Packers Who Have Left Too Soon

With the NFL draft coverage having been churned and churned over and over, I'm going the route of a though-provoking topic and taking a page from ESPN Milwaukee's Green & Gold Today.  Jason Wilde and Brian Dee often integrate the news of the day with a Packers spin.  So with yesterday's news that mega-star recording artist Prince passed away at the all-too-young age of 57, it got me thinking about Green Bay Packers players who have left us too soon.  Who are the biggest names that come to mind when thinking about players we wish would have stuck around a while longer?

I'm almost positive that at least 90% of you are already thinking Reggie White right now.  So to make this more of a discussion, I want to keep the discussion to players who left the Packers and played elsewhere or retired, whether by choice or due to injury.  While there may have been some in the team's nearly 100-year history, I can't think of any players who passed away while actively playing for the team so we'll keep it to the previously mentioned scenarios.  I'll start with my top five and let everyone carry it on in the comments.

5.  Bryce Paup - the old-school linebacker spent his first five seasons with the Packers in the early 1990's and was there through the transition from the doldrums to the arrival of Ron Wolf, Mike Holmgren and the many key players who would lead the Packers back to a Super Bowl a few years later.  Paup played another six seasons and was effective through most of them, spending time with the Buffalo Bills, Jacksonville Jaguars and Minnesota Vikings (they were even scavenging former Packers players way back then!).  In fact, Paup was named the NFL Defensive Player of the Year in 1995, his first year away from Green Bay.  The Packers ran a 4-3 defense and had plenty of talent in their front seven while Paup was always more of a 3-4 outside linebacker.  It's still fun to think about what Paup could have added to that 1995 team that was less than a quarter away from a Super Bowl appearance.

4.  James Lofton - Lofton played nine seasons with the Packers and was the team's leader in receiving yardage until that mark was surpassed by Donald Driver many years later.  Lofton spent another seven in the league after spending time with the Los Angeles Raiders, Buffalo Bills, Los Angeles Rams and Philadelphia Eagles.  Lofton was a key piece of the Bills teams who appeared in the first two of four-straight Super Bowls.  He obviously had plenty of tread left on the tires and given what the Packers teams were in the years after Lofton left Green Bay, he would have been a nice running mate to Sterling Sharpe, who was drafted just a few years later.

3.  Nick Collins - Packers fans still shake their head when they hear Collins' name mentioned.  After his big pick six in Super Bowl XLV, he returned to help the Packers to a thrilling opening-day win to start off the 2011 season but was lost the following week when he suffered a career-ending neck injury on a tackle attempt.  Collins had already cemented himself as one of the NFL's top safeties and one of the best in the Packers' storied history and his loss is one that the team struggled to recover from for years.  It's a lot to ask to replace a talent like Collins and what made matters worse was what the Packers had and chose to work with for the next few seasons until they drafted Ha Ha Clinton-Dix in 2014.  Collins struggled with his injury and made it known that he wanted to play football again.  His many tweets to anyone that would listen indicated that he wasn't ready to give up the game, despite the heavy risk of returning from that injury.  Collins eventually retired but he surely would have had a few more productive years in the Packers defensive backfield.

2.  Sterling Sharpe - Sharpe only played seven seasons for the Packers, but made the most of his time.  595 catches for over 8,000 receiving yards and 65 touchdowns.  The arrival of Brett Favre bolstered Sharpe's career and numbers, as he racked up over 100 catches in each of 1992 and 1993.  It was Sharpe who caught the game-winning touchdown to beat the Detroit Lions in the 1993 playoffs and give the Packers their first playoff win in nearly a decade.  Many argue that Sharpe was a shoe-in for the Pro Football Hall of Fame had a neck injury in 1994 not shortened his career.  Not since James Lofton had the Packers had a true go-to receiver and it was Sharpe who often gave Packers fans one of the only things to cheer about through the late 1980's and early 1990's.

1.  Brett Favre - This story is well-known to modern-day Packers fans and there is no shortage of opinions on it.  Favre retired following the 2007 season and a gut-wrenching loss to the Giants in the NFC Championship game in which he threw an interception to end the Packers' chances of making a Super Bowl appearance.  A few months later, Favre would unretire and force the most awkward summer that the team will probably ever see again.  Favre was eventually traded to the New York Jets and spent the 2008 season there before retiring again.  Once again, Favre decided he wasn't ready to hang up the cleats and spent two seasons with the Vikings, nearly leading them to a Super Bowl in 2009.  It's easy now to say that Favre shouldn't be on this list and while Favre's departure paved the way for Aaron Rodgers to become the Packers starter and what he is today, at the time, there were many who were ready to burn Lambeau Field to the ground over the loss of old #4.  

