a trusted and collaborative leader. His time under the direction of former Packers general managers Ron Wolf and Ted Thompson will undoubtedly serve him well as we work toward our next Super Bowl championship. I am confident that he is the man that will help get us there."

The 10th person to hold the title of general manager for the Packers, Gutekunst (pronounced GOO-tuh-kunst) will have complete control over all roster decisions, including the NFL draft and free agency, while leading Green Bay’s scouting department.

"I look forward to getting to work with the rest of our talented personnel department and using every avenue available to build the Packers into a championship team again," Gutekunst said.

Ball was considered by some as the favorite for the GM job because of his closeness with Thompson, who is remaining with the team as a senior advisor to football operations. But in making Ball the executive vice president/director of football operations instead, the Packers were able to double down on his non-scouting skills and better share the responsibilities of the front office. Since joining Green Bay in 2008, Ball has worked in the role of the vice president of football administration/player finance, though in recent years he committed to watching videotape with Thompson and learning more about talent evaluation to improve as a GM candidate.

As he did in his previous role, Ball will continue to manage the Packers’ salary cap and serve as the chief contract negotiator, while also overseeing several areas in football operations.

"Since joining the Packers in 2008, Russ has proven to be invaluable," Murphy said. "His salary-cap management and negotiating abilities are well known, but he has also provided tremendous leadership throughout football operations and served as a valuable liaison between the football and business sides of the organization. His diverse skills will remain important to our success moving forward, and I look forward to working with him even more closely in his new role."

By promoting Gutekunst and Ball to replace Thompson, the Packers effectively keep two executives who have worked closely together for nearly a decade in their own lanes while not overextending either with many new and unfamiliar duties. They’ve got a football scout as their general manager, as they’ve had since 1991, and they’ve got a finance guy in charge of administration. Gutekunst will scout and draft players, sign free agents and make trades – the latter in presumably a more aggressive fashion than his predecessor – while Ball will have a hand in essentially every operational facet of the organization.

It’s a more effective balance of power, ideas and decision-making, and it also maintains some continuity for a franchise that – despite last season’s collapse – has been one of the most consistently successful in the league over the past decade. Hiring a general manager from outside the organization would have risked excessive upheaval; appointing Ball as GM could have irked head coach Mike McCarthy, who made comments late in the year about "fit" that suggested he wanted a traditional personnel man in the position. The biggest question that remains now is about the future of Eliot Wolf, the director of football operations and son of Ron, who was passed over and could leave the organization he grew up in to pursue a GM job somewhere else.

As part of Monday’s news, Murphy also announced a change in the Packers’ organizational structure: Gutekunst, Ball and McCarthy will all report directly to Murphy. Previously, only the general manager reported to Murphy, who joined the team in 2008 and serves as its CEO and highest-ranking employee. Perhaps, Murphy, who has made the two biggest moves of his 10-year tenure in the past week – reassigning Thompson and hiring his replacements – is positioning himself to be more directly involved in Green Bay’s decision-making. At the very least, while Gutekunst will have total control over the Packers' roster, the restructuring gives authority only to Murphy to hire and fire the head coach.

"The process of identifying our next general manager gave us the opportunity to analyze our entire football operation," Murphy said. "While we have enjoyed a lot of success, we need to improve. With that in mind, the head coach, general manager and executive vice president/director of football operations will report to me moving forward. While I understand this is a departure from the Packers’ current structure, it will serve to increase the breadth and frequency of communication and collaboration. Ultimately, it will make the Packers better."

Gutekunst, who is entering his 20th year with the organization, spent the past two seasons as the director of player personnel after serving as director of college scouting for four years. He previously worked 11 seasons as a college scout in the Southeast region and, prior to that, was a scout for the East Coast region from 1999-2000. Before joining the Packers full-time, Gutekunst was a scouting assistant for the Kansas City Chiefs in 1998, a scouting intern for Green Bay in the summer of 1997 and assisted the New Orleans Saints’ coaching staff in training camp in 1995.
"First, I’d like to thank my mentor, Ted Thompson, for his friendship, and I am happy that we will continue to have the chance to work together," Gutekunst said. "I want to thank Ron Wolf for giving me my first opportunity with the Packers, and of course Mark Murphy for the faith and trust he has placed in me moving forward. And finally, I must thank my wife, Jen, and our children for their constant sacrifice and unwavering support despite all of the time I have spent on the road and away from home."

Gutekunst played football for two years at the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse and served as an assistant coach during his final two years at the school (1995-96) after a shoulder injury cut short his playing career. In 1995, he coached the linebackers as the Eagles finished 14-0 and won the Division III national championship.

