Create Account

Or log in with Facebook


Log in

Or log in with Facebook

Silverstein\'s Missteps

By Category

Silverstein\'s Missteps

I'd like to respond to, if that's the right phrase, Tom Silverstein's assessment of Ted Thompson's approach, or lack thereof, to free agency this offseason. In this morning's Packers Daily Briefing, Silverstein states:

The problem I see with this philosophy is what happens when one of your draft classes isn't any good? There is so much pressure on you to be right in the draft that if you have an off year, it absolutely destroys you. There's no room for error. To me, that's exactly what happened with the 2007 draft class.

DT Justin Harrell, the guy who should have provided the most impact, has offered nothing for two years. RB Brandon Jackson came out of college too early and wasn't ready to be anything more than a spot player. WR James Jones was the bright spot of the draft, but an injury ruined his development last year. S Aaron Rouse and OT Allen Barbre have been disappointments. FB Korey Hall has been solid, LB Desmond Bishop flashed ability last year but clearly wasn't ready to start, K Mason Crosby has had his ups and downs and RB DeShawn Wynn is a developmental player.

If you want to know part of the reason why the Packers were 6-10 last year, there it is. 

 I would point out that Silverstein has some very conveniently colored (for his argument) assessments of the players in question. With Harrell, of course, he is spot on. With Jackson, however, he is way off. Sure, Jackson was not ready in 2007 - but last year he was the best back on the team. He should have at LEAST made a push for more carries after the Carolina game, if not been handed the starting job outright. But for whatever reason, McCarthy, Philbin and Bennett feel the need to stick with Grant as the featured back. That's not Jackson's or Thompson's fault - that's mishandling the personnel on hand - that's one of the many coaching decisions that produced a 6-10 record. Next he points to James Jones and how his injury 'ruined his development'. Um - so what? It's not like Thompson didn't have a deep stable of receivers at the ready in case of such a development. In fact, I would counter that Thompson's drafting of Jordy Nelson, in the face of a lot of criticism, offset whatever loss was felt from Jones' injury. And on and on...

I also like how Silverstien characterizes his objection on the grounds that Thompson isn't "taking advantage of the market".  Actually, I would say he is doing exactly that - by staying out of it. While teams are overpaying for the likes of Canty and Burnett, Thompson will resign guys like Greg Jennings and Aaron Kampman, guys he knows well and knows how they fit into what the Packers are trying to do. We know Jennings will get done, and I suspect Kampman will see an extension around the same time Rodgers saw one last year, provided he performs like I think he will in his new role. And that's just it - why overpay for some guy who you have no idea how he will fit in with your team and schemes? I'd much rather Thompson looked at cheaper guys already on the roster like Hunter or Thompson to play opposite Kampman than sign someone like Bart Scott and find out he doesn't work or that he shuts it down after getting paid - and then have to watch Kampman and/or Bigby walk next year because we couldn't afford to keep them because the team gave Scott a monster contract. 

One last point I'd like to make, speaking of Bart Scott, is the amount of time it can take players to become meaningful contributors to a team. Scott is a perfect example. Drafted in 2002, Scott did not become a starter until 2005, becoming the full-time starter in 2006. It takes time. I know it doesn't make people happy to read that when it's March and seemingly all the other teams are making moves, but Thompson believes his talent is on par with what's out there and is only getting better. I'm inclined to agree with him, especially after the case Winston Moss made at Fan Fest

Finally, I think Silverstein is completely discounting the coaching and schematic changes on the defensive side of the ball. I said it on the podcast and I'll repeat it here: Dom Capers is bigger (and better) than any free agent signing they could have made. And all this concern over the defensive personnel is way, way overblown. Capers is one of the best defensive minds working in the game today - he's not going to put guys in positions they can't handle and he won't be married to any one way of doing things to the point that it begins to hurt the team (unlike his predecessor). Packer fans are in for a pleasant surprise on the defensive side of the ball in the 2009 season and beyond. And no free agent acquisition (or lack thereof) is going to change that.

  • Like Like
  • 0 points

Fan friendly comments only: off Comments (13) This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.

Franklin Hillside's picture

We want Bedard! We want Bedard!

PackerAaron's picture

Come now. Silverstein is one of the best. Just think he's wide of the mark on this one...

Pack93z's picture

Just want to pass along that you are now being read in Viking country.. otherwise known as the PPO.;topics...
Marrdro is a excellent fan of football, but I think he is scouting a bit for the season. ;)

Franklin Hillside's picture

Impulse, knee-jerk statements are what make message boards great.

PackerAaron's picture

Thanks Pack93 - don't know whether to laugh or cry...

WoodyG's picture

Silverstein has a tendency to try to simplify very complicated situations. Anyone can pick one factor (the draft) then do a 180 & declare that factor as the problem. What about the other 2 dozen or so contributors to a winning record? Maybe he has a word limit ??

Aaron- your analysis is where every PackFan should be at this point of season 2009. The players are there. Now so is the coaching. Capers + will have the biggest impact on 2009.

Franklin Hillside's picture

And Jarrett Bush is back too!

L.A.'s picture

PPO actually is a pretty good site, as far as Viking sites can be considered cool. I actually posted there for several years.

Andrew's picture


Ron La Canne's picture

And now just how much more is Bush being paid than Tramon? And add this headline from, "Patriots are ready to move on Peppers."

If anything Silverstein was much too nice. I just can't believe they can justify Bush and Smith, a Pitt. safety who got cut, and tell us their problems were just the coaching staff. It's no damn wonder Kampman doesn't want to be interviewed.

PackerAaron's picture

Ron - the problem WAS the coaching staff. I understand that dosen't placate you, but it's the truth. You're going to be pleasantly suprised in September...

Ron La Canne's picture

I hope so Aaron I really do. I see the talent level at key positions lacking depth and quality. Maybe you can coach some of it, not all.

Pack93z's picture

L.A. I post at the PPO often.. quality folks, great fans, just happen to root for the incorrect hue. ;)

Log in to comment, upload your game day photos and more!

Not a member yet? Join free.

If you have already commented on Cheesehead TV in the past, we've created an account for you. Just verify your email, set a password and you're golden.

Or log in with Facebook



"I firmly believe that any man’s finest hour, the greatest fulfillment of all that he holds dear, is that moment when he has worked his heart out in a good cause and lies exhausted on the field of battle – victorious."
"The Bears still suck!"
"A school without football is in danger of deteriorating into a medieval study hall. "