What Went Wrong in Second Half of Packers' 30-27 Loss to Colts

The Green Bay Packers choked away a win they had in the bag Sunday after 30 minutes. What went so horrifically wrong in the second half against the Colts?

The Green Bay Packers (2-3) may have played the worst second half Sunday since Mike McCarthy became the team's head coach in 2006. Leading 21-3 at the half, McCarthy's Packers allowed 16 points in the third quarter and later surrendered two fourth-quarter leads as the Colts upset Green Bay, 30-27.

The Packers hadn't blown a halftime lead as large as 18 points since 1957, or 55 years.

After re-watching the second-half debacle, here are just some of the things that went terribly wrong over the final 30 minutes:

 

Turnover spark

The fastest way to jump-start a dead team is giving away the football on your own side of the 50, or exactly what the Packers did on their first offensive possession of the second half. Quarterback Aaron Rodgers said his back-shoulder pass to James Jones was tipped, causing the throw to go to the inside shoulder. Regardless of the process that led to the turnover, an interception was probably the worst-case scenario on the Colts first defensive possession. It gave a flat-lining sideline a heart beat.

Running game goes away

Despite being up 18 points to start the second half, Mike McCarthy waited two possessions and seven plays to finally call a run. Granted, Cedric Benson left in the first half with an ankle injury. But seven straight passes after McCarthy witnessed the offense move up-and-down the field with a balanced play-sheet in the first half? Benson's injury shouldn't have tipped the scales to the passing game the way it did. The Packers ran on nine of 17 plays (53 percent) with Benson in the game, then shifted to 14 out of 44 (35 percent) once he left in the second quarter. When the Packers offense has been one dimensional this season, defenses have teed off on Rodgers. Same story during Sunday's second half in Indianapolis.

Regression up front

After keeping Rodgers clean for eight-straight quarters, the offensive line regressed and Rodgers held the ball too long in the second half. Bryan Bulaga continued a miserable season by getting beat for one of five second-half sacks, but Rodgers was responsible for at least two of the sacks. Marshall Newhouse and T.J. Lang were credited with the other two. The regression is tied directly into the previous point: When McCarthy gets unbalanced with playcalling, defenses gett aggressive in putting Rodgers on the ground. When the run game is present, Rodgers stays clean. It's simple football theory, and the Packers offense in 2012 could be Exhibit A. Sunday was just the latest chapter.

Luck avoids sacks 

Pressure remained on Colts quarterback Andrew Luck throughout the contest, but the productivity in getting him to the ground dried up in the second half. After four first-half sacks, the Packers had none in the second. Several times, and because of several different rushers, Luck was able to escape pressure and find a receiver down field. Luck is a fantastic athlete and a difficult man to bring down, but that lack of finishing on several blitzes and pressures killed the Packers late. Seven-yard losses turned into 12-yard completions, and the Colts offense rolled because of it.

Colts run game gains traction

In the second half, the Colts were down to backups at both guard positions and center along the offensive line. Yet Indianapolis was still able to run the football over the last 30 minutes. On the Colts second possession of the second half, Donald Brown rumbled off gains of nine, 11 and 12 yards as Indianapolis marched down the field. Overall, the Colts ran the football 30 times for 119 yards, but the big chunks came in the second half. That's inexcusable when facing such a ragtag offensive line, even if B.J. Raji did leave in the first half.

Missing turnover opportunities

The Packers defense has lived off turnovers under Dom Capers, but the ball just hasn't bounced their way in 2012. On Sunday, Tramon Williams' inability to intercept an easy pick in the red zone handed the Colts three points. A year ago, Williams probably hangs on to that football and the Packers survive. Credit Casey Hayward for making his play on the football in the fourth quarter, but the Packers need to start cashing in on the opportunities they get defensively.

Missed field goals

Both missed field goals were equally costly. The second kick was obviously the dagger, and Mason Crosby probably won't miss many kicks in his career that badly. Considering Crosby was 5-for-5 on kicks in 2012 and has generally made himself into one of the NFL's most dependable kickers, his two misses were even more shocking. Neither was a gimme, but the Packers expect Crosby to make both, especially indoors.

More officiating mistakes

Sam Shields continues to get flagged for phantom defensive pass interference. Sunday's was awful. How the side official saw anything but perfect coverage from Shields late in the third quarter just goes to show that officials are going to make huge mistakes in these games whether they are real or replacement. And while the call didn't automatically give the Colts seven points, it did turn an upcoming 3rd-and-5 from the Indianapolis' 42-yard line into a 1st-and-10 from the Packers' 17. The Colts were in the end zone four plays later.

Failure to take away the only weapon 

How the Packers failed to neutralize the Colts only true weapon in the passing game is beyond comprehensible. It became clear early on that Luck was looking to Reggie Wayne (13 catches, 212 yards, TD) on every drop back. Yet Dom Capers continued to give Wayne single coverage. There are so many ways that a defensive coordinator can essentially take away a receiver, including bracket coverage where the corner and safety combine to eliminate any throw underneath or over the top. It was done successfully in Week 2 when the Packers took Bears receiver Brandon Marshall out of the contest. Yet for 60 minutes, the Packers failed to adjust to Wayne. Even on the last drive, Wayne caught four passes. Make someone else beat you with the game on the line.