Ball is entering his 30th year in the NFL and 11th season in Green Bay. Since joining the Packers in 2008, he has worked in the role of the vice president of football administration/player finance.

Prior to coming to Green Bay, Ball spent six seasons with the New Orleans Saints, serving as senior football administrator for four seasons and as vice president of football administration for the final two years. In 2001, he was the director of football administration for the Washington Redskins.

From 1999 to 2000, Ball served as senior football administrator for the Minnesota Vikings. He began working in the NFL with the Kansas City Chiefs, where he spent 10 seasons (1989-98), the final two in football operations as administrative assistant to then-head coach Marty Schottenheimer. He began his career with the Chiefs as an assistant strength and conditioning coach.

A 1981 graduate of Central Missouri State, Ball was a four-year letterman at center for the Mules. He served as head strength and conditioning coach at the University of Missouri from 1982 to '89 and earned his master’s degree from Missouri in 1990.

-6 points
3
9
croatpackfan's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:48 pm

I always likes people who did not want to check facts first, than to keep lectures to the others.

GM job by description is managing football operations - that means: GM construct roster, leading dfraft day choices by collectively made draft board, hiring and firing HC(s), taking care of salary cap and with associates following all avalable players that can help team during the season, post season and pre-season, and collecting information from all sources of possible future players.

Ted Thompson hired Mike McCarthy, not Mark Murphy and Mike McCarthy is his decision and Mike McCarthy was responsible for the work to Ted Thompson, not Mark Murphy! Russ Ball was responsible for his work to Ted Thompson, not to Mark Murphy. OK! Fact check!

Fact check - Mark Murphy clearly stated at the beginning of the after Ted Thompson era that he change the structure of how football operation are functioning, because there was some problems in the communications between HC, GM and Russ Ball. So he positioned himself over all 3 positions and make them to report to him, not as was establish from Ron Wolf, through Ted Thompson era. Brian Gutekunst HAS NO AUTHORITY TO FIRE MLF! Why? Because MLF reports to Mark Murphy, not to Brian Gutekunst! Brian Gutekunst HAS NO AUTHORITY OVER RUSS BALL, so consequently HAS NOT AUTHORITY OVER SALARY CAP ISSUES! Why? Because Russ Ball reports to Mark Murphy.

Mark Murphy clearly stated that he hired MLF, after just one short interview. He hired HC who had not interview for HC job from any other team, which is ridiculous and huge irresponsibility. He announced that Packers signed new contract with ACR for ridiculous ammount of money and that he did because "WE ARE NOT IDIOTS".

If all of that is not messing with jobs other GMs in NFL have, you should think that again. He publicly said that he participates in the Packers Jets negotiations for trading ACR. If that is not messing with GM's job of constructing roster, how would you call it? He already f*ucked twice those negotiations by his statements, after that he was asked to shut up, by his own words. If that is not messing with GM's job, how you'll call it?

I do not care what any person did in his previous life. It is not about past, it is about present and future. Start to think about short and long future of the Packers organization. Short and long Packers future does not contain Aaron Charles Rodgers. It is very clear and there is a lot of reasons why. We can respect past and learn from it, but we can not be prisoners of the past as you and some other posters indicate are. There is no progress in the past. Enjoy in good memories, learn from bad ones and move on to the future.

That is my advice to you. Sorry if you miss January 2019 public explanation made by Mark Murphy how is new football operation scheme made. That is past that has huge negative influence on the future of organization I'm fan of. Fan w/o any other benefit for that, than my involment in specific organization in the whole US sports.

I will be sad if Packers will be losing w/o hope, if they will be losing with hope that there will be improvement, I will wait. I have patience. If somehow Packers start to excell immediately I will be happy. That is all. And I will comment only on the things I see, know and I have experience from life and learning.

My friendly advice is to less listen what others say, if you must, also look at how they say what they say. Than make conclusions after you get result from the either promised, done or missed actions and results. So more is to look at the results. Not just listen what others says. Mostly those are untruthfull explanations...

5 points
5
0
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 05:48 pm

Dear CPF,

It is very clear from the Packer press release:

"The 10th person to hold the title of general manager for the Packers, Gutekunst (pronounced GOO-tuh-kunst) will have complete control over all roster decisions, including the NFL draft and free agency, while leading Green Bay’s scouting department."

that Brian and the staff Brian oversees and hires chooses the college draft picks, free agents and who he wishes to trade or trade for and Brian goes to Ball to see the salary cap implications.

It makes more sense to have a the effective Chief Financial Officer (essentially Ball) when it comes to player salary caps on the same level as the General Manager, reporting to the President.