A few others who may be on some others' lists:  Ryan Longwell, Jermichael Finley, Cullen Jenkins, Vonta Leach and Darren Sharper.  Some might say running back Ahman Green is also a candidate, having left the Packers in 2007 before returning in 2009 but Green's contributions to the Houston Texans were very minimal as he headed towards the end of his career.  And what about receiver Terrence Murphy? Another in the way-too-long line of former Packers players who had to retire following a neck injury.  

Who else would you add to this list?

 

-------------------

Jason is a freelance writer on staff since 2012 and also co-hosts Cheesehead TV Live, Pulse of the Pack and Pack A Day podcasts.  You can follow him on Twitter here

NFL Categories: 
0 points
 

Comments (43)

Fan-Friendly This filter will hide comments which have ratio of 5 to 1 down-vote to up-vote.
NickPerry's picture

April 22, 2016 at 07:16 am

Tim Lewis comes to mind, I know guys like Since '61 remember Lewis. He was one of the few bright spots of the 80's Packers before a neck injury forced him to retire. Still remember the game on Monday Night Football against the Bears.

Johnathan Franklin... I still think Franklin might have ended up being the better back between Lacy and himself.

Sharpe SHOULD be in the Hall of Fame. 2 years in a row he broke the single season catch record in 92 then 93. Wasn't he the fastest to 500 catches in NFL History before Bolden broke his record?

Edit... Played 7 seasons and never missed a game. 595 receptions, 65 TD's, WOW Sharpe was THE man.

0 points
0
0
RCPackerFan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 07:26 am

I would have loved to have seen how good Lacy and Franklin could have been together. I think they would have been a perfect 1-2 punch.

0 points
0
0
NickPerry's picture

April 22, 2016 at 07:40 am

I agree, Lacy would wear em down and Franklin would have come in and broke off some big runs in the 4th quarter. Franklin also would have been the Perfect 3rd down back. What a shame that injury was.

0 points
0
0
RCPackerFan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 08:00 am

Completely agree.

I was expecting big things from Franklin. I remember watching him a lot in college and the things I saw him do in college he was doing in the NFL until his injury.
He was one of the first players that I watched a lot in college and was hoping Thompson would draft him. Then he did... I think he was the first player that I wanted Thompson to draft and he actually did.

I really would like to see Thompson add another player like him. We could use a change of pace type of RB like him.

0 points
0
0
RobinsonDavis's picture

April 22, 2016 at 05:16 pm

I agree with all those in the article, but Tim Lewis is a great choice! I might add from the halls of "What Could Have Been".... John Brockington after his thigh injury, he was never the same, and Eddie Lee Ivory, he tore-up his knee twice and would have been a monster at RB had he stayed healthy (a day I will remember for life....very sad when he tore that knee against the Bears!). But most of all, I LOVED Ted "The Stork" Hendricks, but due to contract issues, we lost him after one year. How's that for dating yourself!

0 points
0
0
NickPerry's picture

April 22, 2016 at 09:59 pm

Excellent Picks!

0 points
0
0
Since'61's picture

April 23, 2016 at 04:10 pm

Nick - I remember Tim Lewis well. He was on his way to a very good of not great career. Tough loss. Fred Carr was another Packer who I wish lasted longer. Thanks, Since '61

0 points
0
0
D.D.Driver's picture

April 22, 2016 at 06:17 am

Sterling Sharpe would have to be at the top of the list.

A darkhorse: Kurt Warner. Warner has had an interesting career path, but when you cut a bubble-HOF player in training camp, its by definition "too soon."

0 points
0
0
NickPerry's picture

April 23, 2016 at 06:28 am

Good one DD, but I wonder how long he was actualy in camp? From what I remember reading or watching, Warner never even really had a chance. The Packers had Favre, Brunnell, and Detmer who at the time was coming off an amazing College Career. What a group!!

65 NFL Seasons played. 142,625 total passing yards. 934 TDs. 18 Pro Bowls. 1 Pro Bowl MVP. 5 NFL MVPs. 3 QBs that led team to best record in an NFL season. 5 SB appearances. Two of the last three players to win NFL MVP and SB in the same season. 1,658 passing yards in the Super Bowl. 11 passing TDs in the Super Bowl. Top three passing performances in Super Bowl history.

