Create Account

Or log in with Facebook


Log in

Or log in with Facebook

Packers vs. Giants: An Underrated Rivalry

By Category

Packers vs. Giants: An Underrated Rivalry

With the Green Bay Packers set to host the New York Giants on Sunday in the divisional round of the NFL playoffs at Lambeau Field, there's been a lot of attention in the media this week on two recent games between the two franchises.

The first is their meeting earlier this season in Week 13 in New York, a 38-35 victory, a game won on a drive directed by Aaron Rodgers with less than one minute remaining leading to a field goal by Mason Crosby as time expired.

The second is the 2007 NFC Championship in Green Bay, an overtime win for the Giants that catapulted them to the Super Bowl where they beat the undefeated New England Patriots. It was a game in the not-so-distant past in which several players from both current teams took part, minus Brett Favre, of course.

But the Packers and the Giants took part in several classic battles, five of them for NFL championships, all before the Super Bowl era and probably before many people reading this era were born, myself included.

Here's a brief look at those games that make this an underrated rivalry in NFL annals...

  • 1938 NFL Championship game––Played at the Polo Grounds in New York City. The Giants defeated Curly Lambeau's Packers for their third NFL championship and the second since the NFL used a tournament format to determine its champion. Pro Football Hall of Famers quarterback Arnie Herber threw for a touchdown and running back Clarke Hinkle ran for a touchdown in the second quarter. Packers kicker Paul Engebretsen gave the Packers a 17-16 lead in the third quarter, but the Giants won the game when Ed Danowski threw a touchdown pass to Hank Soar to end the scoring.
  • 1939 NFL Championship game––Played at State Fair Park in Milwaukee. The Packers won their fifth NFL championship and second since the NFL went to a postseason tournament. Arnie Herber and Cecil Isbell each threw touchdown passes as the Packers shutout the Giants, 27-0, in the first ever shutout in an NFL title game.
  • 1944 NFL Championship game––Played at the Polo Grounds in New York. The Packers won their sixth NFL championship and the last under Curly Lambeau. Fullback Ted Fristch scored the only two touchdowns for Green Bay that day, one on fourth-and-goal and another on a touchdown pass from Irv Comp. Defensive back Joe Laws had three interceptions for the Packers in a 14-7 defensive showdown.
  • 1961 NFL Championship game––Played at Lambeau Field, then known as New City Stadium in Green Bay. A 37-0 victory for the Packers was Vince Lombardi's first of five NFL championships and the seventh overall for Green Bay. Paul Horning scored 19 points on a touchdown, three field goals and four extra points. Bart Starr threw for three touchdowns, and the Packers defense limited the Giants to 130 yards, six first downs and forced five turnovers.
  • 1962 NFL Championship game––Played at Yankee Stadium in New York. In a game played in cold and blustery conditions, the Packers won, 16-7, their eighth world championship and second of five under Vince Lombardi. Ray Nitchke was named MVP after deflecting a pass that led to an interception and recovering two fumbles. In addition to playing guard, Jerry Kramer scored 10 points as the team's kicker on three field goals and an extra point.
  • Like Like
  • 0 points

Fan friendly comments only: off Comments (10) This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.

overkill's picture

Good article.
Blank underrated.
Get it up, Rodgers.

Bearmeat's picture

I have three teams I hate in the NFL. Those are the Packers modern rivals. That list does not include the Giants, although the Lions will probably appear at #4 if they keep not sucking..

1a. Bears
1b. Vikings
3. Cowboys

IMO the Giants are not a rival. All those championship games happened 30 years before I was born.

PackersRS's picture

Before mine too, but I don't think my birth day should be relevant when assessing whether the Packers and Giants are rivals or not.

I agree with you, though. It's more of a rivalry than Packers Saints or Packers Eagles, but they don't play against each other enough for it to be a rivalry.

I think this is football's or maybe USA's culture. I hate a lot of other soccer teams, and they hate my team, but we have one rival. There's only one team that I and the fanbase get upset about if they finish in front of us.

Bearmeat's picture

I'm just trying to point out that I have point of reference to Lombardi's teams or Curly's teams.

GB didn't even get to the playoffs in '89, but I remember the Majik Man, and hating the Viqueens for keeping us out.

It's all context.

Bearmeat's picture

ps - I WISH Americans had world class soccer. I wish the media covered it, and a I wish it would take the place of that useless sport called basketball.

As it stands I'm left rooting for the USMNT to not epically fold in the WC every 4 years... :(

PackersRS's picture

Hard with all your world-class athletes playing other sports... US has the talent, as shown by the Woman's national team.

But, correct me if I'm wrong, soccer is the most played sport by school girls in the US. It gets a big part of the talent, contrary to the Men's soccer.

Soccer/Sociology talk.

Bearmeat's picture

True. That is hard.

It's one of the reasons I was hoping MLB and NBA seriously stayed locked out.

Ah well.


asshalo's picture

Very interesting kicking facts.

fish/crane's picture

NY Giants should be on the top of all of our dislike lists-media forcing them down our throats.
The Bears? Face it, they are family.

EBL's picture

Congratulations to the Giants.

A heartbreaking loss. But if the choice is New England or the Giants, I would prefer the Giants prevailing.

Log in to comment, upload your game day photos and more!

Not a member yet? Join free.

If you have already commented on Cheesehead TV in the past, we've created an account for you. Just verify your email, set a password and you're golden.

Or log in with Facebook



"I firmly believe that any man’s finest hour, the greatest fulfillment of all that he holds dear, is that moment when he has worked his heart out in a good cause and lies exhausted on the field of battle – victorious."
"A school without football is in danger of deteriorating into a medieval study hall. "
"The Bears still suck!"