Same with the Coach.

Brian should simply be focusing on evaluating talent with financial input from the financial expert Ball and input from the Coach Lafleur on what Matt thinks is needed.

I don't have a problem with all 3 positions reporting to the President.

I have a problem with the EGOS of the individuals involved - MURPHY AND GUTEKUNST - and how their JEAALOUSY OF RODGERS AND EMOTIONS have driven IGNORANT moves of 1) drafting Love and 2) not drafting offensive weapons these last 20 years, 3) alienating Davante, MVS, Tonyan, Reed, Barnes, etc. and then 4) disrespecting the longest tenured Packer - 18 years - in history, who will play out his full 4 remaining years at a high level - higher than Jordan Love, who has shown no evidence of being a Franchise NFL QB, either in stiff college competition or any of this pro games.

-1 points
1
2
croatpackfan's picture

April 21, 2023 at 07:33 am

""The 10th person to hold the title of general manager for the Packers, Gutekunst (pronounced GOO-tuh-kunst) will have complete control over all roster decisions, including the NFL draft and free agency, while leading Green Bay’s scouting department.""

You just confirm what I'm saying.

You can give the title to any employee by your choice, like CEO of the whole universe (CEOWU), but it is not about the title, it is about what is written under the title - THE JOB DESCRIPTION. So, by your own part of the post it is obvious that for Mark Murphy GM job is just draft and roster decisions. No authorities about HC and coaching staff, no authorities to overview Salary Cap. And those 2 important parts of GM job were taken from his hand.

Now, you just jump to your own mouth and blow your own brain to dust! Thank you for confirming my claims by your post!

0 points
0
0
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 22, 2023 at 01:16 am

CPF, my response below:

STR: ""The 10th person to hold the title of general manager for the Packers, Gutekunst (pronounced GOO-tuh-kunst) will have complete control over all roster decisions, including the NFL draft and free agency, while leading Green Bay’s scouting department.""

CPF: You just confirm what I'm saying.

You can give the title to any employee by your choice, like CEO of the whole universe (CEOWU), but it is not about the title, it is about what is written under the title - THE JOB DESCRIPTION. So, by your own part of the post it is obvious that for Mark Murphy GM job is just draft and roster decisions. No authorities about HC and coaching staff, no authorities to overview Salary Cap. And those 2 important parts of GM job were taken from his hand.

STR: CPF, the Packers have just finished going 13-3, 13-3, 13-4 and were 3-1 until Rodgers broke the thumb on his throwing hand and other injuries started to hit.

That 42 wins and 11 loss record was the best of all 32 NFL teams.

Clearly the drop off the last 13 weeks of the season was due primarily to:

1) Injuries:

a) the Injuries on defense:

Stokes (8 games non contact Detroit artificial turf injury), Barnes (8 games), Gary (8 games non contact Detroit artificial turf injury), Campbell on defense

b) the injuries on offense

among the receivers Watson (2 games and was pulled from other games with injuries), Cobb (5 games), Doubs (3 games) , Watkins (4 games), Lazard (1 game) all missed games and Jenkins and Bakhtiari (2 games) coming back and shuffling of the line and clearly the thumb injury to Rodgers for the last 13 games

2) Gutekunst ALIENATING and losing Davante Adams and then MVS.

5 of the Packers losses last year were by 7 points or less and of those 5 losses.
The Packers could have easily been 13 and 4 again last year, with a handful of plays going their way, not even considering the injuries and Gutekunst - and Ball too in all likelihood - destruction of the offense starting with the disrespect and alienation of Davante and MVS.

Sure some of the play calls by Lafleur - especially in the red zone - were questionable, especially trying to run Aaron Jones up the middle when it is clear that Dillon is a better alternative and even then failure is assured more times than not because Myers is not getting any push and is getting manhandled and Runyan's not doing much better.

Barry's early season over reliance on zone defense hurt too.

But Lafleur was the head coach in 2019, 2020, 2021 and first 4 games of 2022 too and the Packers were the winningest team in football during that 53 game period.

Barry was there in 2021 and the Packers were 13-4. Both in 2021 and 2022 the Packers on defense gave up the same 371 points which left the Packers ranked 13th (points allowed) and 9th (yards allowed)in 2021 and 17th in 2022 in both points allowed and yards allowed.

CPF: Now, you just jump to your own mouth and blow your own brain to dust! Thank you for confirming my claims by your post!

STR: Sounds a little extreme CPF.

I just don't find Lafleur or Barry's coaching as the PREDOMINANT reason the Packers fell off 5 games last year.

