Tramon not in the bad or the ugly? He did not play well last night (though it was against Reggie Wayne for much of the night).

Other "Good" nominees- Busari Jr., Derrick Martin, Sam Shields, Tim Masthay, The O-Line, TEs, and Brandon Jackson, and Morgan Freaking Burnett.

Aaron, re-watch the protection on the Rodgers pass to Finley where he was wide open in the end zone, and tell me BJax was "bad." I know he fumbled, but his protection more than made up for it.

Forgive me if this is a dumb question, but why is Chillar in the ugly? I'm drawing a blank...

Not a good week to be named "Brandon," I guess.

has chillar ever really looked that good? i was incredibly confused when they signed him to that decent contract...i remember a few times last year when he looked terrible in coverage. isn't that supposed to be his strength? trade for a LB and make chillar a back up.

The entire Oline gets put in the good!!

I liked how physical Colledge played!

I only saw the 4th quarter. When watching Harrell my thoughts were "wow, that's the 3rd string quarterback". Considering he has only been here a short time I thought that drive was amazing.

To start the game, it appeared the defense was playing zone and lose coverge. As Capers opened up a bit the performance of the DB's improved. The way the defense went from a porus non-entity for three drives to an aggressive turnover oriented machine the rest of the game was encouraging.

Finley is definetely a candidte for the good.

I have no idea which TEs and which FBs make this team, beyond Finley and Kuhn obviously. Tough, tough cuts to be made.

AJ.. AJ.. AJ... should be the starter.. even having ankle issues this week watchin him he was still at the ball carrier as the tackle is being made... and he was in when teh colts were tryin to pass the ball to come back from behind. i did not see him get beat badly in coverage.. (mind you he saw backsups) they werent pickin him apart. he was always around the play when he was in.. did he make a lot of tackles? no.. but he is like brian urlacher in a lot of ways.. if he doesnt make the tackle he is standing right next to the play when it happens... which is important. cause if the runningback makes a play hawk is there. he needs to be our starter

I got a BIG kick out of Manning when they finally did pull him from the game. Boy did he look pissed.

Going to wear my Cheesehead TV t-shirt and drink coffee out of my Cheesehead TV coffee cup and watch it again this weekend (I taped it). Go Packers!

It's the preseason. Defense will always look bad since they are not really gameplanning. They don't really make adjustments. If this were a real game you would probably have seen Woodson on Wayne most of the night. Same goes with the Colts D. They looked bad because most of the time they wanted to just run their base and see what the players can do. Don't want to run a scheme that makes up for a players deficiencies in the preseason, because then you will have less of an idea of how good they really are.

Regarding BJax, he deserves the Bad for the fumble. His pass protection kept him out of the Ugly. You have RBs to carry the ball first, not block on pass plays

What, do all these people owe Brandon Jackson money or something? I suppose he redeemed his fumble at the 5 with his electric 2.0 yards per carry average.

who will be our 3rd down back I voted for craig lumpkin

That pass from Rodgers to Finley over the shoulder took my breath away. I thought Finley might make the good, but no go, eh?

Manning really hates the new protect the Umpire Rule. They are really cutting into his ability to get the quick plays off. I'm afraid I agree with hime. The officials looked like a bunch of stumbling fools out there. Bad rule dump it. Umpires are a dime a dozen. Just have a few spares in the equipment bag for each game.

The lack of Finley in the God, er, I mean Good, category is a joke. Seriously.... he was a man among boys.

I figured as much. Spreading the Packer love is a good thing. It's like we need a "duh, it goes without saying" category.... which could hopefully be a season long nod to: Rodgers, Woodson, Finley :)

It appears everyone is forgetting Reggie Wayne is a TOP 5 WR. The two plays he got big yardage was on a Zone play, where Manning threw over Williams and under Collins.(Not many know this because they don't understand the defense) On the other play Williams and Woodson had the call mixed up. You take away those two plays and everyone would think Williams had a nice game.
When did Al Harris become a starter? I think it was his 5th season? Give the young guys some time to adjust. With more reps I think everyone will be fine.
Fans tend to give up on the young guys too soon. It's week to week with fans. One week you like the player and the next you will find anything to knock them about. Patience is the key.
If Dallas Clark had played, Woodson would've been matched up on him most of the game.