Create Account

Or log in with Facebook


Log in

Or log in with Facebook

An elephant named Mario? Surely not.

By Category

An elephant named Mario? Surely not.

When you look at the seven current-or-just-retired players in the NFL head of Mario Williams in career sacks, three of them are guaranteed Hall of Famers (Julius Peppers, DeMarcus Ware and Dwight Freeney) while the others are in the discussion (Terrell Suggs, Robert Mathis and Jared Allen) or were just damn good (Elvis Dumervil). 
It's not a bad cast to be surrounded by. 
To continue my unofficial series, Geriatric Greats No One Talks About — last week was Darrelle Revis — the focus shifts to a possible replacement for the Packers’ “elephant” position. With the departures of Peppers and former first-round pick Datone Jones, the search for available big-tweeners-not-quite-suited-for-OLB-but-athletic-enough-to-pass-rush-in-a-hybrid-defense now should, maybe, consider Mario Williams. 
Williams, the former No. 1 overall pick, is coming off two of his most forgettable seasons as a pro. These years are coincidentally drowned in questions over Williams’ interest in putting forth a pro effort. He followed a 14.5 sack, All-Pro season in 2014 with a dud in ’15, in a season where he and Rex Ryan sparred in the media before both of their departures from Buffalo, and a disappearing act in '16 with Miami. Back in Buffalo, Ryan, by many accounts, tried to fit a square peg into a round hole by asking Williams to drop into coverage rather than hone in on his proven pass-rushing skills.
Once in Miami in 2016, "Super Mario" appeared in 13 games but started just five and was virtually invisible as a role player. 
No wonder the lack of offseason chatter. 
But it’s always worth asking, is there something left to this player? Why? Because it’s March, many of the top free agents have been picked over, and what the hell else am I supposed to write about? 
The 2014 Bills unit that Williams thrived on, in addition to the two previous Pro Bowl seasons he turned in in ’12 and ’13, had a few things in common. Those Buffalo defenses were built top-to-bottom, with a combination of run stuffers, pass rushers and quality defensive backs. Not a single one of the Bills’ offenses had much to offer other than quality run games. They were defense-first units through and through. 
The '14 Bills in particular were a dominant unit. Aaron Rodgers faced some top-notch units that year, but even Seattle’s “Legion of Boom” fell short of the dominance he faced in a road game against Buffalo. The Bills were downright nasty, and Super Mario was a key cog in that unit. 
Going further back, Williams averaged a hair under 10 sacks a season as a defensive end in Houston before converting, somewhat unsuccessfully, to outside linebacker in his final season with the Texans in 2011. As a new Bill, though, Williams was asked to rush the passer and answered with 38 total sacks in 2012, ’13 and ’14. 
Things went sour in ’15 when Williams and fellow tweener, Jerry Hughes, were tasked with dropping into coverage more often. 
Hughes was also vocal about his displeasure in the apparent change in scheme. 
At this point in his career, Williams had already been paid a pretty penny, and opted for Miami in free agency. The Dolphins’ hybrid unit would employ in pass rushing situations a Wide 9 front, which sets its edge rushers out especially wide. 
The Dolphins had the 30th ranked rush defense in 2016. This was not a unit pinning opposing quarterbacks in obvious passing downs. Just how many 3rd and longs did they face? Not sure. But Williams was demoted after starting five games and disappeared into a reserve role. The 11-year-pro attributed foot and ankle injuries to his hindered productivity. 
At this point, you’re all probably super excited about Williams — a 32-year-old pass rusher who hasn’t been productive in two-and-a-half-years. Hold that thought. 
If there’s anything left of the impressive athlete who was drafted, at the time picked shockingly ahead of Reggie Bush as the No. 1 overall pick, then Williams just might be a quality fill-in for the Packers’ elephant position previously occupied by the likes of Peppers, Jones and Mike Neal. 
Williams measures 6-foot-6, weighs in at over 285 pounds and has always had impressive speed to match his huge frame. Not a true linebacker, and probably not a five-tech in Green Bay's base scheme. He’s a less consistent, less productive and slightly less athletic Julius Peppers for his career. But Peppers is a first-ballot Hall of Famer, obviously. If anything it’s a compliment to point out that Mario is one-if-not-only of Peppers' physical contemporaries.
Williams is also in the need of a jolt if he’s going to have any chance at resurrecting his career. The easy thing would be to sign with a 4-3 team that needs an edge rusher, but schemes are line-blurring these days, and with Green Bay stuck in the Nickel 75 percent of the time, what’s to stop Williams from finding new life as an elephant in Dom Capers’ room? 
Williams probably comes at a discount, too. What’s the basis for this assessment? No one has said his name since free agency started. He’s regarded as a has-been. Why not give him a flyer for $3-4 million a year to play for a winner? In 11 seasons, Williams has reached the postseason twice and never advanced past the Wild Card round. Maybe he’s not just hungry for wrecking quarterbacks, but, you know, for winning some football games? 
To become a situational rusher, at a position suited to his girth and edge-setting capabilities, in a city that has been known to breathe new life into veteran standouts, it’s not completely crazy to think that he makes the Packers — who currently lack an elephant — a more dangerous bunch with him on their team. 
Oh well, see you next week when I ask whether bringing Jason Taylor out of retirement would help the Packers’ pass rush. Kidding. Maybe. 
NFL Categories: 
  • Like Like
  • 0 points

Fan friendly comments only: off Comments (20) This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.