I see the 5 game fall off being:

1) Injuries and adjustments from coming back from injuries 60%

2) Brian's - and I will throw in Russ Ball too - and Russ Ball's disrespect for Davante and MVS and poor drafting choices (Love and Myers as 2 prime examples)

And now I see Brian, Ball and Murphy's disrespect for Rodgers - after the same disrespect with Davante (i.e franchising him after 8 loyal and dependable years) and MVS - leading to the alienation and loss of Tonyan, Lazards, Reed and Barnes - clearly valuable and affordable for the Packers, given what the Bears, Jets, Seahawks and Arizona paid.

CFB, I completely follow Murphy's logic - and the Executive Committee was probably also involved - in not wanting to make Ball the GM, when he had limited experience in scouting and player evaluation and I completely follow Murphy's logic in not wanting to integrate salary cap analysis and management and salary negotiations into Gutekunst's responsibilities, given Gutekunst's lack of experience in those areas. This passage below is sensible and logical:

By promoting Gutekunst and Ball to replace Thompson, the Packers effectively keep two executives who have worked closely together for nearly a decade in their own lanes while not overextending either with many new and unfamiliar duties. They’ve got a football scout as their general manager, as they’ve had since 1991, and they’ve got a finance guy in charge of administration. Gutekunst will scout and draft players, sign free agents and make trades – the latter in presumably a more aggressive fashion than his predecessor – while Ball will have a hand in essentially every operational facet of the organization.

It’s a more effective balance of power, ideas and decision-making, and it also maintains some continuity for a franchise that – despite last season’s collapse – has been one of the most consistently successful in the league over the past decade. Hiring a general manager from outside the organization would have risked excessive upheaval; appointing Ball as GM could have irked head coach Mike McCarthy, who made comments late in the year about "fit" that suggested he wanted a traditional personnel man in the position. The biggest question that remains now is about the future of Eliot Wolf, the director of football operations and son of Ron, who was passed over and could leave the organization he grew up in to pursue a GM job somewhere else.

As part of Monday’s news, Murphy also announced a change in the Packers’ organizational structure: Gutekunst, Ball and McCarthy will all report directly to Murphy. Previously, only the general manager reported to Murphy, who joined the team in 2008 and serves as its CEO and highest-ranking employee.

CPF, it sounds like Murphy created a new position for Ball which puts him on the same level in the organizational chart as Gutekunst and Lafleur.

So Ball, Gutenkunst and Lafleur all bring their knowledge and skills to the table when it to player additions and subtractions and come to a consensus and then Murphy meets with all 3 and agrees or disagrees with the consensus.

Even if Ball and Lafleur were directly reporting to Gutekunst, Gutekunst still reports to Murphy and Murphy - or any President - would still have input and final say anyway on major player and coaching decisions and be ultimately responsible for the success or failure of the team.

There is no public indication by Gutekunst that he feels he is being undermined by Murphy.

Unless of course Brian Gutekunst is communicating his displeasure through Coldworld on this and other Packer websites as I have never seen a poster to a website spend the complete day posting after post chasing down every critique of Packer GM Gutekunst.

CPF, here is more of the passage from the Packer January 2018 press release:

Ball was considered by some as the favorite for the GM job because of his closeness with Thompson, who is remaining with the team as a senior advisor to football operations. But in making Ball the executive vice president/director of football operations instead, the Packers were able to double down on his non-scouting skills and better share the responsibilities of the front office. Since joining Green Bay in 2008, Ball has worked in the role of the vice president of football administration/player finance, though in recent years he committed to watching videotape with Thompson and learning more about talent evaluation to improve as a GM candidate.

As he did in his previous role, Ball will continue to manage the Packers’ salary cap and serve as the chief contract negotiator, while also overseeing several areas in football operations.

"Since joining the Packers in 2008, Russ has proven to be invaluable," Murphy said. "His salary-cap management and negotiating abilities are well known, but he has also provided tremendous leadership throughout football operations and served as a valuable liaison between the football and business sides of the organization. His diverse skills will remain important to our success moving forward, and I look forward to working with him even more closely in his new role."

By promoting Gutekunst and Ball to replace Thompson, the Packers effectively keep two executives who have worked closely together for nearly a decade in their own lanes while not overextending either with many new and unfamiliar duties. They’ve got a football scout as their general manager, as they’ve had since 1991, and they’ve got a finance guy in charge of administration. Gutekunst will scout and draft players, sign free agents and make trades – the latter in presumably a more aggressive fashion than his predecessor – while Ball will have a hand in essentially every operational facet of the organization.