0 points
 

Comments (25)

Fan-Friendly This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.
packsmack25's picture

October 08, 2012 at 02:33 pm

That play, if called correctly, should have been 3rd and 15, as it was clear to everyone in the stadium, including all of the Colts fans around me, that it was OFFENSIVE PI. It turned the game completely on it's head, and if it had happened with a minute to go, everyone would be talking about how terrible of a call it was. Instead it is forgotten, and the team "choked." It's bullshit. The refs choked. Period. Three weeks in a row that a blatantly bad call has gone against the Packers, and they are lucky that they're not looking at 1-4 instead of 2-3. This is a 4-1 team without screw-jobs, people! Just calm down!

0 points
0
0
NoWayJose's picture

October 08, 2012 at 02:54 pm

You are being pretty kind to the Packers. It was the wrong call. But based on what I saw, the likely result of that should-have-been-3-and-15 would have been Reggie Wayne making a first down.

The Packers absolutely failed here and the refs were just a minor part of it this time.

0 points
0
0
packsmack25's picture

October 08, 2012 at 03:13 pm

So you can assume based on events AFTER the momentum swing that Wayne would have converted, but I can't assume that the defense would stop at least ONE long 3rd down conversion? That's ridiculous logic. Forget the fact that the next 3 drives for the Colts went punt, FG, interception. Wipe out a 35 yard swing as well as a free first down and the ensuing 7 points, and this game takes on a completely different complexion.

0 points
0
0
Mojo's picture

October 08, 2012 at 03:51 pm

It does make you wonder how many games, and how many teams fortunes for a season have been decided by refs in the past. One thing fans might not have realized is one of the key components of the ref lock-out was to give the NFL more ability to replace crappy refs. After watching the last few games, I can tell them where to find them.

This year the Fates have not been kind to GB. And is there any call that can influence a game more the PI? Considering all the advantages QB's and receivers already have, the NFL should contemplate lessening the severity of that rule. Especially since it so arbitrarily applied. (Don't get me started on roughing the passer calls either).

Let's face it Pack fans. This is our year to get hosed. Goodell was right it's happened in the past and will happen in the future. And in the present it's happening to the Packers.

0 points
0
0
Idiot Fan's picture

October 08, 2012 at 03:28 pm

"But based on what I saw, the likely result of that should-have-been-3-and-15 would have been Reggie Wayne making a first down."

That made me laugh. And then cry.

0 points
0
0
Idiot Fan's picture

October 08, 2012 at 02:49 pm

I'll never understand why Wayne didn't get the Brandon Marshall treatment during the second half of that game. Can one of the beat writers ask the coaches about that?

0 points
0
0
brando's picture

October 08, 2012 at 03:01 pm

Especially when it was safeties he was getting single coverage with! I can't for the life of me figure out why we kept letting their #1 receiver keep lining up with our safeties over and over, especially Woodson who as we all saw is no longer a reliable cover guy. Every time I saw Woodson lined up in front of Wayne in the 4th quarter I cringed inside knowing what was to come.

0 points
0
0
tundraboy's picture

October 08, 2012 at 03:09 pm

A day later I am still embarrassed and disgusted with the passive aggressive defense. It has to be Capers. Maybe he has to get out of the sky booth and be on the field!!! I am sick of a year and half now of games. where we make the great stop or plays to get the other team in long 3rd down situations only to give up easy long first downs. Happened against Giants in NY and almost every game since. Seen half ass efforts to get after qb usually resulting in trying to blitz and the opposing receiver is left with plenty of room to catch the ball. Wayne was great but where was the coverage when he was obviously getting the ball!!!!!!!!!!!

0 points
0
0
Rocky70's picture

October 08, 2012 at 04:30 pm

Wake up people.

GB is basically playing like sh*t, but somehow it's on the officiating?
Good teams overcome bad calls. GB is simply not a 'good team' yet.

You're starting to sound like Bear fans. (Blame someone just not the team)

0 points
0
0
SHODAN's picture

October 08, 2012 at 11:32 pm

Which "people" are you attempting to call out here? Only one individual is actively painting the Colts loss as a screw-job.

Your wake-up call is almost wholly unnecessary.

0 points
0
0
packsmack25's picture

October 09, 2012 at 07:48 am

Green Bay is a 4-1 team trapped in a 2-3 team's record. Only the blind would see it another way. In the NFL, games decided by 3 points or less hinge on one play. The Packers have had two major plays go against them erroneously and cost them wins in 3 point games. Just because they aren't blowing people out doesn't mean they don't deserve the wins.