Brunell was another I guess we could add to the list.

0 points
0
0
Bearmeat's picture

April 22, 2016 at 06:23 am

I agree with the list above. I don't remember James Lofton with the Pack - to me he was a Buffalo Bill. I do, however, remember Bryce Paup sketchily. But again, he was still more of a Bill to me.

Even though they weren't Packers, I'll take this another step: Barry Sanders. Best RB since Jim Brown IMO. And Calvin Johnson - Best WR since Jerry Rice IMO. Both excellent guys in the community. Both scary to play against, both physically unbelievable on the field and both classy when they made a big play. Both of their careers wasted in Detroit.

Sad.

0 points
0
0
EdsLaces's picture

April 22, 2016 at 07:12 am

*Ed thinks about Nick Collins and a tear slowly rolls down his cheek *

0 points
0
0
marpag1's picture

April 22, 2016 at 11:07 am

Pull up a chair, bud. I've got a bottle of 18 year old Talisker. It ain't gonna drink itself...

0 points
0
0
croatpackfan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 09:34 am

If Brett Favre stay till 2009 with Packers, Packers would never win SB with Aaron Rodgers. Why? For several reasons, the most important one is that Aaron would be traded earlier for some draft picks and he would brought SB to some other franchise.... That is the truth and all of you knows it!
Knowing above, I'm glad that Brett Favre left (or be traded) Packers when he had left. With all respect for him and his loyal huge fans! He was and is one of the greatest QB ever and that is what nobody can take from him!

0 points
0
0
Evan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 08:13 am

I might even argue he hung around a year or two too long.

0 points
0
0
GLM's picture

April 22, 2016 at 09:58 am

I would add Johnny Mitchell to that list. Another very good safety who had his career ended early due to injury.

0 points
0
0
GLM's picture

April 22, 2016 at 10:01 am

Wrong player...Roland Mitchell.

0 points
0
0
GLM's picture

April 22, 2016 at 10:01 am

And he was a cornerback.

0 points
0
0
marpag1's picture

April 22, 2016 at 11:04 am

Terrance Murphy is the one I always wonder about. I thought he would be a stud. For that matter, I even wonder what might have been with Derek Sherrod. As it stands, he might be the biggest bust in TT's career... but what if he hadn't snapped his leg like a burned out matchstick?

0 points
0
0
Evan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 11:29 am

Sherrod is not the biggest bust in TT's career. I think a devastating injury like that takes him out of consideration.

Justin Harrell is #1. Jarel Worthy is probably #2. Brian Brohm is #3. And I'd put Alex Green at #4 (a. because he pretty much sucked and b. that pick should have been used for Marshawn).

After the 3rd round, I don't think "busts" are a thing.

0 points
0
0
marpag1's picture

April 22, 2016 at 11:36 am

Well, I did say "he MIGHT be ..."

Agree, though, about Harrell and Worthy. Gigantic whiffs....

0 points
0
0
RCPackerFan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 01:02 pm

Yeah, I also don't like when people call Sherrod a bust or one of Thompsons worst picks. Can't blame Thompson for not knowing he was going to break his leg 6 months later and have his career cut short.
The only thing I would change is Brohm I think is the 1b to Harrels 1a for busted picks. I might argue that Brohms pick was worse. Harrell had injuries. Brohm was horrendous. Beat out by a 7th rounder. Considering people thought he was going to be better then Rodgers, adds a little more to the busted pick fire.

0 points
0
0
Evan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 01:32 pm

Yea, I'm cool with elevating Brohm also because Rodgers was already on the roster and they'd invested 3 years into his development. So, not only was Brohm total garbage, there was no need to take another QB so high.

At there was "need" for Harrell and Worthy.

0 points
0
0
Idiot Fan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 07:12 pm

I don't disagree that Harrell is probably #1, but it's so easy to say that in retrospect. Harrell was a wrecking ball in college when he wasn't injured. You could say that the injuries should have been red flags, but Adrian Peterson was hurt all the time in college too, and people don't generally consider him a bad pick because he has been durable enough in the pros. So, yeah, a bust, but not pure idiocy.

Honestly, I would almost ding TT more for a pick like Nick Perry. He has been so-so for us, but from the start he has seemed like a square peg in a round hole at OLB.

0 points
0
0
Evan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 08:06 pm

"He has been so-so for us, but from the start he has seemed like a square peg in a round hole at OLB."

I see that a lot (mostly from Taryn) and it's simply not true. At least according to his scouting report at the time.