It’s a more effective balance of power, ideas and decision-making, and it also maintains some continuity for a franchise that – despite last season’s collapse – has been one of the most consistently successful in the league over the past decade. Hiring a general manager from outside the organization would have risked excessive upheaval; appointing Ball as GM could have irked head coach Mike McCarthy, who made comments late in the year about "fit" that suggested he wanted a traditional personnel man in the position. The biggest question that remains now is about the future of Eliot Wolf, the director of football operations and son of Ron, who was passed over and could leave the organization he grew up in to pursue a GM job somewhere else.

As part of Monday’s news, Murphy also announced a change in the Packers’ organizational structure: Gutekunst, Ball and McCarthy will all report directly to Murphy. Previously, only the general manager reported to Murphy, who joined the team in 2008 and serves as its CEO and highest-ranking employee. Perhaps, Murphy, who has made the two biggest moves of his 10-year tenure in the past week – reassigning Thompson and hiring his replacements – is positioning himself to be more directly involved in Green Bay’s decision-making. At the very least, while Gutekunst will have total control over the Packers' roster, the restructuring gives authority only to Murphy to hire and fire the head coach.

"The process of identifying our next general manager gave us the opportunity to analyze our entire football operation," Murphy said. "While we have enjoyed a lot of success, we need to improve. With that in mind, the head coach, general manager and executive vice president/director of football operations will report to me moving forward. While I understand this is a departure from the Packers’ current structure, it will serve to increase the breadth and frequency of communication and collaboration. Ultimately, it will make the Packers better."

Gutekunst, who is entering his 20th year with the organization, spent the past two seasons as the director of player personnel after serving as director of college scouting for four years. He previously worked 11 seasons as a college scout in the Southeast region and, prior to that, was a scout for the East Coast region from 1999-2000. Before joining the Packers full-time, Gutekunst was a scouting assistant for the Kansas City Chiefs in 1998, a scouting intern for Green Bay in the summer of 1997 and assisted the New Orleans Saints’ coaching staff in training camp in 1995.

"First, I’d like to thank my mentor, Ted Thompson, for his friendship, and I am happy that we will continue to have the chance to work together," Gutekunst said. "I want to thank Ron Wolf for giving me my first opportunity with the Packers, and of course Mark Murphy for the faith and trust he has placed in me moving forward. And finally, I must thank my wife, Jen, and our children for their constant sacrifice and unwavering support despite all of the time I have spent on the road and away from home."

Gutekunst played football for two years at the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse and served as an assistant coach during his final two years at the school (1995-96) after a shoulder injury cut short his playing career. In 1995, he coached the linebackers as the Eagles finished 14-0 and won the Division III national championship.

Ball is entering his 30th year in the NFL and 11th season in Green Bay. Since joining the Packers in 2008, he has worked in the role of the vice president of football administration/player finance.

Prior to coming to Green Bay, Ball spent six seasons with the New Orleans Saints, serving as senior football administrator for four seasons and as vice president of football administration for the final two years. In 2001, he was the director of football administration for the Washington Redskins.

From 1999 to 2000, Ball served as senior football administrator for the Minnesota Vikings. He began working in the NFL with the Kansas City Chiefs, where he spent 10 seasons (1989-98), the final two in football operations as administrative assistant to then-head coach Marty Schottenheimer. He began his career with the Chiefs as an assistant strength and conditioning coach.

A 1981 graduate of Central Missouri State, Ball was a four-year letterman at center for the Mules. He served as head strength and conditioning coach at the University of Missouri from 1982 to '89 and earned his master’s degree from Missouri in 1990.

0 points
1
1
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:34 pm

Looks like we are surrounded by complicated fellas.

2 points
2
0
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 03:24 pm

It seems you totally fail to grasp the significance of what you are quoting. You think that supports your position? It doesn’t.

5 points
5
0
LambeauPlain's picture

April 20, 2023 at 08:50 am

Who would be your BAP selected with #15 that would surprise/shock you?

Mine would be selecting Bijan Robinson, RB.

1 points
2
1
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:03 am

"Who would be your BAP selected with #15 that would surprise/shock you?"

Hendon Hooker.

-8 points
1
9
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 03:03 pm

The guy you proved yourself to have no knowledge about 2 days ago?

You are full of it.

2 points
2
0
BirdDogUni's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:26 am

Mine would be:

Michael Mayer or JSN...

2 points
2
0
stockholder's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:50 am

D.J Carter- DL Geo.
He will drop.

1 points
2
1
jannes bjornson's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:59 pm

Pass on this guy.

