Sorry for the extended hiatus yesterday and today. Life can sometimes intrude…
Actually, in hindsight, it’s probably for the best that I wasn’t able to post yesterday. I would not have been much better than the commenters over at JSOnline. I was truly full of bile and ready for the entire Packers organization to be burned to the ground.
I’m a BIT more level-headed today.
First of all, yes, Mike McCarthy deserves to be fired for the way his team has performed the last two weeks. However, that won’t be happening, at least not anytime soon. Mark Murphy is right when he says that a lot can happen in the next eight games. And Matt Bowen is right when he says that the team is one or two weeks away from shutting it down on McCarthy if things don’t improve.
Sorry, but I’m having a hard time believing that they will.
Here’s my biggest concern. After two weeks of his team looking thoroughly unprepared, first for a divisional showdown that could have catapulted his team back into the race for the division crown, and then against a winless team featuring a rookie coach and a 21 year old quarterback making his first professional start, McCarthy had the balls big enough to say this in a public setting:
I’ll stand by what I said yesterday after the game: if there was an error that was made leading up to this game it was probably too, too much work this week…. I felt in the fourth quarter that our energy level wasn’t what it was in the first three quarters, and that’s something that I have to take a very close look at because they had a good week of work. That’s the facts. Now, what happened on Sunday was there was a lot of production. We had a lot of production yesterday. The impact plays against us is what cost us the game, and that’s the reality of the way the game went.
This notion that the youngest team in the National Football League got pooped in the 4th quarter because their faux-Pittsburgh-tough coach was too hard on them during the week is just ridiculous. As Leroy Butler points out – they weren’t even in pads! They DID, however….go outside? Is that it? Does McCarthy think that heading outdoors equals a ‘tough practice’? Don’t answer that.
No, McCarthy has to do better than that – my fear is that he won’t. Time and time again, we’ve heard him talk about ‘cleaning things up’ and ‘getting things fixed’ only to see the same mistakes again and again. And if he’s proven one thing over his tenure it’s that nothing will change. No matter how bad it gets, he’ll keep trotting out his three and four receiver formations, leaving his over matched tackles, whoever they are this week, to the mercy of the defensive ends. He’ll refuse to pound the football, even when his team is ahead, even when the running game is actually working for a change. The list goes on and on.
I also found this response from McCarthy, when asked about the coaching staff, of particular interest:
To have a new message or a new messenger, I’m confident that’s not what our football team needs right now. They have a very loud, direct, clear message in the team meetings day in and day out. So there is no question or uncertainty of what we are asking everybody to do, coaches and players, and the accountability of what needs to be done.
Translation: My coaches are not the problem.
Oh, sure, you can make the argument that he is putting it on the entire squad, coaches and players alike. But make no mistake – McCarthy has reached the point where all the heat is on him and his staff. And after making sweeping changes on the defensive side of the ball in the offseason, it would look rather foolish to then have massive changes on offense and special teams halfway through the following season. That would pretty much indicate that McCarthy has no clue what the hell he is doing and that he will spare no one to save his job. McCarthy, to his credit, is not going down that road. Yet.
They are in the thick of the regular season, and unless you’re the Cleveland Browns, you don’t fire General Managers in the middle of the season. Coaches, however, have been known to be removed with months remaining in the season. Do I think that’s likely in Green Bay? No. But McCarthy knows he’s coaching for his job this Sunday and every week afterward until the team is eliminated from the playoffs. Then, he’ll get to meet with the man who decides his fate, Mr. Ted Thompson. You know, the guy responsible for giving McCarthy the players who apparently aren’t doing what McCarthy’s coaches are telling them to do.
And that, my fellow Packer fans, is a meeting I would LOVE to be a fly on the wall for. Because really, that’s the crux of the issue. McCarthy refuses to alter his gameplans and schemes to fit the obvious deficiencies of his roster. Is he trying to make a point to Thompson with this bit about not needing to change anything on the staff?
Speaking of the staff, watching the Broncos last night brought me back to the whole Mike Nolan/Greg Williams/Dom Capers saga that transpired this offseason. It must get Capers just a little pissed when he looks at how Denver and New Orleans went about transforming their rosters in the offseason to suit their new coordinators, while the Packers handed Capers the exact same squad that failed the year before – (oh, wait, Thompson DID give Capers Anthony Smith…then took him away) and said “Here’s Aaron Kampman at outside linebacker – have fun”. What a surprise then to see the exact same issues come to light – no pressure on the quarterback, tight ends burning the defense for touchdowns, etc etc etc. Maybe, JUST maybe – these players that Thompson loves so much, and who just needed a real, live professional defensive coordinator to expose their brilliance, just MAYBE they aren’t quite as good as Thompson thinks they are.
OK, yes, I’m ranting. And it feels good.
The truth of the matter is that, with a win this weekend, the season, and McCarthy’s career, is back on. Lose, and it’s all over but the crying. I’m betting it’s the latter, but I’m hoping, nay, praying, that I’m wrong.