Packer_Pete's picture

he has nothing left... not even worth taking a shot for 3 - 4 million...

Savage57's picture

It would be a risk, but comparing the extent of it to the risk Ted just took with Perry, why not kick it around and see if you can plug him in for a relatively low guarantee and load him up with incentives?

Spock's picture

If this is all you got to write about, IMHO, don't bother. A has been now low effort "name" still out there. Meh.

dnicholson's picture

Glad you appreciated the story. Your positive attitude surely motivates me to continue sharing my perspective.

GLM's picture

I think it's a great article, Dave. I hadn't thought about Williams until you brought it up. He just might be the next in a growing line of distinguished free agents to find new life with the Packers...we'll see. There's plenty of time left in the FA period.

Spock's picture

Hey, I gave you my candid reaction to the story. I gave you the courtesy of READING the story. It is just disappointing that my initial thought on seeing the headline was "Oh, great another fluff piece on a "name" out there, like a thousand others. I always read the story before commenting, and had done so this time as usual. I like your writing STYLE,, just not the story. Sorry if you took that as a personal attack! I said it was IMHO. I gave an opinion on the article that was honest and I stick with what I said.

Zachary Jacobson's picture

It's the off-season. A lot of what is written about centers around potential free agents and pipe dreams. I thought this was a good story with even better perspective.

piosGBP's picture

Spin up an article and wow us with your Packer takes then, Spock. Take a break from the Millennium Falcon, eh?!

Pack88's picture

For 3 million I could be as useless as Mario Williams. Plus I would be a media sensation an old white guy on the field. Call Russ Ball and I'll sign this afternoon

croatpackfan's picture

Contrary to Williams, you would not survive...

Pack88's picture

Good point; but our stats would be just about the same!

Lphill's picture

What's scary is that everyone else worth taking a chance on have already signed elsewhere ,no real improvement to the defense besides House , we can't draft and start 3 or 4 rookies , we may need a vet like Williams after all . He might be motivated if it means a ring.

Handsback's picture

Actually I thought Mario should be viewed as a plug-in if the money was right. If he can still rush the passers at the league aren't losing anything.
Hang in there...good idea and out of the box thinking.

Since '61's picture

It's an interesting thought. I don't know if I would spend $3-4 million on a flyer though. Offer the Vet minimum with incentives. But first we need to determine if he's healthy and if he still has the desire to play. If he is still out there after the draft maybe give him a look. Never hurts to have the conversation. Thanks, Since '61

4thand1's picture

Why not bring him and at least talk to him? Get a feel where he's at as far as playing.

Matt Gonzales's picture

I think this is totally unlikely, but also not totally crazy. This would fill a need while also allow for grooming future players, IF he does in fact still have more in the tank. That's the big if, and Peppers still showed plus physicality and athleticism when we brought him in to a new position.

EdsLaces's picture

He wouldn't even be as good as Datone was ....nah.

BELIEVER's picture

He is 32 years old. Hell ya bring him in. The crap defense the Pack had last year, he would be an improvement over anybody but Perry. Ya including the highly over paid Mathews.

stockholder's picture


porupack's picture

Good proposition David. All options have merits. Definitely worth a look, and you similarly show the risk and potential....that recent performance was impacted by bad fit.
Guess it depends highly on his motivation, and price. I think a big indicator of motivation is in fact, the price Mario demands. If I was GM, I'd flirt with MWilliams, and hold an incentive-biased deal on low side for a first year of a 2-year deal with a sweet second year escalation. If Mario has the football motivation, he'll take a lower offer and complete his legacy. 2017 needs more in the trenches than 2 rookies.

Log in to comment, upload your game day photos and more!

Not a member yet? Join free.

If you have already commented on Cheesehead TV in the past, we've created an account for you. Just verify your email, set a password and you're golden.

Or log in with Facebook



"The Bears still suck!"
"I firmly believe that any man’s finest hour, the greatest fulfillment of all that he holds dear, is that moment when he has worked his heart out in a good cause and lies exhausted on the field of battle – victorious."
"A school without football is in danger of deteriorating into a medieval study hall. "