2 points
2
0
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 03:41 pm

Jalen Carter if he fell. If he’s not ruled out on character. Unlikely I admit.

2 points
2
0
stockholder's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:45 pm

Don't let it shock you. He's the best player in the draft.
Does he fit in GB. Yes- if Dillion leaves.
Would we have to Defense against him? - Yes
In fact the Lions won by defensing against Jones.
Are DL isn't good enough to defense against him.
So take him. He's better than Cook. And if Jones is hurt?

0 points
2
2
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 21, 2023 at 01:44 am

"Who would be your BAP selected with #15 that would surprise/shock you?"

Hendon Hooker, QB, Tennessee

-1 points
1
2
RCPackerFan's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:15 am

I am very similar to you in that in my younger days I was watching as much college football as possible to scout players. I loved doing it. Unfortunately I don't have time to do that much anymore. Badgers are my college team and I am usually watching recordings of them or listening to them on the radio.

But unlike you I watch every minute of the draft. I absolutely love it! I do miss the 2 day format, because it was one full weekend of nothing but the draft. But now that I'm used to the 3 day set up. I really do like it. At first I didn't like it as much, but with have a family and kids and other responsibilities it is much easier to give up 1 day then it is 2 full days on a weekend.

Another reason why I like the 3 day set up is because of the down time in between the rounds. There seems to be a quite a bit of movement between the days. It gives teams times to reset themselves which is a good thing.

I agree with you that the Online reactions can be a bit much. There are way to many overreactions. The B word gets thrown around way too much. The truth is no one knows how a player will truly turn out. We can guess and think we know, but we don't really know. Even the experts are wrong a lot. I'll never forget when the Packers drafted Brian Brohm, Merrill Hodge stated that he would be the Packers starting QB over Rodgers.

I just can't wait to see who we bring onto our team. Once they are drafted they are a Packer and I am excited for them to be on my team!

5 points
5
0
tonyorth's picture

April 20, 2023 at 09:48 am

Love the article. Glad I am not the only one. For maybe the past five years I have compiled a Big Board using various online prognosticators - Walter Football, CHTV, talking heads, etc. I then rank based on Packers' "needs" and then make a mock. I watch highlights but no film. The results? Miserable. I have NEVER gotten a Packers draft pick right (right player, right round) so this year I was like 'to hell with it.'

No amateur could do my job and most here couldn't do anyone else's here either so, while I do hold management accountable for their drafts I won't call them fools when they make a bad call.

5 points
6
1
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:01 am

Who was the last Utah State player drafted in the first round before Jordan Love in 2020?

Phil Olsen 50 years earlier in 1970.

What does that say about Utah State and the level of competition Jordan Love faced?

-8 points
1
9
RCPackerFan's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:37 am

Ok, I'll bite.

Before Josh Allen when was the last time someone from Wyoming was drafted in the first round? 1976 when there were actually 2 guys drafted.

Before Patrick Mahomes when was the last time someone from Texas Tech was drafted in the first round? 2009 Michael Crabtree. 1983 Gabriel Rivera. 1981Ted Watts.

Did their schools make a difference with how Allen and Mahomes have become pros?

4 points
4
0
jannes bjornson's picture

April 20, 2023 at 03:05 pm

Phil Sims, Morehead State. SB Winner, MVP.

3 points
3
0
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 06:51 pm

Good one.

Southern Mississippi was independent too when Favre played there. If I recall he had a decent career.

1 points
1
0
LeotisHarris's picture

April 20, 2023 at 06:53 pm

Dear StarrtoRodgers,

Bill Munson attended Utah State and was drafted by the LA Rams in the first round of the 1964 NFL Draft. That would make him the last Utah State player drafted in the first round before Jordan Love in 2020. Please send my prize to PO Box 114, Two Rivers, WI 54241. Thanks.

Merlin Olson attended Utah State and was also drafted by the LA Rams in the first round of the 1962 NFL Draft.

Phil Olson, Merlin's little brother, was drafted in the first round (overall #4) of the 1970 draft by the Boston Patriots. Prior to reporting to the Patriots, he suffered a severe knee injury in practice the week of the College All-Star game in Chicago, Illinois when defensive tackle Mike McCoy (remember this, it's important later on!) of the University of Notre Dame fell on his right knee, ending his 1970 season.

Olsen was traded to the Rams before the 1971 season for a No. 1 draft choice and additional financial compensation. He suffered a second injury to the same knee after winning the starting position at right defensive tackle, but came back after five weeks to be the starter for the Rams in 1971 and 1972 next to his brother, Merlin Olsen. Merlin and Phil played side-by-side as defensive tackles for the Los Angeles Rams in 1971 and 1972, the only time in NFL history this has ever happened. A younger brother, Orrin, played for the Kansas City Chiefs in 1976. Merlin, Phil and Orrin were all playing in the NFL in 1976, which is one of the few times in NFL history that three brothers have ever played at the same time.