0 points
0
0
petr's picture

October 08, 2012 at 05:10 pm

I haven't rewatched this yet (and don't really want to), but I thought we played far too much 2 man defensive line in the 2nd half that allowed Indy to run the ball. Raji affected the plans of course, but Worthy, Pickett and Wilson should have been used as a 3 man line more. Maybe they didn't want Neal to play too much, but then why was Daniels inactive?

0 points
0
0
Hands's picture

October 08, 2012 at 05:16 pm

I got very frustrated w/ the calls against Perry and Shields but that's not what beat the Pack...they did that all by themselves.

The team is imploding on itself by either lack of talent or effort. I was istening to the game on the radio (Sirrius) and turned to my wife and said " Green Bay started the game with one first down, a run by Rodgers but the Colts have three plays over ten yards....2 passes and a run. This doesn't sound good." As it turns out the Pack grabs a 21-3 lead but whatever happened in the first qtr. repeated itself throughout the 2nd half.
Maybe the team is still looking at their press clippings.

0 points
0
0
packsmack25's picture

October 09, 2012 at 07:49 am

Packers have lost 2 games by 3 or less. And they should have won both games, if not for big blown calls. Tell me how that's a team imploding on itself?

0 points
0
0
Ruppert's picture

October 08, 2012 at 05:21 pm

The refs didn't have anything to do with this mess yesterday. The only question to me right now is if it's more on the players or the coaching. Tough call.

McCarthy is doing his worst coaching since '08, IMO. From stupid challenges to forgetting the running game, he's missing on every guess right now.

I'm not thrilled with Capers right now either, but at least he's working with quite a few rookies.

And guys are playing just awfully. Bulaga is brutal. (Brutal-aga?). Jerel Worthy should be on the practice squad. Finley is horrible. Even Double D can't catch.

But the biggest head scratcher among the players now is Aaron Rodgers. He does not look totally right out there. Just from the way he carries himself. Two years ago, an indoor game meant he'd be sprinting out of the pocket at full speed and throwing 20 yard balls as hard as he could to Jordy. Where was THAT look, that general attitude yesterday? He just isn't totally comfortable.

And we're staring pretty hard at 2-4 right now.

0 points
0
0
Rocky70's picture

October 08, 2012 at 06:11 pm

Cut AR a little slack. He's pretty much on his own out there. He may be the only "elite" player on the "O". The rest of what you stated is 'as accurate as anything I've read lately'.

GB needs a huge turnaround or season 2012 will be lost & forgotten. (Although 2-3 hardly seems like a mountain ---- A few wins in a row would change many attitudes)

0 points
0
0
FITZCORE 1252'S EVO's picture

October 08, 2012 at 09:20 pm

Idk, every analyst and their mother will cram it down our throats just how deep and talented our receiving corps is...

0 points
0
0
packsmack25's picture

October 09, 2012 at 07:51 am

When they're 3-3 Sunday night and you stop seeing red for the wrong reasons, will you join me in being angry that they would be 5-1 if not for bogus calls?

0 points
0
0
Ace731's picture

October 08, 2012 at 05:42 pm

That's quite the list of things that went wrong. Inexcusable.

0 points
0
0
pkrNboro's picture

October 08, 2012 at 06:20 pm

I've seen the extremes of opinion on Saturday.

If Saturday is not stout after the snap, then the pressure up the middle could be driving Rodgers further back in the pocket -- which could be screwing up where Bulaga and Newhouse set up shop.

However, I was watching a stream and the tv crews always follow the ball -- so I don't know if this idea holds water.

0 points
0
0
Brian's picture

October 08, 2012 at 10:03 pm

+1 I was wondering the same. It just seems like he(AR) is uncomfortable and Saturday mentioned he isn't totally sure of the protection calls yet. I tried to watch the pressure up the middle but it's hard to see when the whole pocket is collapsing but it seems like Saturday is struggling.

0 points
0
0
al's picture

October 08, 2012 at 06:24 pm

No heart. The end.

0 points
0
0
pkrNboro's picture

October 08, 2012 at 06:29 pm

I don't know what to make of McCarthy.

For all the shit he spews about being responsible, how can "he" overlook his play-calling -- the imbalance of pass to run -- and not correct it, especially during a damn game?

It's not like he's a rookie coach, and possibly awed by the game. He's at a point where after a few 3-and-outs that he needs pull a Costanza, and do the exact opposite of what he thinks is right.

0 points
0
0
A_Lerxst_in_Packerland's picture

October 08, 2012 at 07:30 pm

"...he needs pull a Costanza, and do the exact opposite of what he thinks is right."

Good one! You made me laugh.
(But seriously, maybe he should...)

0 points
0
0
brewcityeddy's picture

October 09, 2012 at 08:32 pm

This offense needs to dust off some West Coast plays, especially screens, draws and slants. That should open up the fakes and deeper routes. And it will substitute for a running game.

Defensively, I was really expecting Capers to go back to the Bears gameplan. Take away the one big WR threat and send pressure.

0 points
0
0