"Nick Perry was a top defensive end recruit out of Detroit that Pete Carroll was able to cherry-pick to USC, and his impact playing the "elephant" position within Caroll's defense as a freshman will encourage many teams to consider drafting him as an outside linebacker in a 3-4 scheme. A"

http://www.nfl.com/combine/profiles/nick-perry?id=2533048

0 points
0
0
Idiot Fan's picture

April 23, 2016 at 01:32 pm

Get out of here with your evidence and thoughtful response. I would like to cling to my preconceived ideas, thank you very much.

0 points
0
0
marpag1's picture

April 23, 2016 at 02:49 am

Everybody has their own personal definition of "bust"... just like everyone has their own definition of "elite QB" or "shut down corner" or "difference maker," or whatever. And no one really agrees on what those definitions mean.

If your definition of bust simply means that you spent a very high pick and you didn't get diddly-squat in return, then Sherrod is certainly a "bust." I'm not actually saying that TT made a bad decision. In fact, I'm wondering what might have happened if he hadn't broken his leg. I liked the pick.

0 points
0
0
4EVER's picture

April 22, 2016 at 12:44 pm

Thanks Jason! I needed that trip back. Too many to mention so I'll leave saying, cheers. Go Pack! GO

0 points
0
0
HarlanHuckleby's picture

April 22, 2016 at 01:14 pm

Craig Hentrich. Punter might not be the most important position but they had a solid one in Hentrich and it would have been nice to make the investment in him.

0 points
0
0
Evan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 01:33 pm

Also see: Ryan, Jon

0 points
0
0
marpag1's picture

April 22, 2016 at 02:44 pm

How do you like Tim Masthay?

Career averages: Masthay / Ryan

Gross average........... 44.2 / 44.8
Touchback % ............ 7.4 / 9.9
% inside the 20 ........ 33.8 / 34.1
Net average ............. 40.1 / 40.1

Packer fans hugely overrate Jon Ryan. Sometimes the one that got away isn't as great as we think.

0 points
0
0
Idiot Fan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 07:13 pm

And underrate Masthay, IMO.

0 points
0
0
Evan's picture

April 22, 2016 at 08:12 pm

Stupid stats...

0 points
0
0
marpag1's picture

April 23, 2016 at 01:51 am

Which stats do you prefer?

0 points
0
0
Evan's picture

April 23, 2016 at 09:52 am

The ones that support my preconceived notions are my favorite.

0 points
0
0
marpag1's picture

April 23, 2016 at 02:58 pm

hehe.... ah, gotchya. I didn't see those listed at the ESPN webpage. ;)

0 points
0
0
mrtundra's picture

April 24, 2016 at 06:03 pm

I agree on Hentrich. His punting was stellar and he always seemed to pin the opposition inside their own 20. What an asset to have!

0 points
0
0
Point-Packer's picture

April 22, 2016 at 03:37 pm

Easy choice: Jeff Query.

0 points
0
0
Dustin Evans's picture

April 22, 2016 at 04:52 pm

What about Charles Woodson. He converted to strickly safefty when he went back to Oakland and still put up good numbers. Wish he retired as a Packer.

0 points
0
0
Tundraboy's picture

April 22, 2016 at 09:14 pm

Ted Hendricks tops the list in my mind. Great player and was only one we could say that about in those years with a straight face. After that Lofton. Both left too soon. And not because of injury.

0 points
0
0
4thand1's picture

April 23, 2016 at 08:59 am

Tundra had to scroll to the bottom to see someone get it right! That to me is #1. I was young and blew a gasket when the Packers let Hendricks get away.

0 points
0
0
Tundraboy's picture

April 23, 2016 at 09:39 pm

Yes that was absolutely rock bottom for the franchise in my lifetime. Those of us who stayed loyal after the 60s and then the dark ages remember how depressing it was to then see him get recognition as a raider.

0 points
0
0
Irish_Cheesehead's picture

April 23, 2016 at 09:15 am

I still think the Packers gave up on Andre Rison too soon after the Super Bowl season. He has several productive seasons with the Chiefs after he left. Perhaps it was due to his personality - not sure exactly how he was in the locker room at that point in his career. He sure came through for the Packers in '96, though.

0 points
0
0
hokecole's picture

April 24, 2016 at 07:26 pm

Frank Zombo. I always pull for the free agent signings that make good because most do not last more than a season or two, but Zombo has continued his career at linebacker with the Chiefs, and the Pack could have used him.

0 points
0
0