In 1973 and 1974 Olsen was moved to defensive end where he backed up Fred Dryer and Jack Youngblood. He was traded to the Broncos in 1975, where he reunited with Coach John Ralston, who had recruited him out of high school to Stanford and had coached him in the East-West Shrine Game. Olsen switched positions again, this time to center, where he played through 1976.

Olsen was the captain of the Broncos' return teams both seasons there. In 1976 Rick Upchurch had a spectacular year as a rookie kick returner. That year, the Broncos tied the then-NFL record with six kicks returned for touchdowns, with Upchurch setting the NFL mark for punt returns for a touchdown in a season with four. That same season, in addition to starting more than half the games at center, Olsen blocked four kicks (a punt, two PATs and a field goal). The Broncos beat the New York Giants 14–13 after Olsen blocked a PAT; for his efforts, he was presented with a game ball.

He moved on to the Buffalo Bills to reunite with his Ram coach Chuck Knox as one of "Knox's Guys". These were players who Chuck Knox would bring into his teams to provide leadership, skill and experience. However, Olsen subsequently suffered a third knee injury and spent his time in Buffalo on the injured reserve unit, retiring shortly afterwards.

Mike McCoy was the first pick of the Green Bay Packers and the second player overall selected in the 1970 NFL Draft. McCoy was named Packers Rookie of the Year in 1970 and led the Packers in quarterback sacks in 1973 and 1976.

He played eleven years in the NFL – seven with Green Bay, two with the Oakland Raiders, two with the New York Giants, and a couple of games with the Detroit Lions.

What does Phil Olson and Mike McCoy being drafted in the first round of the 1970 NFL Draft say about faith in the ability of large white men to stop the run given the fact that Rich Moore was a bust in 1969? What does it say about the efficacy of the use of the jet sweep in the red zone, especially in the PAC 12? Who will grind the wheat?

3 points
3
0
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:06 pm

Masterful work, my friend. I regret that I only have one 👍 to give!

2 points
2
0
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 10:19 am

If I’m honest, I really enjoy the second and third days, sometimes UDFA too. More picks, more unknowns to dig into and already a first rounder/trades to debate. This year seems to have the potential to be very unpredictable early. That might spice things up in the first. Goodall is not a TV plus. He’s the TT press conference of hosts. I suppose he likes himself enough for all of us?

3 points
3
0
Qoojo's picture

April 20, 2023 at 11:49 am

As a fan, I cannot think of a bigger waste of time than researching 100s of players where you actually end up with 5-10ish of them, and do not find out the results of how well you did for 2-4 years. Don't even get me started on mock drafts, which are worse than NCAAB tournament predictions due to randomness.

I am happy with whomever they draft, and I do not concern myself when the non-professionals (ESPN, media, armchair gm, ...) declare a player a reach or bust. I focus more on the positions drafted and read the little predraft blurbs on them. It's a crapshoot.

If you declare any draft pick an immediate bust or hand out a draft grade immediately after the draft, you disqualify yourself as knowledgeable.

As an example of how pointless these immediate grades are, the Vikings won the offseason superbowl like 10 years in a row from 200? to 201?.

9 points
9
0
golfpacker1's picture

April 20, 2023 at 02:57 pm

Careful Qoojo, you are insulting a lot of Packer fans who live for the NFL draft and everything that goes into it. Most draft fans don't see it as a waste of time to research players and they like to see how their picks compare against the real ones. There is no bad part of the draft in my opinion. It doesn't seem like you like it as much. I wish it happened twice a year. Can't wait.

2 points
2
0
Qoojo's picture

April 20, 2023 at 03:37 pm

I meant no insult on draft research. I should have added "for me" but i did not.

2 points
2
0
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 03:39 pm

"Don't even get me started on mock drafts, which are worse than NCAAB tournament predictions due to randomness"

Qoojo,

The objective of the 31 Billionaire Parasite NFL Owners who control the teams and these various NFL media sites and the paid wage slaves and talking heads who spew out these mock drafts is to MAXIMIZE REVENUE and NOT NECESSARILY TO PROVIDE TRUTH or any value. The entrance of "profit" corrupts any offering.

I only find value in:

1) My OwN EYES - watching the college players play college games.

2) Qualifying what I see by what level of competition the particular player is facing.

3) My OWN EYES - watching the college players at the NFL combine and Pro Days.

4) Evaluating individual College statistics, again adjusting for level of competition.

5) Evaluating the NFL Combine and Pro Day measurements and results..

-2 points
2
4
13TimeChamps's picture

April 20, 2023 at 04:31 pm

I have to admit I agree. I always wonder how people find the time to do all this "research". When I was working, I never had the time, and since retired, I seem to find much more interesting things to do with my time.

But I do find it entertaining reading posts about wanting one player over another because his arms are 1/2" longer or his hands are 1/4" bigger. Or all this film they're supposedly going over. That seems like a really tedious job for those who are actually getting paid to do it. And I've never done a mock draft in my life. I've never heard of 90% of these players, so I've never seen the point. And that doesn't make me any less of a Packer fan, btw.

In the end, it's all harmless fun I guess. Personally, I'd rather be out cruising the countryside on my '96 Softail or Facetiming with my grandkids. But to each their own I guess.

5 points
5
0
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:01 pm

I do like the draft, but I pick certain positions each year and then look for standouts and dive in to the player and how they might fit. I then then look for surprises too. I just find it interesting to see what happens in the draft and in their careers, but also to have some context to discussions in the long dead periods of winter. I could never do a full draft!

I do enjoy the to and fro of others views and rebuttals when supported by reasoning. I also like all the later unknowns (and some earlier) and digging in after to see if I can see why them. It’s good late night chilling fodder for me over the winter. 0 for 2 in round one for last year and that was not a problem. A little better in the second. Still fun and still paying dividends as players careers take shape.

2 points
2
0
TKWorldWide's picture

April 20, 2023 at 07:09 pm

Yeah, I just think it’s kind of fun. But I do not have my own draft board with names on magnetic tiles.

2 points
2
0
StarrtoRodgers's picture

April 20, 2023 at 03:22 pm

Coldworld: "You cherry picking to distort again. Whether or not one buys Rex Shields’ assessment, it’s pretty clear you distorted his conclusion deliberately. Go back to you bridge, troll."

Coldworld:

You have no objectivity at all.

All you can do is name call and try to censor anyone that provides facts - even Cheesehead TV.

Coldworld, anyone that is half awake knows that you work for the Packers General Manager & Public Relations and are paid to:
a) steer people's thinking with Packer Management Fed Propaganda diverting blame onto the Coach and Players

and

b) follow those posters around that have a critical view of Packer Management decisions, trying to discredit them as they provide simple facts.

I didn't "cherry pick"

The assessment was from Pro Football Focus analysts who looked at “PFF wins above replacement over a four-year rookie contract.” for all players drafted by the 32 GMs. PFF's numbers showed:

"The Packers ranked 17th in terms of draft success in the first round, taking into account positional value, and 7th in the NFC.

On Day 2 (rounds 2 and 3), the Packers have been below average since 2017. The team ranked 27th.

Finally, the Packers rank 21st on Day 3 (4th round to 7th round) in team draft success from 2017 until 2022."

The PFF article Rex Shield of Cheesehead TV referenced in Rex's April 14, 2023 article:
"Draftin' Ain't Easy: How the Packers Have Drafted Since 2017
Some teams navigate the draft waters better than others. "
was titled "NFL general manager superlatives, trends: Most successful at trade-ups, best Day 3 drafters and more" and was written by Brad Spielberger on April 11, 2023.

Rex of Cheesehead Tv was just trying to be kind to Brian Gutekunst. with his qualifying "but....."

After all, even though Cheesehead TV claims at the top of their website:

"Cheesehead TV is not affiliated with the Green Bay Packers or the National Football League."

for some unknown reason: Rex and Cheeshead TV also offer that:

"We are the 1st independent fan site to be officially credentialed at a Packer Regular Season, Playoff Game & Superbowl (XLV)."

and I am sure they do not want to lose Packer Management and "The League" (i.e. the 31 Billionaires Owners) credentialing them.

-4 points
1
5
Coldworld's picture

April 20, 2023 at 03:55 pm

Just letting others judge from what you quoted and what you omitted. It speaks for itself. Just as I can read for myself.

Since you posted that twice, hours and now yards apart, the comparative for readers reference here was:

You:

“Overall, the Packers’ draft results under Gutekunst have been nothing to write home about..."

Rex Shields”

“Overall, the Packers’ draft results under Gutekunst have been nothing to write home about, but he has still landed quality starters, including an All-Pro cornerback, a top-end offensive lineman, and a potentially star wide receiver. He has also found value in the later rounds, which is not an easy feat.”

Judge for yourselves.

3 points
4
1